FabSwingers.com forum: The last album you listened to in full pt 19

By (user no longer on site) OP
over a year ago

Black Celebration - Depeche Mode

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

David Bowie - Station To Station

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Treasure by Cocteau Twins then Victorialand by Cocteau Twins

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *0ng0 furyMan
over a year ago

Birkenhead

easy star all stars - ziggy stardub

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Rob Zombie - Past, Present and Future, not into his music enough to buy proper albums but this "greatest hits " package is fucking banging

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *M60Couple
over a year ago

Central Scotland

Def Leppard Hysteria.

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *umalotagainMan
over a year ago

between OX26 & BH23

Killers pressure machine

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *implyJayGeeMan
over a year ago

Garthamlock

And justice for all - Metallica

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *amantha_NiteTV/TS
over a year ago

The Lake District

The KLF,The White Room.Fatastic digging this one out

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *easidersCouple
over a year ago

Wirral

Sly & The Family Stone - Fresh

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Anti Cimex - Scandinavian Jawbreaker

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site) OP
over a year ago

Brothers In Arms - Dire Straits

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *ergus1622Man
over a year ago

Dundee

Last one was the new jinjer album

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *0ng0 furyMan
over a year ago

Birkenhead

Aswad - Hulet

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site) OP
over a year ago

The Chronic - Dr. Dre

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *luemarraMan
over a year ago

Carlisle

1916: Motorhead

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *ubikslongswordMan
over a year ago

Rubiksville

At the risk of having to hand in my manliness card, starlight express 2024 cast recording

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Mudhoney- Digital Garbage

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *obyn GravesTV/TS
over a year ago

1127 walnut avenue

Is this my world.. Jerry's kids

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *imon_hydeMan
over a year ago

Wells next the sea

Victorialand by Cocteau Twins

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *0ng0 furyMan
over a year ago

Birkenhead

Pitman - It Takes A Nation of Tossers

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *nfamyMan
over a year ago

Goole

Faith no More - Angel Dust

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *eus n EuropaCouple
over a year ago

Norwich

Donna Summer The Ultimate Collection

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Lemon Jelly - Lost Horizons

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *eeliciouschaosWoman
over a year ago

London

Fugazi - Marillion

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *red and daphneCouple
over a year ago

in the middle

Jack White - No Name

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *obyn GravesTV/TS
over a year ago

1127 walnut avenue

Are we not men....Devo

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *vlizTV/TS
over a year ago

merseyside and anglesey

War of the world's,

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *onestjohn1962Man
over a year ago

Sheffield

Far side of the moon

I was at Edinburgh Planetarium during the Fringe last August

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *0ng0 furyMan
over a year ago

Birkenhead

roxy music - country life

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

"roxy music - country life"

Awesome album, love me some Roxy

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *tevenTellyCouple
over a year ago

Newmarket

Hardy - Live at Red Rocks

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *0ng0 furyMan
over a year ago

Birkenhead

yep i agree

roxy are boss

The Orb - COW/Chill out, World!

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Sinead O'Connor, Lion and the cobra.

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *iguyforcouples2025Man
over a year ago

a village close to Lincoln

Iron Maiden, Senjutsu

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *umalotagainMan
over a year ago

between OX26 & BH23

Marillion misplaced childhood

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *orksRockerMan
over a year ago

Bradford

While working yesterday...

The Temperance Movement - White Bear

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site) OP
over a year ago

The Innocents - Erasure

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *obyn GravesTV/TS
over a year ago

1127 walnut avenue

Melon...Jon cougar concentration camp

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Monster Magnet - Superjudge deluxe with a ton of bonus tracks

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *ulieAndBeefCouple
over a year ago

Manchester-ish

Monster - REM

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Kino - picture

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site) OP
over a year ago

Mob Rules - Black Sabbath

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *obyn GravesTV/TS
over a year ago

1127 walnut avenue

Chrome black gold... Chrome hoof

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

"Mob Rules - Black Sabbath "

Amazing lp, Dio rules in my world

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site) OP
over a year ago

I,Assassin - Gary Numan

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *mileyculturebelfastMan
over a year ago

belfast

Aerial salad - roi

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site) OP
over a year ago

Revenge Of The Killer Slits - The Slits

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *eeliciouschaosWoman
over a year ago

London

X’s - Cigarettes After Sex

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *olarbear73Man
over a year ago

Glasgowish

Guided By Voices - Universe Room

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *0ng0 furyMan
over a year ago

Birkenhead

Steely Dan - Gaucho

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

"And justice for all - Metallica "

Ride the Lightning- Metallica

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *alm_one4Man
over a year ago

Close To The Edge, Down Bi The River

Horns For A Halo - Elegant Weapons

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *otsossieMan
over a year ago

Hard.shoulder of the M1

Mushroom World - Krusseldorf

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site) OP
over a year ago

Upstairs At Eric's - Yazoo

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *otfun1406Man
over a year ago

Chacewater

The headless children - WASP

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *uvs2watchherCouple
over a year ago

newcastle

Sound of silence. Paul Simon but sang different by disturbed. Never expected this. Paul says its how he wanted but could never sing it xxx

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *unsexual MemelordWoman
over a year ago

Midlothian

Nightmare by Avenged Sevenfold.

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *teamynSteCouple
over a year ago

Hull

Dire Straits, Alchemy

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Darklands ... Jesus and Mary chain

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Embrace - self titled album

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Xray Specs - Conscious Consumer

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *eedsmale36Man
over a year ago

Leeds

"Black Celebration - Depeche Mode "

Good call Sarah

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *eedsmale36Man
over a year ago

Leeds

"Darklands ... Jesus and Mary chain "

Now we’re talking

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *eedsmale36Man
over a year ago

Leeds

The Forest is the path - Snow Patrol.

Anybody go see them last night in Hull?

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *art1968Man
over a year ago

stafford

[Removed by poster at 20/02/25 07:34:00]

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

2 pac All eyes on me

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *0ng0 furyMan
over a year ago

Birkenhead

King Tubby - Firehouse Revolution (King Tubbys Productions in the Digital Era 85-89)

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Chili Peppers - Freakey Styley

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *alm_one4Man
over a year ago

Close To The Edge, Down Bi The River

Somewhere In Time - Iron Maiden

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *eroLondonMan
over a year ago

Mayfair

"Wendy and Lisa" by Wendy & Lisa.

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *r_Mrs.DSCouple
over a year ago

Voldsøy

Beyonce - The Lion King: The Gift

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *tirlingMorty13Man
over a year ago

Herts / Essex borders

Live After Death

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *loria JamesTV/TS
over a year ago

Durham

Blondies Greatest Hits but I have Foo Fighters In Your Honor in the car

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

We are The Pipettes - The Pipettes

Nothing wrong with a bit of Indie - Doo wop🕺🕺

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *tlanshiaWoman
over a year ago

Chatham

Linkin Park - From Zero

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *orksRockerMan
over a year ago

Bradford

This afternoon while working

NiN - Hesitation Marks

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *007ManMan
over a year ago

Worthing

AC/DC High Voltage. Tribute to Bon Scott.

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Fleetwood mac greatest hits today

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site) OP
over a year ago

Pickled Eggs and Sherbet - The All Seeing I

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *otsossieMan
over a year ago

Hard.shoulder of the M1

"Pickled Eggs and Sherbet - The All Seeing I"

Nice choice

Mushroom World by Krusselfdorf is my current album de jour.

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *obyn GravesTV/TS
over a year ago

1127 walnut avenue

29.29 split vision... Subhumans

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *rthur30Man
over a year ago

Warrington

David Russell - The Glory of the Baroque

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Slaughter and the dogs - Do it dog style

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *55 ManMan
over a year ago

The West

Queensryche; Operation Mindcrime

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

"Queensryche; Operation Mindcrime"

Love that album, saw them do it live on the Empire tour, amazing show

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *0ng0 furyMan
over a year ago

Birkenhead

Beyond The Wizards Sleeve - Ark 1

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *imon_hydeMan
over a year ago

Wells next the sea

Faded by The Liminanas. Out today and not bad at all

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Parallel Lines - Blondie

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *allwirral995Man
over a year ago

Wirral

Sick boi - Ren

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *uchessdoeWoman
over a year ago

Northampton

Cool It Down - Yeah Yeah Yeahs

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site) OP
over a year ago

So - Peter Gabriel

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *0ng0 furyMan
over a year ago

Birkenhead

frank zappa - congress shall make no law

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *dmundwilsonMan
over a year ago

Llandudno

Horny dub Tommy mcCook.

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *mileyculturebelfastMan
over a year ago

belfast

Crass - Christ the album

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *layfull pairingCouple
over a year ago

Bristol

X Ray Spex ... Germfree adolescents

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site) OP
over a year ago

Inflammable Material - Stiff Little Fingers

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *i_alternative_coupleCouple
over a year ago

cradley

Ascendancy by Trivium

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *mileyculturebelfastMan
over a year ago

belfast

The drowns - view from the bottom

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *dmundwilsonMan
over a year ago

Llandudno

"X Ray Spex ... Germfree adolescents "

Fabulous Lp.

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *rHotNottsMan
over a year ago

Dubai & Nottingham

I’ve just done the end by Black Eyed Peas while doing housework, great album

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *aryportmanMan
over a year ago

Crosby

De La Soul. 3 Feet High and Rising

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *hrisnCarlaCouple
over a year ago

Lyndhurst

War of the worlds

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

SOAD Toxicity

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Station to Station - David Bowie

It’s a music nIght, so update incoming

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Fugazi - In on the killtaker

What a great album that is

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *rank.blackMan
over a year ago

Woolwich

Probably Era & Oliver Shanti - Looking From East

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *etitesaraTV/TS
over a year ago

rochdale

Hanoi Rocks.

Either Back to Mystery City, or Up Around The Bend.

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *adacroMan
over a year ago

Falkirk

Pornograffitti extreme

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

iron maiden - iron maiden

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *0ng0 furyMan
over a year ago

Birkenhead

Jah Division - Dub Will Tear Us Apart Again

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *upanovaMan
over a year ago

Sheffield

"Black Celebration - Depeche Mode "

Good choice

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *upanovaMan
over a year ago

Sheffield

Adele 21, I think, failing that Rumours Fleetwood Mac. I drive a lot a flip my music around on spotify

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *amRod64Man
over a year ago

Gravesend

Sad Wings of Destiny - Judas Priest

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *dfabMan
over a year ago

Dunboyne

Vista Chino - Peace

Album for lovers of Kyuss, done after Josh Homme fucked off to complete his transition to Complete Wanker.

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *dfabMan
over a year ago

Dunboyne

In total contrast to my choice above, the other album I've bought and loved recently is Gemma Hayes - Blind Faith.

Maybe 2 fillers but the rest is excellent. Woman has an amazingly ethereal voice

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Gris-Gris by Dr John

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *eic-sidneyMan
over a year ago

Leicester

Playing now

Dance - No one's watching

By Ezra collective

Gets the feet n body moving

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *dmundwilsonMan
over a year ago

Llandudno

"Gris-Gris by Dr John"

Sultry!

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *obyn GravesTV/TS
over a year ago

1127 walnut avenue

Cycledelic... Johnny moped

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site) OP
over a year ago

Dynasty - Kiss

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *mileyculturebelfastMan
over a year ago

belfast

Tim Armstrong - a poets life

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Update.

40 Years - Cock Sparrer

Oi Oi!

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *FF23Man
over a year ago

London

David Bowie- ziggy stardust and the spiders from mars

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Radiohead - The Bends

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *0ng0 furyMan
over a year ago

Birkenhead

Desmond Williams - Delights Of The Garden

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *tag and HellcatCouple
over a year ago

Notts/Derby

Black & White - Wretch 32

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *ai Hard 2 - Dai HarderMan
over a year ago

Manchester / Cardiff

Got some taste you lot!!! Definitely some classics listed 👌

My last; Placebo (self titled)

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site) OP
over a year ago

Kick - INXS

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Critical Thinking - Manic Street Preachers.

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

I loved Kyuss And early Qotsa - and Hommecwas in Screaming Trees - and then yeah …

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *anielpiercedMan
over a year ago

Bricks Are Heavy - L7 , was listening to it on a long car trip and just let it play in entirety.

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Americana by The Offspring

The Chuckle Fuckers

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *0ng0 furyMan
over a year ago

Birkenhead

Lee 'Scratch' Perry - Voodooism

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site) OP
over a year ago

Cafe Bleu - The Style Council

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *mileyculturebelfastMan
over a year ago

belfast

Nailbomb - point blank

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

"Hanoi Rocks.

Either Back to Mystery City, or Up Around The Bend."

You can't beat a bit of Hanoi

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *0ng0 furyMan
over a year ago

Birkenhead

The Brian Jonestown Massacre - Don't Get Lost

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *gf301Man
over a year ago

canterbury

Marillion. Clutching at straws

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

The Jam - The Gift (just tonight)

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Love - Forever Changes

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *echnosonic_BrummieMan
over a year ago

Willenhall

Ocean Colour Scene - Moseley Shoals.

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Johnny Cash's "new" one Life Goes On

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *inkyRebelMan
over a year ago

Swindon

Doors, the doors

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *ai Hard 2 - Dai HarderMan
over a year ago

Manchester / Cardiff

Goldie - "Timeless" (which at 30 years old this year, turns out, 'it very much is'!)

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *mileyculturebelfastMan
over a year ago

belfast

Chubby and the gang - and then there was

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site) OP
over a year ago

Lovesexy - Prince

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *ypersoonMan
over a year ago

WHITCHURCH, Shropshire

Songs For The Victorious by Knives At Sea

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

"Treasure by Cocteau Twins then Victorialand by Cocteau Twins "

Amazing singer Liz Frazer

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *TRADIVARIUS69xxxMan
over a year ago

reading

"Brothers In Arms - Dire Straits "
classic 🤯

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *rthur30Man
over a year ago

Warrington

"Love - Forever Changes"

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *rthur30Man
over a year ago

Warrington

Blood on the tracks - Bob Dylan

Spilt Milk - Jellyfish

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

‘Sunday In The Park With George’ original cast recording.

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *obyn GravesTV/TS
over a year ago

1127 walnut avenue

Sleeps holy mountain... SLEEP

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *0ng0 furyMan
over a year ago

Birkenhead

the cure - faith

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *iltshirefunmaleMan
over a year ago

Devizes

Folk songs of England - Maddy Prior and Tim Hart

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site) OP
over a year ago

Ooey, Gooey, Chewy Ka- Blooey - The Dirtbombs

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Sticky fingers the Stones

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *aughty-DMan
over a year ago

Bristol

TOOL- Lateralus

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Ray Charles genius 2

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Zero Grace, Liam Bailey

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *0ng0 furyMan
over a year ago

Birkenhead

prince - planet earth

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Appetite for Destruction- Guns n Roses

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *obyn GravesTV/TS
over a year ago

1127 walnut avenue

Attention... Septic death

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *olarbear73Man
over a year ago

Glasgowish

Manic Street Preachers - Critical Thinking

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

All Mod Cons ...... The Jam

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *ew aged adventurerMan
over a year ago

swansea

Land ... Patti Smith ...

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *obyn GravesTV/TS
over a year ago

1127 walnut avenue

Lifespan of a moth....16

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *awpleasureMan
over a year ago

Sutton Coldfield

A night at the opera

Queen

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Garbage - s/t fabulous debut lp and the single sleeves were works of art

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site) OP
over a year ago

Black & White - The Strang lers

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Dire Straits - Love over gold

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Push the Sky Away

Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *inceIlkestonMan
over a year ago

Ilkeston

"Black Celebration - Depeche Mode "

luck and grace, david gilmour

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *obyn GravesTV/TS
over a year ago

1127 walnut avenue

You are the victim...Raw power

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately

By *ndrewInEssexMan
over a year ago

Harlow

Bigger, Better, Faster, More! by 4 Non Blondes.

(closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately