FabSwingers.com mobile

Already registered?
Login here

Back to forum list
Back to Politics

NEW POLLS in lol SNP way ahead

Jump to newest
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

Now since unionists love their polls here is two but then again you wont believe them as it has the SNP way ahead

Latest @Survation Holyrood poll:

Constituency

SNP 42% (+3)

Labour 25% (-3)

Tories 25% (+1)

Liberal Democrats 6% (-1)

Other 2% (-)

List

SNP 33% (+1)

Tories 23% (+2)

Labour 23% (-1)

Green 9% (-1)

Liberal Democrats 8% (-2)

UKIP 3% (-)

Other 1% (-1

NEW: Scottish Westminster Voting Intention for @Daily_Record:

SNP 39% (+2); LAB 27% (-2); CON 24% (NC); LD 7% (NC); Other 3% (NC

Now i do prefer to see the real true figures but i thought since unionists love polls it was too good not too lmao hehehehehehehehe

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge

So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *hybloke67Man
over a year ago

ROMFORD

Polls don't always get it right do they!

How many polls in Scotland correctly predicted the SNP would lose a load of seats at the last general election?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

You see rattled a few cages already in this thread hehehehehehe

Yes polls do not show the true figure it show a sample number i prefer the the real true figure but its always good to rattle a few cages lol

Even with all the SNP bad stories the SNP are still miles ahead in the polls not working unionists might need to lie more lol

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

I dont really take any notice of polls that only use a small amount of ppl,id like to see a poll done with over 100,000 ppl taking part getting into the housing schemes,16 to 18yr olds ect then im sure the snp would be well ahead

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"You see rattled a few cages already in this thread hehehehehehe

Yes polls do not show the true figure it show a sample number i prefer the the real true figure but its always good to rattle a few cages lol

Even with all the SNP bad stories the SNP are still miles ahead in the polls not working unionists might need to lie more lol

"

Where is anyone rattled?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"I dont really take any notice of polls that only use a small amount of ppl,id like to see a poll done with over 100,000 ppl taking part getting into the housing schemes,16 to 18yr olds ect then im sure the snp would be well ahead "

Imagine the SNP won every council, every Scottish seat in Westminster, every single seat in the Scottish parliament, and every Scottish MEP seat. What would change?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"I dont really take any notice of polls that only use a small amount of ppl,id like to see a poll done with over 100,000 ppl taking part getting into the housing schemes,16 to 18yr olds ect then im sure the snp would be well ahead

Imagine the SNP won every council, every Scottish seat in Westminster, every single seat in the Scottish parliament, and every Scottish MEP seat. What would change? "

Scotland will be unionist free lol

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"I dont really take any notice of polls that only use a small amount of ppl,id like to see a poll done with over 100,000 ppl taking part getting into the housing schemes,16 to 18yr olds ect then im sure the snp would be well ahead

Imagine the SNP won every council, every Scottish seat in Westminster, every single seat in the Scottish parliament, and every Scottish MEP seat. What would change?

Scotland will be unionist free lol "

And.....?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"I dont really take any notice of polls that only use a small amount of ppl,id like to see a poll done with over 100,000 ppl taking part getting into the housing schemes,16 to 18yr olds ect then im sure the snp would be well ahead

Imagine the SNP won every council, every Scottish seat in Westminster, every single seat in the Scottish parliament, and every Scottish MEP seat. What would change?

Scotland will be unionist free lol

And.....?"

You asked i answered

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"I dont really take any notice of polls that only use a small amount of ppl,id like to see a poll done with over 100,000 ppl taking part getting into the housing schemes,16 to 18yr olds ect then im sure the snp would be well ahead

Imagine the SNP won every council, every Scottish seat in Westminster, every single seat in the Scottish parliament, and every Scottish MEP seat. What would change?

Scotland will be unionist free lol "

Lol now that would be good

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"You see rattled a few cages already in this thread hehehehehehe

Yes polls do not show the true figure it show a sample number i prefer the the real true figure but its always good to rattle a few cages lol

Even with all the SNP bad stories the SNP are still miles ahead in the polls not working unionists might need to lie more lol

"

Must admit, I still say I vote SNP in YOUGOV and other polls, but truth is, my vote for snp has been removed, as long as they continue the way they are going in Scottish politics they will no longer receive my vote.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"I dont really take any notice of polls that only use a small amount of ppl,id like to see a poll done with over 100,000 ppl taking part getting into the housing schemes,16 to 18yr olds ect then im sure the snp would be well ahead

Imagine the SNP won every council, every Scottish seat in Westminster, every single seat in the Scottish parliament, and every Scottish MEP seat. What would change?

Scotland will be unionist free lol

Lol now that would be good "

So neither of you can name 1 single policy change.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *entaur_UKMan
over a year ago

Cannock


"Now since unionists love their polls here is two but then again you wont believe them as it has the SNP way ahead

Latest @Survation Holyrood poll:

Constituency

SNP 42% (+3)

Labour 25% (-3)

Tories 25% (+1)

Liberal Democrats 6% (-1)

Other 2% (-)

List

SNP 33% (+1)

Tories 23% (+2)

Labour 23% (-1)

Green 9% (-1)

Liberal Democrats 8% (-2)

UKIP 3% (-)

Other 1% (-1

NEW: Scottish Westminster Voting Intention for @Daily_Record:

SNP 39% (+2); LAB 27% (-2); CON 24% (NC); LD 7% (NC); Other 3% (NC

Now i do prefer to see the real true figures but i thought since unionists love polls it was too good not too lmao hehehehehehehehe "

Great stuff keep up the good work in Scotland. The more Scottish seats that the SNP keep away from Labour the more likely it is the Conservatives will win the next general election.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *utandbigMan
over a year ago

Bournemouth


"Now since unionists love their polls here is two but then again you wont believe them as it has the SNP way ahead

Latest @Survation Holyrood poll:

Constituency

SNP 42% (+3)

Labour 25% (-3)

Tories 25% (+1)

Liberal Democrats 6% (-1)

Other 2% (-)

List

SNP 33% (+1)

Tories 23% (+2)

Labour 23% (-1)

Green 9% (-1)

Liberal Democrats 8% (-2)

UKIP 3% (-)

Other 1% (-1

NEW: Scottish Westminster Voting Intention for @Daily_Record:

SNP 39% (+2); LAB 27% (-2); CON 24% (NC); LD 7% (NC); Other 3% (NC

Now i do prefer to see the real true figures but i thought since unionists love polls it was too good not too lmao hehehehehehehehe

Great stuff keep up the good work in Scotland. The more Scottish seats that the SNP keep away from Labour the more likely it is the Conservatives will win the next general election. "

Not any chance of that happening

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"Now since unionists love their polls here is two but then again you wont believe them as it has the SNP way ahead

Latest @Survation Holyrood poll:

Constituency

SNP 42% (+3)

Labour 25% (-3)

Tories 25% (+1)

Liberal Democrats 6% (-1)

Other 2% (-)

List

SNP 33% (+1)

Tories 23% (+2)

Labour 23% (-1)

Green 9% (-1)

Liberal Democrats 8% (-2)

UKIP 3% (-)

Other 1% (-1

NEW: Scottish Westminster Voting Intention for @Daily_Record:

SNP 39% (+2); LAB 27% (-2); CON 24% (NC); LD 7% (NC); Other 3% (NC

Now i do prefer to see the real true figures but i thought since unionists love polls it was too good not too lmao hehehehehehehehe "

Using your own figures the snp will have more msp / mp.

Will Scotland be unionist free I doubt it as the other parties added together are much more.

Your right I do love a good poll.

When people see their wages dropping next year due to increased taxation it will be interesting to see if there is a change in boring intention! !!

After all there won't be huge rises in the services the government provide.

The tax take will go down due to spending being reduced in retail etc so guess what personal taxation will need to go up again.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Voting intention

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *uxinteriorMan
over a year ago

south west , continental

Great stuff, very good to hear The SNP are streets ahead. When are you having your referendum vote on leaving the Union? Bet it can't come quick enough as the majority obviously want it.

Then there will be the sorting out of the small print of joining that other Union, the European Union.

A truly independent Scotland then.....

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"Great stuff, very good to hear The SNP are streets ahead. When are you having your referendum vote on leaving the Union? Bet it can't come quick enough as the majority obviously want it.

Then there will be the sorting out of the small print of joining that other Union, the European Union.

A truly independent Scotland then..... "

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

11 years of SNP government in Scotland and with the sad bastards pro unionists doing everything they can to attack the SNP and put Scotland all doom and gloom and still the SNP are miles ahead lol

Must be doing something right eh

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Can I ask where this poll is published? ?

Just so I can read it

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"Can I ask where this poll is published? ?

Just so I can read it "

Survation

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Great poll - the unionist doom mongers have nothing to give Scotland . And nearly all politicians in England either don't care about Scotland or have no idea what the Scottish political scene looks like

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"11 years of SNP government in Scotland and with the sad bastards pro unionists doing everything they can to attack the SNP and put Scotland all doom and gloom and still the SNP are miles ahead lol

Must be doing something right eh

"

So the poll wouldn't change one single thing then

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"Great poll - the unionist doom mongers have nothing to give Scotland . And nearly all politicians in England either don't care about Scotland or have no idea what the Scottish political scene looks like "

How many SNP politicians know what's going on in Cambridgeshire?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ustJ0dieTV/TS
over a year ago

Burton

I'm assuming this thread is to indicate the likelihood of Indyref 2 and subsequent victory of the Yes camp?

Well saying the SNP is very popular is certainly one thing. But saying it indicates a win for Yes is another. I know for a fact that many Scottish voters hate being in the EU as much as the Union. So if the campaign for another referendum is fought on a platform of "We are doing this to stop us being forced out of the EU, which we will rejoin asap when independent", then those people will have a difficult choice to make. I'd say a victory for the nationalists is anything but certain.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"11 years of SNP government in Scotland and with the sad bastards pro unionists doing everything they can to attack the SNP and put Scotland all doom and gloom and still the SNP are miles ahead lol

Must be doing something right eh

So the poll wouldn't change one single thing then "

So you agree CLCC the SNP must be doing something right in Scotland that they have the voters trust ?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"11 years of SNP government in Scotland and with the sad bastards pro unionists doing everything they can to attack the SNP and put Scotland all doom and gloom and still the SNP are miles ahead lol

Must be doing something right eh

So the poll wouldn't change one single thing then

So you agree CLCC the SNP must be doing something right in Scotland that they have the voters trust ? "

No necessarily !!!

It depends on how the voter views the opposition as well as the standing party's popularity! !

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"I'm assuming this thread is to indicate the likelihood of Indyref 2 and subsequent victory of the Yes camp?

Well saying the SNP is very popular is certainly one thing. But saying it indicates a win for Yes is another. I know for a fact that many Scottish voters hate being in the EU as much as the Union. So if the campaign for another referendum is fought on a platform of "We are doing this to stop us being forced out of the EU, which we will rejoin asap when independent", then those people will have a difficult choice to make. I'd say a victory for the nationalists is anything but certain.

"

Nope the two polls i put up show SNP mikes ahead thats the point

I think some forgot some voters may not like independence fair enough but they vote SNP because they are sticking up for Scotlands interests

Also if you notice in that poll on the site on voting for independence its at 46% no campaign has even started yet and its not going down its on the rise and we all dont know the final brexit deal not bad eh

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"11 years of SNP government in Scotland and with the sad bastards pro unionists doing everything they can to attack the SNP and put Scotland all doom and gloom and still the SNP are miles ahead lol

Must be doing something right eh

So the poll wouldn't change one single thing then

So you agree CLCC the SNP must be doing something right in Scotland that they have the voters trust ? "

I think in the vast majority of cases that people vote for a party that they like, therefore I believe people vote SNP because they like SNP. You in the other hand Kinky, we arguing just yesterday that people vote for party X to stop Party Y winning the seat. So by your logic, people don't actually like the SNP, they just vote SNP to stop another party getting in.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"11 years of SNP government in Scotland and with the sad bastards pro unionists doing everything they can to attack the SNP and put Scotland all doom and gloom and still the SNP are miles ahead lol

Must be doing something right eh

So the poll wouldn't change one single thing then

So you agree CLCC the SNP must be doing something right in Scotland that they have the voters trust ?

No necessarily !!!

It depends on how the voter views the opposition as well as the standing party's popularity! !"

Yeah well i think after 11 years you know what Scotland think of the unionist branch offices eh ? Lol

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ustJ0dieTV/TS
over a year ago

Burton


"I'm assuming this thread is to indicate the likelihood of Indyref 2 and subsequent victory of the Yes camp?

Well saying the SNP is very popular is certainly one thing. But saying it indicates a win for Yes is another. I know for a fact that many Scottish voters hate being in the EU as much as the Union. So if the campaign for another referendum is fought on a platform of "We are doing this to stop us being forced out of the EU, which we will rejoin asap when independent", then those people will have a difficult choice to make. I'd say a victory for the nationalists is anything but certain.

Nope the two polls i put up show SNP mikes ahead thats the point

I think some forgot some voters may not like independence fair enough but they vote SNP because they are sticking up for Scotlands interests

Also if you notice in that poll on the site on voting for independence its at 46% no campaign has even started yet and its not going down its on the rise and we all dont know the final brexit deal not bad eh

"

Yes but as I said, if your voters hate the EU more than the Union, then there are already 38% of the votes in the bag should the SNP platform continue with "we will rejoin the EU".

Supporting the SNP does not necessarily mean pro-EU.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

Oh just a wee fun question lol

How many countries that have gained their independence from the UK and begged to rejoin ? Lol

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

If the SNP did get in with a substantial majority they would probably pass more socialist bills and measures, seeing as they are a socialist party, as are the vast majority of Scots voters. Has always been so since everyone had the vote.

With a strong seat in Holywood, I'd imagine they'd seek another referendum, if that had been an election pledge. If that happens, and it would be after Brexit, I can see many voters supporting a leave vote as it rises above party politics.

Should there be independence anyway, the SNP will morph into a socialist party by name anyway and the rest will still be there.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

Many people seem to forgot alot of ex Labour voters in Scotland now vote and support SNP let that sink in!!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

For a party with more seats than anyone else, midway between elections, to increase their popularity, is rather rare, especially in not one but two polls, is it not?

I don't really think anyone outside of Scotland really understands what happens there. I know from personal experience of living in three different countries over the time of the referendum, that the facts are distorted with borders, depending on the agenda of that country and opinions are decided based on that.

Live and let live, I say. If the Scots want independence, don't put up spurious arguments. ...just let them self-determine as you (the general 'You') are likely to be less well informed than they.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *entaur_UKMan
over a year ago

Cannock


"Now since unionists love their polls here is two but then again you wont believe them as it has the SNP way ahead

Latest @Survation Holyrood poll:

Constituency

SNP 42% (+3)

Labour 25% (-3)

Tories 25% (+1)

Liberal Democrats 6% (-1)

Other 2% (-)

List

SNP 33% (+1)

Tories 23% (+2)

Labour 23% (-1)

Green 9% (-1)

Liberal Democrats 8% (-2)

UKIP 3% (-)

Other 1% (-1

NEW: Scottish Westminster Voting Intention for @Daily_Record:

SNP 39% (+2); LAB 27% (-2); CON 24% (NC); LD 7% (NC); Other 3% (NC

Now i do prefer to see the real true figures but i thought since unionists love polls it was too good not too lmao hehehehehehehehe

Great stuff keep up the good work in Scotland. The more Scottish seats that the SNP keep away from Labour the more likely it is the Conservatives will win the next general election.

Not any chance of that happening "

Every chance of it happening actually. Look at the last 3 general elections SNP have taken those Scottish Labour seats away, historically the Labour party rely on Scottish seats in general elections to get a majority. While the SNP have done well over the last 3 general elections it's Labour who have suffered and the tories who have ended up with the most seats overall.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

And is that due to the individual parties themselves or the overwhelming popularity of the SNP by itself? Is it not more of a political perfect storm?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *igsteve43Man
over a year ago

derby


"You see rattled a few cages already in this thread hehehehehehe

Yes polls do not show the true figure it show a sample number i prefer the the real true figure but its always good to rattle a few cages lol

Even with all the SNP bad stories the SNP are still miles ahead in the polls not working unionists might need to lie more lol

"

You do realise that unionist parties still take over 60% of the vote in all3 of those polls so keep dreaming of independance as thats all it is a dream

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"Now since unionists love their polls here is two but then again you wont believe them as it has the SNP way ahead

Latest @Survation Holyrood poll:

Constituency

SNP 42% (+3)

Labour 25% (-3)

Tories 25% (+1)

Liberal Democrats 6% (-1)

Other 2% (-)

List

SNP 33% (+1)

Tories 23% (+2)

Labour 23% (-1)

Green 9% (-1)

Liberal Democrats 8% (-2)

UKIP 3% (-)

Other 1% (-1

NEW: Scottish Westminster Voting Intention for @Daily_Record:

SNP 39% (+2); LAB 27% (-2); CON 24% (NC); LD 7% (NC); Other 3% (NC

Now i do prefer to see the real true figures but i thought since unionists love polls it was too good not too lmao hehehehehehehehe

Great stuff keep up the good work in Scotland. The more Scottish seats that the SNP keep away from Labour the more likely it is the Conservatives will win the next general election.

Not any chance of that happening

Every chance of it happening actually. Look at the last 3 general elections SNP have taken those Scottish Labour seats away, historically the Labour party rely on Scottish seats in general elections to get a majority. While the SNP have done well over the last 3 general elections it's Labour who have suffered and the tories who have ended up with the most seats overall. "

wrong

Labour in the last two elections didnt rely on Scottish seats to get a majority they would still be out on their asses

2015 Labour got 232 add 59 scottish seats = 291 way short of the 326 needed for majorty in Westminster

2017 Labour got 262 add 59 Scottish seats = 321 still short of the majority seats needed to form a majority government blew that out the water lol

We in Scotland can see without any doubt now the unionist so called fake parties are only branches offices of their London based parties and will always take their orders from London

Ruth Davidson

Richard Leonard

Willie Rennie

Those three are only puppets taking their orders fron their masters in London Scotland has figured this out

Anyone dare to prove me wrong ?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

[Removed by poster at 01/02/18 11:56:54]

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"You see rattled a few cages already in this thread hehehehehehe

Yes polls do not show the true figure it show a sample number i prefer the the real true figure but its always good to rattle a few cages lol

Even with all the SNP bad stories the SNP are still miles ahead in the polls not working unionists might need to lie more lol

You do realise that unionist parties still take over 60% of the vote in all3 of those polls so keep dreaming of independance as thats all it is a dream"

And you do realise the question asked was ' Who would you vote for in an election? ', not 'do you want to separate from the UK?'

Believe it or not, they are not the same question.

The SNP is the party in coalition power and their ratings are increasing: ergo they must be doing something very right or the other parties something very wrong.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

Yeah and believe or not

Not everyone votes for SNP just for independence lol

The hardcore unionists would have you believe the SNP only have one policy .... " independence " and yet the dont see how daft that statement makes them look lol

So when a unionist next comes out with the SNP only have one policy ... independence line by there logic then is that the reason then SNP keep winning elections lmao!!!!!!!

You smell the hatred unionists have because SNP are getting things right and making Scotland a fairer and equal country and thats with one hand tied behind its back just imagine what can be done if Scotland were free from Westminster rule and all affairs get put back into the hands of the Scottish people and not rich gravy train asses in Westminster and in the unelected lords

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *hybloke67Man
over a year ago

ROMFORD

Has anyone on here actually been asked to a question for an opinion poll?

I've alway voted since I was 18 and have never been asked to be part of any poll.

I'm just wondering who is actually asked these questions?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *nleashedCrakenMan
over a year ago

Widnes


"Polls don't always get it right do they!

How many polls in Scotland correctly predicted the SNP would lose a load of seats at the last general election? "

Quite a few actually!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *nleashedCrakenMan
over a year ago

Widnes


"Now since unionists love their polls here is two but then again you wont believe them as it has the SNP way ahead

Latest @Survation Holyrood poll:

Constituency

SNP 42% (+3)

Labour 25% (-3)

Tories 25% (+1)

Liberal Democrats 6% (-1)

Other 2% (-)

List

SNP 33% (+1)

Tories 23% (+2)

Labour 23% (-1)

Green 9% (-1)

Liberal Democrats 8% (-2)

UKIP 3% (-)

Other 1% (-1

NEW: Scottish Westminster Voting Intention for @Daily_Record:

SNP 39% (+2); LAB 27% (-2); CON 24% (NC); LD 7% (NC); Other 3% (NC

Now i do prefer to see the real true figures but i thought since unionists love polls it was too good not too lmao hehehehehehehehe

Great stuff keep up the good work in Scotland. The more Scottish seats that the SNP keep away from Labour the more likely it is the Conservatives will win the next general election.

Not any chance of that happening "

Don't count your chickens. If Labour don't start to take a different and much clearer approach on BREXIT they won't get the anti-BREXIT bounce they got in 2017. Corbyn is not seen by all as the great savour.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *azzle DazzleCouple
over a year ago

strathaven


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. "
Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"Now since unionists love their polls here is two but then again you wont believe them as it has the SNP way ahead

Latest @Survation Holyrood poll:

Constituency

SNP 42% (+3)

Labour 25% (-3)

Tories 25% (+1)

Liberal Democrats 6% (-1)

Other 2% (-)

List

SNP 33% (+1)

Tories 23% (+2)

Labour 23% (-1)

Green 9% (-1)

Liberal Democrats 8% (-2)

UKIP 3% (-)

Other 1% (-1

NEW: Scottish Westminster Voting Intention for @Daily_Record:

SNP 39% (+2); LAB 27% (-2); CON 24% (NC); LD 7% (NC); Other 3% (NC

Now i do prefer to see the real true figures but i thought since unionists love polls it was too good not too lmao hehehehehehehehe

Great stuff keep up the good work in Scotland. The more Scottish seats that the SNP keep away from Labour the more likely it is the Conservatives will win the next general election.

Not any chance of that happening

Don't count your chickens. If Labour don't start to take a different and much clearer approach on BREXIT they won't get the anti-BREXIT bounce they got in 2017. Corbyn is not seen by all as the great savour."

Corbyn ain't winning Scotland over that's for damn sure

Hell the fanny doesn't even know you can be outside the EU and still be in the single market and he doesn't know Scotland has its own laws

He attacks the SNP on stuff like zero hour contacts and the bedroom tax

Yet in Wales were Labour are in government still have both lol

I thought Corbyn would be great for Labour instead he has been a big disappointment

He is anti trident yet as Labour leader he will not scrap it piss poor

The ring wing Labour mps still own his ass

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

One of the founding members of the Labour party Keir Hardie would be ashamed of Labour today

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????"

Good luck on getting an answer lol

No person can honestly believe if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

They know in Whitehall they need Scotland money lose it and their gravy train is gone

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

But where would the queen go on holiday?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"But where would the queen go on holiday?

"

By any luck into a council hoose and pay her own way instead of fleecing off the tax payer lol

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *hybloke67Man
over a year ago

ROMFORD

Would an independent Scotland be part of the commonwealth?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"Would an independent Scotland be part of the commonwealth? "

That would be upto the people of Scotland

The answer is i want fuck all to do with the head of state its outdated piece of shite

Couldnt give a flying fuck about unelected kings or queens its outdated and needed now a days the british empire died long ago and its the UK shame is nothing to be proud of

I would prefer Scotland to become a free republic

Where we elect people to govern us not to ruled over

The UK will come to end the youth will make sure of it

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Good luck on getting an answer lol

No person can honestly believe if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

They know in Whitehall they need Scotland money lose it and their gravy train is gone

"

You the Scottish voted to remain together. You can

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *hybloke67Man
over a year ago

ROMFORD


"Would an independent Scotland be part of the commonwealth?

That would be upto the people of Scotland

The answer is i want fuck all to do with the head of state its outdated piece of shite

Couldnt give a flying fuck about unelected kings or queens its outdated and needed now a days the british empire died long ago and its the UK shame is nothing to be proud of

I would prefer Scotland to become a free republic

Where we elect people to govern us not to ruled over

The UK will come to end the youth will make sure of it"

Didn't the people of Scotland vote to remain part of the UK?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Plus ,To be fair not so long ago we had a Scottish PM.

That was a huge pacifier I think regards the vote to remain....

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Good luck on getting an answer lol

No person can honestly believe if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

They know in Whitehall they need Scotland money lose it and their gravy train is gone

You the Scottish voted to remain together. You can "

I didnt vote to remain part of the corrupt UK

So if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Good luck on getting an answer lol

No person can honestly believe if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

They know in Whitehall they need Scotland money lose it and their gravy train is gone

You the Scottish voted to remain together. You can

I didnt vote to remain part of the corrupt UK

So if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

"

Because like alot of things they come in Cycles , and your time to rise n be a nation again will come. We are patient Cousins albeit the bigger cousin.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *hybloke67Man
over a year ago

ROMFORD


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Good luck on getting an answer lol

No person can honestly believe if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

They know in Whitehall they need Scotland money lose it and their gravy train is gone

You the Scottish voted to remain together. You can

I didnt vote to remain part of the corrupt UK

So if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

"

You said it would be up to the people of Scotland.

The people of Scotland had a vote and decided to be part of the UK.

The English did not get a vote.

The Welsh did not get a vote.

And the people of Northern Ireland did not get a vote.

The people of Scotland decided to remain part of the UK all on their own.

It's called democracy.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Good luck on getting an answer lol

No person can honestly believe if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

They know in Whitehall they need Scotland money lose it and their gravy train is gone

You the Scottish voted to remain together. You can

I didnt vote to remain part of the corrupt UK

So if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

You said it would be up to the people of Scotland.

The people of Scotland had a vote and decided to be part of the UK.

The English did not get a vote.

The Welsh did not get a vote.

And the people of Northern Ireland did not get a vote.

The people of Scotland decided to remain part of the UK all on their own.

It's called democracy."

Wrong on many levels

1. Yes Scotland voted to remain part of the UK but demcocracy is not a one off event where the question on Scottish independence can never be asked again as believe ut or not people in a democracy is allowed to change its mind lol

2. There was English , Welsh and Northen Irish people who live in Scotland did vote on Scottish independence

Those living outside of Scotland why should they get a say ? I wouldnt go poking my nose and want a vote on English independence because i dont live in England there is the big clue lol

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"I'm assuming this thread is to indicate the likelihood of Indyref 2 and subsequent victory of the Yes camp?

Well saying the SNP is very popular is certainly one thing. But saying it indicates a win for Yes is another. I know for a fact that many Scottish voters hate being in the EU as much as the Union. So if the campaign for another referendum is fought on a platform of "We are doing this to stop us being forced out of the EU, which we will rejoin asap when independent", then those people will have a difficult choice to make. I'd say a victory for the nationalists is anything but certain.

Nope the two polls i put up show SNP mikes ahead thats the point

I think some forgot some voters may not like independence fair enough but they vote SNP because they are sticking up for Scotlands interests

Also if you notice in that poll on the site on voting for independence its at 46% no campaign has even started yet and its not going down its on the rise and we all dont know the final brexit deal not bad eh

Yes but as I said, if your voters hate the EU more than the Union, then there are already 38% of the votes in the bag should the SNP platform continue with "we will rejoin the EU".

Supporting the SNP does not necessarily mean pro-EU. "

Again using the survey figures more people are gonna vote for a unionist party but the vote will be split 3 ways !!!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Good luck on getting an answer lol

No person can honestly believe if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

They know in Whitehall they need Scotland money lose it and their gravy train is gone

You the Scottish voted to remain together. You can

I didnt vote to remain part of the corrupt UK

So if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

Because like alot of things they come in Cycles , and your time to rise n be a nation again will come. We are patient Cousins albeit the bigger cousin."

Plus if you have an ailing family member you don't just cast them adrift. We are together through good and bad. The highs the lows. Pretty brutal you Nationalist. You vote to stay now you clutch at straws hoping we will cut you adrift when as you say you drain. Sounds like dark at end of your tunnel . Light at end of ours.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????"

Of course they are impotent in Westminster. Can you name one law that the SNP have passed in the house of commons?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *hybloke67Man
over a year ago

ROMFORD


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Good luck on getting an answer lol

No person can honestly believe if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

They know in Whitehall they need Scotland money lose it and their gravy train is gone

You the Scottish voted to remain together. You can

I didnt vote to remain part of the corrupt UK

So if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

You said it would be up to the people of Scotland.

The people of Scotland had a vote and decided to be part of the UK.

The English did not get a vote.

The Welsh did not get a vote.

And the people of Northern Ireland did not get a vote.

The people of Scotland decided to remain part of the UK all on their own.

It's called democracy."

So for research.

If Scotland had a vote tomorrow and decided to leave the UK.

In 4 years time would you allow there to be another vote asking the Scottish people if they wanted to rejoin the UK?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Of course they are impotent in Westminster. Can you name one law that the SNP have passed in the house of commons? "

UK parliament remember!!!

What are you trying to say CLCC ? Do you not want SNP mp's representing the Scottish people in a UK parilament ? How strange lol

Me personally i want to bring our Scottish mps back home to Edinburgh and have fuck all to do with that shit hole down in London called Westminster lol

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Good luck on getting an answer lol

No person can honestly believe if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

They know in Whitehall they need Scotland money lose it and their gravy train is gone

You the Scottish voted to remain together. You can

I didnt vote to remain part of the corrupt UK

So if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

You said it would be up to the people of Scotland.

The people of Scotland had a vote and decided to be part of the UK.

The English did not get a vote.

The Welsh did not get a vote.

And the people of Northern Ireland did not get a vote.

The people of Scotland decided to remain part of the UK all on their own.

It's called democracy.

So for research.

If Scotland had a vote tomorrow and decided to leave the UK.

In 4 years time would you allow there to be another vote asking the Scottish people if they wanted to rejoin the UK?"

First off you have to understand things

If Scotland gained independence then those unionist branch offices would have to register as an actually party not fake parties

Then when an election happens in an independent Scotland if those registered parties put forward a policy in a manifesto to unite the Kingdoms of Scotland and England again to form the UK again and win the election yes they would have a mandate for a referendum to reform the UK union how hard is that to understand ? HEHEHE

Anyway you would have a big problem with that as 300 years + ago when the treaty was signed on the act of the union to unite the Kingdoms of Scotland and England it was based on that their would be ONE PARLIAMENT for the whole of the UK

Do you think people in Scotland will be ready to hand over Holyrood for Westminster rule again ?

Anyway Tony war criminal Blair breached the act of the union back giving Scotland back its own devolved parliament

I mean i thought that was the whole point of the UK was to unite Scotland and England and create one parliament ooppsss did i really let slip ? So sorry hehehe

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *hybloke67Man
over a year ago

ROMFORD


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Good luck on getting an answer lol

No person can honestly believe if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

They know in Whitehall they need Scotland money lose it and their gravy train is gone

You the Scottish voted to remain together. You can

I didnt vote to remain part of the corrupt UK

So if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

You said it would be up to the people of Scotland.

The people of Scotland had a vote and decided to be part of the UK.

The English did not get a vote.

The Welsh did not get a vote.

And the people of Northern Ireland did not get a vote.

The people of Scotland decided to remain part of the UK all on their own.

It's called democracy.

So for research.

If Scotland had a vote tomorrow and decided to leave the UK.

In 4 years time would you allow there to be another vote asking the Scottish people if they wanted to rejoin the UK?

First off you have to understand things

If Scotland gained independence then those unionist branch offices would have to register as an actually party not fake parties

Then when an election happens in an independent Scotland if those registered parties put forward a policy in a manifesto to unite the Kingdoms of Scotland and England again to form the UK again and win the election yes they would have a mandate for a referendum to reform the UK union how hard is that to understand ? HEHEHE

Anyway you would have a big problem with that as 300 years + ago when the treaty was signed on the act of the union to unite the Kingdoms of Scotland and England it was based on that their would be ONE PARLIAMENT for the whole of the UK

Do you think people in Scotland will be ready to hand over Holyrood for Westminster rule again ?

Anyway Tony war criminal Blair breached the act of the union back giving Scotland back its own devolved parliament

I mean i thought that was the whole point of the UK was to unite Scotland and England and create one parliament ooppsss did i really let slip ? So sorry hehehe "

So your answer is no.

You wouldn't give the people of Scotland the chance to rejoin the UK.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Good luck on getting an answer lol

No person can honestly believe if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

They know in Whitehall they need Scotland money lose it and their gravy train is gone

You the Scottish voted to remain together. You can

I didnt vote to remain part of the corrupt UK

So if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

You said it would be up to the people of Scotland.

The people of Scotland had a vote and decided to be part of the UK.

The English did not get a vote.

The Welsh did not get a vote.

And the people of Northern Ireland did not get a vote.

The people of Scotland decided to remain part of the UK all on their own.

It's called democracy.

So for research.

If Scotland had a vote tomorrow and decided to leave the UK.

In 4 years time would you allow there to be another vote asking the Scottish people if they wanted to rejoin the UK?

First off you have to understand things

If Scotland gained independence then those unionist branch offices would have to register as an actually party not fake parties

Then when an election happens in an independent Scotland if those registered parties put forward a policy in a manifesto to unite the Kingdoms of Scotland and England again to form the UK again and win the election yes they would have a mandate for a referendum to reform the UK union how hard is that to understand ? HEHEHE

Anyway you would have a big problem with that as 300 years + ago when the treaty was signed on the act of the union to unite the Kingdoms of Scotland and England it was based on that their would be ONE PARLIAMENT for the whole of the UK

Do you think people in Scotland will be ready to hand over Holyrood for Westminster rule again ?

Anyway Tony war criminal Blair breached the act of the union back giving Scotland back its own devolved parliament

I mean i thought that was the whole point of the UK was to unite Scotland and England and create one parliament ooppsss did i really let slip ? So sorry hehehe

So your answer is no.

You wouldn't give the people of Scotland the chance to rejoin the UK."

Where did i say that find me where you think i said such a thing ?

Here is it more clear for you

IN an independent Scotland if those that are registered as actual parties put forward in a manifesto to rejoin the UK and they won that election to have a referendum then yes they would have a mandate for it

If they win that referendum then yes we would have to respect the wishes of the people and rejoin the UK got it now ?

strange democracy you live in hehehe

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *hybloke67Man
over a year ago

ROMFORD


"Plus ,To be fair not so long ago we had a Scottish PM.

That was a huge pacifier I think regards the vote to remain...."

Actually we had two.

Tony Blair and Gordon Brown.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"Plus ,To be fair not so long ago we had a Scottish PM.

That was a huge pacifier I think regards the vote to remain....

Actually we had two.

Tony Blair and Gordon Brown."

He kept that quiet, rather than Google it . Do tell???

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"Plus ,To be fair not so long ago we had a Scottish PM.

That was a huge pacifier I think regards the vote to remain....

Actually we had two.

Tony Blair and Gordon Brown. He kept that quiet, rather than Google it . Do tell???"

Born in Edinburgh. Curiosity got better of me. Wonder if he used his vote

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *hybloke67Man
over a year ago

ROMFORD


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Good luck on getting an answer lol

No person can honestly believe if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

They know in Whitehall they need Scotland money lose it and their gravy train is gone

You the Scottish voted to remain together. You can

I didnt vote to remain part of the corrupt UK

So if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

You said it would be up to the people of Scotland.

The people of Scotland had a vote and decided to be part of the UK.

The English did not get a vote.

The Welsh did not get a vote.

And the people of Northern Ireland did not get a vote.

The people of Scotland decided to remain part of the UK all on their own.

It's called democracy.

So for research.

If Scotland had a vote tomorrow and decided to leave the UK.

In 4 years time would you allow there to be another vote asking the Scottish people if they wanted to rejoin the UK?

First off you have to understand things

If Scotland gained independence then those unionist branch offices would have to register as an actually party not fake parties

Then when an election happens in an independent Scotland if those registered parties put forward a policy in a manifesto to unite the Kingdoms of Scotland and England again to form the UK again and win the election yes they would have a mandate for a referendum to reform the UK union how hard is that to understand ? HEHEHE

Anyway you would have a big problem with that as 300 years + ago when the treaty was signed on the act of the union to unite the Kingdoms of Scotland and England it was based on that their would be ONE PARLIAMENT for the whole of the UK

Do you think people in Scotland will be ready to hand over Holyrood for Westminster rule again ?

Anyway Tony war criminal Blair breached the act of the union back giving Scotland back its own devolved parliament

I mean i thought that was the whole point of the UK was to unite Scotland and England and create one parliament ooppsss did i really let slip ? So sorry hehehe

So your answer is no.

You wouldn't give the people of Scotland the chance to rejoin the UK.

Where did i say that find me where you think i said such a thing ?

Here is it more clear for you

IN an independent Scotland if those that are registered as actual parties put forward in a manifesto to rejoin the UK and they won that election to have a referendum then yes they would have a mandate for it

If they win that referendum then yes we would have to respect the wishes of the people and rejoin the UK got it now ?

strange democracy you live in hehehe

"

I'm not interested in that.

What I am asking is would the Prime Minister/President/Dictator or who ever would be in charge of an independent Scotland give the people of Scotland the chance to have a vote to rejoin the UK?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

OK kinky let's say this is real and SNP won and Scotland won to leave UK. Do you think SNP can manage running a similar version of NHS, DWP and also prison's let alone having free medicine and school's. If Scotland then be accepted to join the European Union how much would SNP gave to them, then you got free movement of people coming have Scotland got enough jobs for them and housing and how do the SNP manage to control them from not going in the UK.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Good luck on getting an answer lol

No person can honestly believe if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

They know in Whitehall they need Scotland money lose it and their gravy train is gone

You the Scottish voted to remain together. You can

I didnt vote to remain part of the corrupt UK

So if Scotland is such a drain on Westminster why then keep Scotland in the UK ?

You said it would be up to the people of Scotland.

The people of Scotland had a vote and decided to be part of the UK.

The English did not get a vote.

The Welsh did not get a vote.

And the people of Northern Ireland did not get a vote.

The people of Scotland decided to remain part of the UK all on their own.

It's called democracy.

So for research.

If Scotland had a vote tomorrow and decided to leave the UK.

In 4 years time would you allow there to be another vote asking the Scottish people if they wanted to rejoin the UK?

First off you have to understand things

If Scotland gained independence then those unionist branch offices would have to register as an actually party not fake parties

Then when an election happens in an independent Scotland if those registered parties put forward a policy in a manifesto to unite the Kingdoms of Scotland and England again to form the UK again and win the election yes they would have a mandate for a referendum to reform the UK union how hard is that to understand ? HEHEHE

Anyway you would have a big problem with that as 300 years + ago when the treaty was signed on the act of the union to unite the Kingdoms of Scotland and England it was based on that their would be ONE PARLIAMENT for the whole of the UK

Do you think people in Scotland will be ready to hand over Holyrood for Westminster rule again ?

Anyway Tony war criminal Blair breached the act of the union back giving Scotland back its own devolved parliament

I mean i thought that was the whole point of the UK was to unite Scotland and England and create one parliament ooppsss did i really let slip ? So sorry hehehe

So your answer is no.

You wouldn't give the people of Scotland the chance to rejoin the UK.

Where did i say that find me where you think i said such a thing ?

Here is it more clear for you

IN an independent Scotland if those that are registered as actual parties put forward in a manifesto to rejoin the UK and they won that election to have a referendum then yes they would have a mandate for it

If they win that referendum then yes we would have to respect the wishes of the people and rejoin the UK got it now ?

strange democracy you live in hehehe

I'm not interested in that.

What I am asking is would the Prime Minister/President/Dictator or who ever would be in charge of an independent Scotland give the people of Scotland the chance to have a vote to rejoin the UK?"

Now your changing your question this is what you asked

"If Scotland had a vote tomorrow and decided to leave the UK.

In 4 years time would you allow there to be another vote asking the Scottish people if they wanted to rejoin the UK?"

Lol

Helllooooooo!!!!

Whoever wins the election in an independent a has mandate to deliver their policies if a party thats registered wins the election on their manfiesto to have referendum on rejoining the UK and a yes vote is returned then yeah thats what will happen

Lmao

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Of course they are impotent in Westminster. Can you name one law that the SNP have passed in the house of commons?

UK parliament remember!!!

What are you trying to say CLCC ? Do you not want SNP mp's representing the Scottish people in a UK parilament ? How strange lol

Me personally i want to bring our Scottish mps back home to Edinburgh and have fuck all to do with that shit hole down in London called Westminster lol

"

See, you can't name a single law they have passed, you agree that they are impotent.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"OK kinky let's say this is real and SNP won and Scotland won to leave UK. Do you think SNP can manage running a similar version of NHS, DWP and also prison's let alone having free medicine and school's. If Scotland then be accepted to join the European Union how much would SNP gave to them, then you got free movement of people coming have Scotland got enough jobs for them and housing and how do the SNP manage to control them from not going in the UK."

I think there is questions somewhere in there lol

1. YES i believe the government we the people in Scotland vote for can manage ALL affairs

2. Wow so right now all reversed power at Westminster lies with Westminster not with the EU that means Westminster have power to do something about immigration but no no leave voters think my god its all the EU fault lmao

So why do you think an independent Scotland will hand over all powers to the EU ? Lol

3. You say that like freedom of movement is a bad thing NO ITS NOT!!!!! tell me where would you be with all these non UK born citizens treating you in hospitals or making your food in take aways ?

People out on an independent Scotland would be most welcome i couldnt give a flying fuck where your born you wanna call Scotland your home then your fucking Scottish to me

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Of course they are impotent in Westminster. Can you name one law that the SNP have passed in the house of commons?

UK parliament remember!!!

What are you trying to say CLCC ? Do you not want SNP mp's representing the Scottish people in a UK parilament ? How strange lol

Me personally i want to bring our Scottish mps back home to Edinburgh and have fuck all to do with that shit hole down in London called Westminster lol

See, you can't name a single law they have passed, you agree that they are impotent. "

CLCC do SNP stand in English seats ?

Answer is NO they do not!!!

So hint the SNP will never be the government at UK level

I will point this out to you

Westminster is suppose to be a UK parliament correct ? Do you not want SNP mp's who were elected by the people of Scotland to represent the Scottish people ?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"OK kinky let's say this is real and SNP won and Scotland won to leave UK. Do you think SNP can manage running a similar version of NHS, DWP and also prison's let alone having free medicine and school's. If Scotland then be accepted to join the European Union how much would SNP gave to them, then you got free movement of people coming have Scotland got enough jobs for them and housing and how do the SNP manage to control them from not going in the UK.

I think there is questions somewhere in there lol

1. YES i believe the government we the people in Scotland vote for can manage ALL affairs

2. Wow so right now all reversed power at Westminster lies with Westminster not with the EU that means Westminster have power to do something about immigration but no no leave voters think my god its all the EU fault lmao

So why do you think an independent Scotland will hand over all powers to the EU ? Lol

3. You say that like freedom of movement is a bad thing NO ITS NOT!!!!! tell me where would you be with all these non UK born citizens treating you in hospitals or making your food in take aways ?

People out on an independent Scotland would be most welcome i couldnt give a flying fuck where your born you wanna call Scotland your home then your fucking Scottish to me "

Since recently you like opinion pills.

Scotland almost mirror England's desire to reduce immigration! !

I am not saying all imigration is bad but I would love better education and training in this country to give people a chance.

Japan has a very aging population and really don't like imigration so they work around the problem.

I think we need to look outside the box on this subject !!!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Of course they are impotent in Westminster. Can you name one law that the SNP have passed in the house of commons?

UK parliament remember!!!

What are you trying to say CLCC ? Do you not want SNP mp's representing the Scottish people in a UK parilament ? How strange lol

Me personally i want to bring our Scottish mps back home to Edinburgh and have fuck all to do with that shit hole down in London called Westminster lol

See, you can't name a single law they have passed, you agree that they are impotent.

CLCC do SNP stand in English seats ?

Answer is NO they do not!!!

So hint the SNP will never be the government at UK level

I will point this out to you

Westminster is suppose to be a UK parliament correct ? Do you not want SNP mp's who were elected by the people of Scotland to represent the Scottish people ?"

So they are never going to be in government, can never pass a law, or implement a single policy. That makes them totally, and utterly, impotent!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Of course they are impotent in Westminster. Can you name one law that the SNP have passed in the house of commons?

UK parliament remember!!!

What are you trying to say CLCC ? Do you not want SNP mp's representing the Scottish people in a UK parilament ? How strange lol

Me personally i want to bring our Scottish mps back home to Edinburgh and have fuck all to do with that shit hole down in London called Westminster lol

See, you can't name a single law they have passed, you agree that they are impotent.

CLCC do SNP stand in English seats ?

Answer is NO they do not!!!

So hint the SNP will never be the government at UK level

I will point this out to you

Westminster is suppose to be a UK parliament correct ? Do you not want SNP mp's who were elected by the people of Scotland to represent the Scottish people ?

So they are never going to be in government, can never pass a law, or implement a single policy. That makes them totally, and utterly, impotent! "

Ok fucking that shite back and look at what your saying

So question is you think they are impotent is it not better to have our Scottish elected mps sent back home to Holyrood ? Lmao

Do unionists take something that doesnt make them think or something heheheehee

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

The clue is in the fucking name people

''Scottish National Party'' they are formed to look out for the best interests of the Scottish people

Is that really hard to understand? Lmao!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Its Westminster governments that seem to think they know whats best for Scotland when i can clearly tell them fuck off! No they dont

Its time to end Westminster rule!!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *abioMan
over a year ago

Newcastle and Gateshead

you do know that because of the way scottish elections work that result would basically mean that instead of having an snp majority administration, you would end up having a snp minority administraion instead....

so.... yey polls!!!!!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Isn't it good to be told what's in Scotland's interests by people who don't live in Scotland .

I bet all the people telling us what's best will be the same people who voted to leave the EU - "because they shouldn't be telling us how to run our country " - how ironic!!

The British Empire thankfully died yours ago - move on

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Of course they are impotent in Westminster. Can you name one law that the SNP have passed in the house of commons?

UK parliament remember!!!

What are you trying to say CLCC ? Do you not want SNP mp's representing the Scottish people in a UK parilament ? How strange lol

Me personally i want to bring our Scottish mps back home to Edinburgh and have fuck all to do with that shit hole down in London called Westminster lol

See, you can't name a single law they have passed, you agree that they are impotent.

CLCC do SNP stand in English seats ?

Answer is NO they do not!!!

So hint the SNP will never be the government at UK level

I will point this out to you

Westminster is suppose to be a UK parliament correct ? Do you not want SNP mp's who were elected by the people of Scotland to represent the Scottish people ?

So they are never going to be in government, can never pass a law, or implement a single policy. That makes them totally, and utterly, impotent!

Ok fucking that shite back and look at what your saying

So question is you think they are impotent is it not better to have our Scottish elected mps sent back home to Holyrood ? Lmao

Do unionists take something that doesnt make them think or something heheheehee"

You are the one who voted for an impotent party that can't make a difference. Which one of us isn't thinking?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Of course they are impotent in Westminster. Can you name one law that the SNP have passed in the house of commons?

UK parliament remember!!!

What are you trying to say CLCC ? Do you not want SNP mp's representing the Scottish people in a UK parilament ? How strange lol

Me personally i want to bring our Scottish mps back home to Edinburgh and have fuck all to do with that shit hole down in London called Westminster lol

See, you can't name a single law they have passed, you agree that they are impotent.

CLCC do SNP stand in English seats ?

Answer is NO they do not!!!

So hint the SNP will never be the government at UK level

I will point this out to you

Westminster is suppose to be a UK parliament correct ? Do you not want SNP mp's who were elected by the people of Scotland to represent the Scottish people ?

So they are never going to be in government, can never pass a law, or implement a single policy. That makes them totally, and utterly, impotent!

Ok fucking that shite back and look at what your saying

So question is you think they are impotent is it not better to have our Scottish elected mps sent back home to Holyrood ? Lmao

Do unionists take something that doesnt make them think or something heheheehee

You are the one who voted for an impotent party that can't make a difference. Which one of us isn't thinking? "

See now its starting to became really close that you seem very anti Scottish lol

What now getting at ? So people in Scotland have no right to elect a party that has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

CLCC out of interest then who do you believe has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"you do know that because of the way scottish elections work that result would basically mean that instead of having an snp majority administration, you would end up having a snp minority administraion instead....

so.... yey polls!!!!! "

Lol

Fabio shhhh don't let kinky know this !!!!!

I would pay good money to see his face after the next Holyrood elections

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"you do know that because of the way scottish elections work that result would basically mean that instead of having an snp majority administration, you would end up having a snp minority administraion instead....

so.... yey polls!!!!! "

Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

And that is your embarrassed that you think its fucking great to have people on a list vote that is not elected by the people of Scotland to get in as an MSP

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

For example who the fuck in Scotland elected

Kezia Dugdale or James Kelly Or Ana Sarwar ?

Answer is nobody did they go in as an MSP because they stood on the list vote

Anyway minority governments is not always a bad thing it forces parties to work together for the common good of the people

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Of course they are impotent in Westminster. Can you name one law that the SNP have passed in the house of commons?

UK parliament remember!!!

What are you trying to say CLCC ? Do you not want SNP mp's representing the Scottish people in a UK parilament ? How strange lol

Me personally i want to bring our Scottish mps back home to Edinburgh and have fuck all to do with that shit hole down in London called Westminster lol

See, you can't name a single law they have passed, you agree that they are impotent.

CLCC do SNP stand in English seats ?

Answer is NO they do not!!!

So hint the SNP will never be the government at UK level

I will point this out to you

Westminster is suppose to be a UK parliament correct ? Do you not want SNP mp's who were elected by the people of Scotland to represent the Scottish people ?

So they are never going to be in government, can never pass a law, or implement a single policy. That makes them totally, and utterly, impotent!

Ok fucking that shite back and look at what your saying

So question is you think they are impotent is it not better to have our Scottish elected mps sent back home to Holyrood ? Lmao

Do unionists take something that doesnt make them think or something heheheehee

You are the one who voted for an impotent party that can't make a difference. Which one of us isn't thinking?

See now its starting to became really close that you seem very anti Scottish lol

What now getting at ? So people in Scotland have no right to elect a party that has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

CLCC out of interest then who do you believe has Scotland's best interests at heart ? "

It's not anti Scottish, it's political reality. There is nothing to stop people voting for an impotent party, that's their right. It's no difference to those who vote Plaid Cymru, or most of the NI parties, Monster Raving Looney Party etc.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Of course they are impotent in Westminster. Can you name one law that the SNP have passed in the house of commons?

UK parliament remember!!!

What are you trying to say CLCC ? Do you not want SNP mp's representing the Scottish people in a UK parilament ? How strange lol

Me personally i want to bring our Scottish mps back home to Edinburgh and have fuck all to do with that shit hole down in London called Westminster lol

See, you can't name a single law they have passed, you agree that they are impotent.

CLCC do SNP stand in English seats ?

Answer is NO they do not!!!

So hint the SNP will never be the government at UK level

I will point this out to you

Westminster is suppose to be a UK parliament correct ? Do you not want SNP mp's who were elected by the people of Scotland to represent the Scottish people ?

So they are never going to be in government, can never pass a law, or implement a single policy. That makes them totally, and utterly, impotent!

Ok fucking that shite back and look at what your saying

So question is you think they are impotent is it not better to have our Scottish elected mps sent back home to Holyrood ? Lmao

Do unionists take something that doesnt make them think or something heheheehee

You are the one who voted for an impotent party that can't make a difference. Which one of us isn't thinking?

See now its starting to became really close that you seem very anti Scottish lol

What now getting at ? So people in Scotland have no right to elect a party that has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

CLCC out of interest then who do you believe has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

It's not anti Scottish, it's political reality. There is nothing to stop people voting for an impotent party, that's their right. It's no difference to those who vote Plaid Cymru, or most of the NI parties, Monster Raving Looney Party etc. "

There is that shit again i am getting accused out i will keep pointing it out now since you all thought your were being smart lol

CLCC you didnt answer my questions

CLCC out of interest then who do you believe has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Of course they are impotent in Westminster. Can you name one law that the SNP have passed in the house of commons?

UK parliament remember!!!

What are you trying to say CLCC ? Do you not want SNP mp's representing the Scottish people in a UK parilament ? How strange lol

Me personally i want to bring our Scottish mps back home to Edinburgh and have fuck all to do with that shit hole down in London called Westminster lol

See, you can't name a single law they have passed, you agree that they are impotent.

CLCC do SNP stand in English seats ?

Answer is NO they do not!!!

So hint the SNP will never be the government at UK level

I will point this out to you

Westminster is suppose to be a UK parliament correct ? Do you not want SNP mp's who were elected by the people of Scotland to represent the Scottish people ?

So they are never going to be in government, can never pass a law, or implement a single policy. That makes them totally, and utterly, impotent!

Ok fucking that shite back and look at what your saying

So question is you think they are impotent is it not better to have our Scottish elected mps sent back home to Holyrood ? Lmao

Do unionists take something that doesnt make them think or something heheheehee

You are the one who voted for an impotent party that can't make a difference. Which one of us isn't thinking?

See now its starting to became really close that you seem very anti Scottish lol

What now getting at ? So people in Scotland have no right to elect a party that has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

CLCC out of interest then who do you believe has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

It's not anti Scottish, it's political reality. There is nothing to stop people voting for an impotent party, that's their right. It's no difference to those who vote Plaid Cymru, or most of the NI parties, Monster Raving Looney Party etc.

There is that shit again i am getting accused out i will keep pointing it out now since you all thought your were being smart lol

CLCC you didnt answer my questions

CLCC out of interest then who do you believe has Scotland's best interests at heart ? "

I vote Labour.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Of course they are impotent in Westminster. Can you name one law that the SNP have passed in the house of commons?

UK parliament remember!!!

What are you trying to say CLCC ? Do you not want SNP mp's representing the Scottish people in a UK parilament ? How strange lol

Me personally i want to bring our Scottish mps back home to Edinburgh and have fuck all to do with that shit hole down in London called Westminster lol

See, you can't name a single law they have passed, you agree that they are impotent.

CLCC do SNP stand in English seats ?

Answer is NO they do not!!!

So hint the SNP will never be the government at UK level

I will point this out to you

Westminster is suppose to be a UK parliament correct ? Do you not want SNP mp's who were elected by the people of Scotland to represent the Scottish people ?

So they are never going to be in government, can never pass a law, or implement a single policy. That makes them totally, and utterly, impotent!

Ok fucking that shite back and look at what your saying

So question is you think they are impotent is it not better to have our Scottish elected mps sent back home to Holyrood ? Lmao

Do unionists take something that doesnt make them think or something heheheehee

You are the one who voted for an impotent party that can't make a difference. Which one of us isn't thinking?

See now its starting to became really close that you seem very anti Scottish lol

What now getting at ? So people in Scotland have no right to elect a party that has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

CLCC out of interest then who do you believe has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

It's not anti Scottish, it's political reality. There is nothing to stop people voting for an impotent party, that's their right. It's no difference to those who vote Plaid Cymru, or most of the NI parties, Monster Raving Looney Party etc.

There is that shit again i am getting accused out i will keep pointing it out now since you all thought your were being smart lol

CLCC you didnt answer my questions

CLCC out of interest then who do you believe has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

I vote Labour. "

So you believe Scottish Labour branch office have Scotland's best interests at heart ?

Now since down in London Corbyn is leader do you not think its piss poor that he has no clue that Scotland has its own laws ?

Also do you not think its piss poor that Corbyn attacks the SNP on stuff like the bedroom tax and zero hour contracts when the so called one Labour party their branch office in Wales where they are in government voted against scrapping zero hour contracts and wont mitigate the bedroom tax ?

Labour had its chance in Scotland 100+ and still Scotland does not have home rule

Now as a Labour man CLCC you should know the history of Labour and where it was formed and who founded the Labour party his name would be Keir Hardie good man he stood on a platform of deliver home rule for Scotland that was on of Labour big values where is that been delivered for Scotland ? hehehehehehe

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *abioMan
over a year ago

Newcastle and Gateshead

[Removed by poster at 01/02/18 16:51:33]

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *abioMan
over a year ago

Newcastle and Gateshead


"you do know that because of the way scottish elections work that result would basically mean that instead of having an snp majority administration, you would end up having a snp minority administraion instead....

so.... yey polls!!!!!

Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

And that is your embarrassed that you think its fucking great to have people on a list vote that is not elected by the people of Scotland to get in as an MSP

a couple of things....

1) if it was just based on constituencys.... you wouldn't win a majority either.....

2) you can't throw around the "blaming the way the system works" card if you have shown that you can actually get a majority under it....

3) you do realise that you are lambasting getting msp's in under list rules when about 40% of the snp msps you would have at the next election would be msp's you got because of the list.........

you really do know how to put your foot in your mouth......."

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Of course they are impotent in Westminster. Can you name one law that the SNP have passed in the house of commons?

UK parliament remember!!!

What are you trying to say CLCC ? Do you not want SNP mp's representing the Scottish people in a UK parilament ? How strange lol

Me personally i want to bring our Scottish mps back home to Edinburgh and have fuck all to do with that shit hole down in London called Westminster lol

See, you can't name a single law they have passed, you agree that they are impotent.

CLCC do SNP stand in English seats ?

Answer is NO they do not!!!

So hint the SNP will never be the government at UK level

I will point this out to you

Westminster is suppose to be a UK parliament correct ? Do you not want SNP mp's who were elected by the people of Scotland to represent the Scottish people ?

So they are never going to be in government, can never pass a law, or implement a single policy. That makes them totally, and utterly, impotent!

Ok fucking that shite back and look at what your saying

So question is you think they are impotent is it not better to have our Scottish elected mps sent back home to Holyrood ? Lmao

Do unionists take something that doesnt make them think or something heheheehee

You are the one who voted for an impotent party that can't make a difference. Which one of us isn't thinking?

See now its starting to became really close that you seem very anti Scottish lol

What now getting at ? So people in Scotland have no right to elect a party that has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

CLCC out of interest then who do you believe has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

It's not anti Scottish, it's political reality. There is nothing to stop people voting for an impotent party, that's their right. It's no difference to those who vote Plaid Cymru, or most of the NI parties, Monster Raving Looney Party etc.

There is that shit again i am getting accused out i will keep pointing it out now since you all thought your were being smart lol

CLCC you didnt answer my questions

CLCC out of interest then who do you believe has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

I vote Labour.

So you believe Scottish Labour branch office have Scotland's best interests at heart ?

Now since down in London Corbyn is leader do you not think its piss poor that he has no clue that Scotland has its own laws ?

Also do you not think its piss poor that Corbyn attacks the SNP on stuff like the bedroom tax and zero hour contracts when the so called one Labour party their branch office in Wales where they are in government voted against scrapping zero hour contracts and wont mitigate the bedroom tax ?

Labour had its chance in Scotland 100+ and still Scotland does not have home rule

Now as a Labour man CLCC you should know the history of Labour and where it was formed and who founded the Labour party his name would be Keir Hardie good man he stood on a platform of deliver home rule for Scotland that was on of Labour big values where is that been delivered for Scotland ? hehehehehehe "

I don't believe in home rule for Scotland, I believe in the union.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"you do know that because of the way scottish elections work that result would basically mean that instead of having an snp majority administration, you would end up having a snp minority administraion instead....

so.... yey polls!!!!!

Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

And that is your embarrassed that you think its fucking great to have people on a list vote that is not elected by the people of Scotland to get in as an MSP

a couple of things....

1) you can't throw around the "blaming the way the system works" card if you have shown that you can actually get a majority under it....

2) you do realise that you are lambasting getting msp's in under list rules when about 40% of the snp msps you would have at the next election would be msp's you got because of the list.........

you really do know how to put your foot in your mouth......."

Come on if am gonna get accused off people of not answering question

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

Those three with others stood on a list vote not the constituency vote

You know the way it should be the people of Scotland electing MSP not MSP getting in through the list vote

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Of course they are impotent in Westminster. Can you name one law that the SNP have passed in the house of commons?

UK parliament remember!!!

What are you trying to say CLCC ? Do you not want SNP mp's representing the Scottish people in a UK parilament ? How strange lol

Me personally i want to bring our Scottish mps back home to Edinburgh and have fuck all to do with that shit hole down in London called Westminster lol

See, you can't name a single law they have passed, you agree that they are impotent.

CLCC do SNP stand in English seats ?

Answer is NO they do not!!!

So hint the SNP will never be the government at UK level

I will point this out to you

Westminster is suppose to be a UK parliament correct ? Do you not want SNP mp's who were elected by the people of Scotland to represent the Scottish people ?

So they are never going to be in government, can never pass a law, or implement a single policy. That makes them totally, and utterly, impotent!

Ok fucking that shite back and look at what your saying

So question is you think they are impotent is it not better to have our Scottish elected mps sent back home to Holyrood ? Lmao

Do unionists take something that doesnt make them think or something heheheehee

You are the one who voted for an impotent party that can't make a difference. Which one of us isn't thinking?

See now its starting to became really close that you seem very anti Scottish lol

What now getting at ? So people in Scotland have no right to elect a party that has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

CLCC out of interest then who do you believe has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

It's not anti Scottish, it's political reality. There is nothing to stop people voting for an impotent party, that's their right. It's no difference to those who vote Plaid Cymru, or most of the NI parties, Monster Raving Looney Party etc.

There is that shit again i am getting accused out i will keep pointing it out now since you all thought your were being smart lol

CLCC you didnt answer my questions

CLCC out of interest then who do you believe has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

I vote Labour.

So you believe Scottish Labour branch office have Scotland's best interests at heart ?

Now since down in London Corbyn is leader do you not think its piss poor that he has no clue that Scotland has its own laws ?

Also do you not think its piss poor that Corbyn attacks the SNP on stuff like the bedroom tax and zero hour contracts when the so called one Labour party their branch office in Wales where they are in government voted against scrapping zero hour contracts and wont mitigate the bedroom tax ?

Labour had its chance in Scotland 100+ and still Scotland does not have home rule

Now as a Labour man CLCC you should know the history of Labour and where it was formed and who founded the Labour party his name would be Keir Hardie good man he stood on a platform of deliver home rule for Scotland that was on of Labour big values where is that been delivered for Scotland ? hehehehehehe

I don't believe in home rule for Scotland, I believe in the union. "

Wow and here you are saying you are a Labour man and yet you dont believe in one of Labour biggest values is to deliver Home Rule for Scotland

Not so much socialist eh you sound right at home with New Labour and the right wing side of the Labour party hehehe

I wonder CLCC whats your views on Keir Hardie did you think is was asshole for wanting to deliver Scotland Home Rule ? HEHEHEEHEE

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"So what? Is there a general election coming up? SNP are impotent in Westminster, and already in government in Scotland, so nothing would change. Impotent in Westminster so why are they so intent on hanging on to us?

??????

Of course they are impotent in Westminster. Can you name one law that the SNP have passed in the house of commons?

UK parliament remember!!!

What are you trying to say CLCC ? Do you not want SNP mp's representing the Scottish people in a UK parilament ? How strange lol

Me personally i want to bring our Scottish mps back home to Edinburgh and have fuck all to do with that shit hole down in London called Westminster lol

See, you can't name a single law they have passed, you agree that they are impotent.

CLCC do SNP stand in English seats ?

Answer is NO they do not!!!

So hint the SNP will never be the government at UK level

I will point this out to you

Westminster is suppose to be a UK parliament correct ? Do you not want SNP mp's who were elected by the people of Scotland to represent the Scottish people ?

So they are never going to be in government, can never pass a law, or implement a single policy. That makes them totally, and utterly, impotent!

Ok fucking that shite back and look at what your saying

So question is you think they are impotent is it not better to have our Scottish elected mps sent back home to Holyrood ? Lmao

Do unionists take something that doesnt make them think or something heheheehee

You are the one who voted for an impotent party that can't make a difference. Which one of us isn't thinking?

See now its starting to became really close that you seem very anti Scottish lol

What now getting at ? So people in Scotland have no right to elect a party that has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

CLCC out of interest then who do you believe has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

It's not anti Scottish, it's political reality. There is nothing to stop people voting for an impotent party, that's their right. It's no difference to those who vote Plaid Cymru, or most of the NI parties, Monster Raving Looney Party etc.

There is that shit again i am getting accused out i will keep pointing it out now since you all thought your were being smart lol

CLCC you didnt answer my questions

CLCC out of interest then who do you believe has Scotland's best interests at heart ?

I vote Labour.

So you believe Scottish Labour branch office have Scotland's best interests at heart ?

Now since down in London Corbyn is leader do you not think its piss poor that he has no clue that Scotland has its own laws ?

Also do you not think its piss poor that Corbyn attacks the SNP on stuff like the bedroom tax and zero hour contracts when the so called one Labour party their branch office in Wales where they are in government voted against scrapping zero hour contracts and wont mitigate the bedroom tax ?

Labour had its chance in Scotland 100+ and still Scotland does not have home rule

Now as a Labour man CLCC you should know the history of Labour and where it was formed and who founded the Labour party his name would be Keir Hardie good man he stood on a platform of deliver home rule for Scotland that was on of Labour big values where is that been delivered for Scotland ? hehehehehehe

I don't believe in home rule for Scotland, I believe in the union.

Wow and here you are saying you are a Labour man and yet you dont believe in one of Labour biggest values is to deliver Home Rule for Scotland

Not so much socialist eh you sound right at home with New Labour and the right wing side of the Labour party hehehe

I wonder CLCC whats your views on Keir Hardie did you think is was asshole for wanting to deliver Scotland Home Rule ? HEHEHEEHEE"

One what page of the last Labour manifesto did it mention home rule?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *abioMan
over a year ago

Newcastle and Gateshead


"you do know that because of the way scottish elections work that result would basically mean that instead of having an snp majority administration, you would end up having a snp minority administraion instead....

so.... yey polls!!!!!

Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

And that is your embarrassed that you think its fucking great to have people on a list vote that is not elected by the people of Scotland to get in as an MSP

a couple of things....

1) you can't throw around the "blaming the way the system works" card if you have shown that you can actually get a majority under it....

2) you do realise that you are lambasting getting msp's in under list rules when about 40% of the snp msps you would have at the next election would be msp's you got because of the list.........

you really do know how to put your foot in your mouth.......

Come on if am gonna get accused off people of not answering question

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

Those three with others stood on a list vote not the constituency vote

You know the way it should be the people of Scotland electing MSP not MSP getting in through the list vote

"

you are right.... can i add two more names for you

All the current party leaders in Scotland, including Nicola Sturgeon and Ruth Davidson, have at some time benefited from the “safety net” set-up

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

The SNP getting the UK government telt!!

This is why the SNP have the best interests of the Scottish people at heart and we in Scotland trust the SNP

''Mike Russell tells UK Government: 'If you send Brexit analysis to us we will make it public''

The SNP getting them telt in Whitehall you release the analysis to us and we will show the public what brexit will mean for Scotland and the UK

While Labour sit back and tell us no you have to accept brexit and coming out the single market fuck off Labour!!!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *abioMan
over a year ago

Newcastle and Gateshead

Sturgeon was defeated twice in the Glasgow Govan seat in 1999 and 2003 by Labour before parachuting in on the list!!!

twice i have ya know.... twice..... taking advantage of the list system!!!

shocking isn't it kinky!!!!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"you do know that because of the way scottish elections work that result would basically mean that instead of having an snp majority administration, you would end up having a snp minority administraion instead....

so.... yey polls!!!!!

Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

And that is your embarrassed that you think its fucking great to have people on a list vote that is not elected by the people of Scotland to get in as an MSP

a couple of things....

1) you can't throw around the "blaming the way the system works" card if you have shown that you can actually get a majority under it....

2) you do realise that you are lambasting getting msp's in under list rules when about 40% of the snp msps you would have at the next election would be msp's you got because of the list.........

you really do know how to put your foot in your mouth.......

Come on if am gonna get accused off people of not answering question

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

Those three with others stood on a list vote not the constituency vote

You know the way it should be the people of Scotland electing MSP not MSP getting in through the list vote

you are right.... can i add two more names for you

All the current party leaders in Scotland, including Nicola Sturgeon and Ruth Davidson, have at some time benefited from the “safety net” set-up

"

I think people can now see without a shadow of a doubt now those accusing me of not answering questions themselves are doing the that very thing hehe

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"you do know that because of the way scottish elections work that result would basically mean that instead of having an snp majority administration, you would end up having a snp minority administraion instead....

so.... yey polls!!!!!

Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

And that is your embarrassed that you think its fucking great to have people on a list vote that is not elected by the people of Scotland to get in as an MSP

a couple of things....

1) you can't throw around the "blaming the way the system works" card if you have shown that you can actually get a majority under it....

2) you do realise that you are lambasting getting msp's in under list rules when about 40% of the snp msps you would have at the next election would be msp's you got because of the list.........

you really do know how to put your foot in your mouth.......

Come on if am gonna get accused off people of not answering question

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

Those three with others stood on a list vote not the constituency vote

You know the way it should be the people of Scotland electing MSP not MSP getting in through the list vote

you are right.... can i add two more names for you

All the current party leaders in Scotland, including Nicola Sturgeon and Ruth Davidson, have at some time benefited from the “safety net” set-up

I think people can now see without a shadow of a doubt now those accusing me of not answering questions themselves are doing the that very thing hehe

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?"

1. No one

2. The electorate.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

Same poll

64.0% of 16-34 year olds back Scottish independence.

79.7% of 16-34 year olds back remaining in the EU.

Told you the youth are not dumb and is the future and they can see time is up on the UK union

Sooner or later Scotland will become independent

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"you do know that because of the way scottish elections work that result would basically mean that instead of having an snp majority administration, you would end up having a snp minority administraion instead....

so.... yey polls!!!!!

Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

And that is your embarrassed that you think its fucking great to have people on a list vote that is not elected by the people of Scotland to get in as an MSP

a couple of things....

1) you can't throw around the "blaming the way the system works" card if you have shown that you can actually get a majority under it....

2) you do realise that you are lambasting getting msp's in under list rules when about 40% of the snp msps you would have at the next election would be msp's you got because of the list.........

you really do know how to put your foot in your mouth.......

Come on if am gonna get accused off people of not answering question

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

Those three with others stood on a list vote not the constituency vote

You know the way it should be the people of Scotland electing MSP not MSP getting in through the list vote

you are right.... can i add two more names for you

All the current party leaders in Scotland, including Nicola Sturgeon and Ruth Davidson, have at some time benefited from the “safety net” set-up

I think people can now see without a shadow of a doubt now those accusing me of not answering questions themselves are doing the that very thing hehe

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

1. No one

2. The electorate. "

I feel embarrassed for you hehehehe

See people this proves people outside of Scotland have no clue on how things work lol

The electorate never voted Kezia or Kelly or Sarwar as they never stood on the constituency vote they jumped on to the safe opinion which was the list vote which the voters dont get to vote on fuck sake

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"you do know that because of the way scottish elections work that result would basically mean that instead of having an snp majority administration, you would end up having a snp minority administraion instead....

so.... yey polls!!!!!

Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

And that is your embarrassed that you think its fucking great to have people on a list vote that is not elected by the people of Scotland to get in as an MSP

a couple of things....

1) you can't throw around the "blaming the way the system works" card if you have shown that you can actually get a majority under it....

2) you do realise that you are lambasting getting msp's in under list rules when about 40% of the snp msps you would have at the next election would be msp's you got because of the list.........

you really do know how to put your foot in your mouth.......

Come on if am gonna get accused off people of not answering question

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

Those three with others stood on a list vote not the constituency vote

You know the way it should be the people of Scotland electing MSP not MSP getting in through the list vote

you are right.... can i add two more names for you

All the current party leaders in Scotland, including Nicola Sturgeon and Ruth Davidson, have at some time benefited from the “safety net” set-up

I think people can now see without a shadow of a doubt now those accusing me of not answering questions themselves are doing the that very thing hehe

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

1. No one

2. The electorate.

I feel embarrassed for you hehehehe

See people this proves people outside of Scotland have no clue on how things work lol

The electorate never voted Kezia or Kelly or Sarwar as they never stood on the constituency vote they jumped on to the safe opinion which was the list vote which the voters dont get to vote on fuck sake "

No? The voter don't get to chose which party they want to vote for on the list? Who decides then? This should be fucking good!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *abioMan
over a year ago

Newcastle and Gateshead


"

I think people can now see without a shadow of a doubt now those accusing me of not answering questions themselves are doing the that very thing hehe

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?"

1).... interesting history....

it is basically a copy of the new zealand system..... and it was was advocated and agreed by ALL the UK parties in the general devolution bills for Scotland, Wales and London....

it was actually advocated by the Smallers parties at the time such as the SNP and PC in wales because it wil reward smaller parties who would not get representation under FPTP

(if you want to call out someone who did politics as part of their degree course and wrote a paper about it then be my guest!)

2) there is a movement to say that if you don't win an constiuency ballot you should not be on the list..... but you can't call if out if your own leader has taken advantage of it TWICE.......

for the record, ruth davidson took advantage of it once, kezia dugdal took advantage of it once,

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"you do know that because of the way scottish elections work that result would basically mean that instead of having an snp majority administration, you would end up having a snp minority administraion instead....

so.... yey polls!!!!!

Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

And that is your embarrassed that you think its fucking great to have people on a list vote that is not elected by the people of Scotland to get in as an MSP

a couple of things....

1) you can't throw around the "blaming the way the system works" card if you have shown that you can actually get a majority under it....

2) you do realise that you are lambasting getting msp's in under list rules when about 40% of the snp msps you would have at the next election would be msp's you got because of the list.........

you really do know how to put your foot in your mouth.......

Come on if am gonna get accused off people of not answering question

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

Those three with others stood on a list vote not the constituency vote

You know the way it should be the people of Scotland electing MSP not MSP getting in through the list vote

you are right.... can i add two more names for you

All the current party leaders in Scotland, including Nicola Sturgeon and Ruth Davidson, have at some time benefited from the “safety net” set-up

I think people can now see without a shadow of a doubt now those accusing me of not answering questions themselves are doing the that very thing hehe

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

1. No one

2. The electorate.

I feel embarrassed for you hehehehe

See people this proves people outside of Scotland have no clue on how things work lol

The electorate never voted Kezia or Kelly or Sarwar as they never stood on the constituency vote they jumped on to the safe opinion which was the list vote which the voters dont get to vote on fuck sake

No? The voter don't get to chose which party they want to vote for on the list? Who decides then? This should be fucking good! "

Fucking hell!!!!

No one vote Kezia or Sarwar or Kelly they were on the list vote fuck sake!!!!

In the constituency vote you are voting for an individual duh!!!!!

The list vote your voting for a party/branch office

So again just to spell it out CLCC no one voted for Kezia Kelly or Sarwar you think you get it yet ?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *abioMan
over a year ago

Newcastle and Gateshead


"

The electorate never voted Kezia or Kelly or Sarwar as they never stood on the constituency vote they jumped on to the safe opinion which was the list vote which the voters dont get to vote on fuck sake "

the same people didn't vote for nicola sturgeon TWICE....... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP!

so does the same thing apply?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"you do know that because of the way scottish elections work that result would basically mean that instead of having an snp majority administration, you would end up having a snp minority administraion instead....

so.... yey polls!!!!!

Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

And that is your embarrassed that you think its fucking great to have people on a list vote that is not elected by the people of Scotland to get in as an MSP

"

The parliament was set up that way from the beginning so I'm normal conditions one party would not have a majority! !!!

Nothing to do with keeping the snp out !!!

Maybe a touch of paranoia ??

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"you do know that because of the way scottish elections work that result would basically mean that instead of having an snp majority administration, you would end up having a snp minority administraion instead....

so.... yey polls!!!!!

Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

And that is your embarrassed that you think its fucking great to have people on a list vote that is not elected by the people of Scotland to get in as an MSP

a couple of things....

1) you can't throw around the "blaming the way the system works" card if you have shown that you can actually get a majority under it....

2) you do realise that you are lambasting getting msp's in under list rules when about 40% of the snp msps you would have at the next election would be msp's you got because of the list.........

you really do know how to put your foot in your mouth.......

Come on if am gonna get accused off people of not answering question

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

Those three with others stood on a list vote not the constituency vote

You know the way it should be the people of Scotland electing MSP not MSP getting in through the list vote

you are right.... can i add two more names for you

All the current party leaders in Scotland, including Nicola Sturgeon and Ruth Davidson, have at some time benefited from the “safety net” set-up

I think people can now see without a shadow of a doubt now those accusing me of not answering questions themselves are doing the that very thing hehe

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

1. No one

2. The electorate.

I feel embarrassed for you hehehehe

See people this proves people outside of Scotland have no clue on how things work lol

The electorate never voted Kezia or Kelly or Sarwar as they never stood on the constituency vote they jumped on to the safe opinion which was the list vote which the voters dont get to vote on fuck sake

No? The voter don't get to chose which party they want to vote for on the list? Who decides then? This should be fucking good!

Fucking hell!!!!

No one vote Kezia or Sarwar or Kelly they were on the list vote fuck sake!!!!

In the constituency vote you are voting for an individual duh!!!!!

The list vote your voting for a party/branch office

So again just to spell it out CLCC no one voted for Kezia Kelly or Sarwar you think you get it yet ?

"

I know perfectly well how it works, I'm qualified to speak on it, I don't believe however that you are. So who decides how many MSPs are selected and from which lists, if not the votes of the electorate?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"you do know that because of the way scottish elections work that result would basically mean that instead of having an snp majority administration, you would end up having a snp minority administraion instead....

so.... yey polls!!!!!

Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

And that is your embarrassed that you think its fucking great to have people on a list vote that is not elected by the people of Scotland to get in as an MSP

The parliament was set up that way from the beginning so I'm normal conditions one party would not have a majority! !!!

Nothing to do with keeping the snp out !!!

Maybe a touch of paranoia ??"

Yet SNP shat all over that and got a majority in 2011 oops

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"you do know that because of the way scottish elections work that result would basically mean that instead of having an snp majority administration, you would end up having a snp minority administraion instead....

so.... yey polls!!!!!

Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

And that is your embarrassed that you think its fucking great to have people on a list vote that is not elected by the people of Scotland to get in as an MSP

a couple of things....

1) you can't throw around the "blaming the way the system works" card if you have shown that you can actually get a majority under it....

2) you do realise that you are lambasting getting msp's in under list rules when about 40% of the snp msps you would have at the next election would be msp's you got because of the list.........

you really do know how to put your foot in your mouth.......

Come on if am gonna get accused off people of not answering question

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

Those three with others stood on a list vote not the constituency vote

You know the way it should be the people of Scotland electing MSP not MSP getting in through the list vote

"

The green party that passed the snp are only list msp so I think you should be grateful !!!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"Plus ,To be fair not so long ago we had a Scottish PM.

That was a huge pacifier I think regards the vote to remain....

Actually we had two.

Tony Blair and Gordon Brown. He kept that quiet, rather than Google it . Do tell??? Born in Edinburgh. Curiosity got better of me. Wonder if he used his vote"

Did his Scottish accent not give it away?

Gordon Brown spoke for the remainder camp but is on record afterwards as saying he had been lied to about conditions of remaining and was furious he'd been used to propagate untruths.

He did say a lot of people away from independence then regretted it

And there's the crux of all this.....had it been a fair and measured election on both sides, there would not now be this rising resentment in Scotland leading to an increase in SNP popularity. No one outside of Scotland or who wasn't IN Scotland at the run up to the vote can realise this and how strongly it is felt.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

[Removed by poster at 01/02/18 17:36:25]

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"you do know that because of the way scottish elections work that result would basically mean that instead of having an snp majority administration, you would end up having a snp minority administraion instead....

so.... yey polls!!!!!

Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

And that is your embarrassed that you think its fucking great to have people on a list vote that is not elected by the people of Scotland to get in as an MSP

a couple of things....

1) you can't throw around the "blaming the way the system works" card if you have shown that you can actually get a majority under it....

2) you do realise that you are lambasting getting msp's in under list rules when about 40% of the snp msps you would have at the next election would be msp's you got because of the list.........

you really do know how to put your foot in your mouth.......

Come on if am gonna get accused off people of not answering question

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

Those three with others stood on a list vote not the constituency vote

You know the way it should be the people of Scotland electing MSP not MSP getting in through the list vote

you are right.... can i add two more names for you

All the current party leaders in Scotland, including Nicola Sturgeon and Ruth Davidson, have at some time benefited from the “safety net” set-up

I think people can now see without a shadow of a doubt now those accusing me of not answering questions themselves are doing the that very thing hehe

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

1. No one

2. The electorate.

I feel embarrassed for you hehehehe

See people this proves people outside of Scotland have no clue on how things work lol

The electorate never voted Kezia or Kelly or Sarwar as they never stood on the constituency vote they jumped on to the safe opinion which was the list vote which the voters dont get to vote on fuck sake

No? The voter don't get to chose which party they want to vote for on the list? Who decides then? This should be fucking good!

Fucking hell!!!!

No one vote Kezia or Sarwar or Kelly they were on the list vote fuck sake!!!!

In the constituency vote you are voting for an individual duh!!!!!

The list vote your voting for a party/branch office

So again just to spell it out CLCC no one voted for Kezia Kelly or Sarwar you think you get it yet ?

I know perfectly well how it works, I'm qualified to speak on it, I don't believe however that you are. So who decides how many MSPs are selected and from which lists, if not the votes of the electorate?

Ah right there is that my dick is bigger than your dick shit again

Now CLCC you got it yet

On the constituency vote your voting for an individual but Kezia , Kelly and Sarwar were not on that ballot correct ? So duh no one voted their asses!!!

They however stood on the list vote where in that ballot you are voting for the party / branch office

The party/ branch office put forward the people to sit on the list vote not the voters

Get clued up how STV works in Scotland lol"

You STILL haven't answered the question! Who picks who gets elected from the list. I say it's the voters, you say it's not, so who decides?

I am clued up on how it works, I've got the paper to prove it.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"you do know that because of the way scottish elections work that result would basically mean that instead of having an snp majority administration, you would end up having a snp minority administraion instead....

so.... yey polls!!!!!

Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

And that is your embarrassed that you think its fucking great to have people on a list vote that is not elected by the people of Scotland to get in as an MSP

a couple of things....

1) you can't throw around the "blaming the way the system works" card if you have shown that you can actually get a majority under it....

2) you do realise that you are lambasting getting msp's in under list rules when about 40% of the snp msps you would have at the next election would be msp's you got because of the list.........

you really do know how to put your foot in your mouth.......

Come on if am gonna get accused off people of not answering question

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

Those three with others stood on a list vote not the constituency vote

You know the way it should be the people of Scotland electing MSP not MSP getting in through the list vote

you are right.... can i add two more names for you

All the current party leaders in Scotland, including Nicola Sturgeon and Ruth Davidson, have at some time benefited from the “safety net” set-up

I think people can now see without a shadow of a doubt now those accusing me of not answering questions themselves are doing the that very thing hehe

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

1. No one

2. The electorate.

I feel embarrassed for you hehehehe

See people this proves people outside of Scotland have no clue on how things work lol

The electorate never voted Kezia or Kelly or Sarwar as they never stood on the constituency vote they jumped on to the safe opinion which was the list vote which the voters dont get to vote on fuck sake

No? The voter don't get to chose which party they want to vote for on the list? Who decides then? This should be fucking good!

Fucking hell!!!!

No one vote Kezia or Sarwar or Kelly they were on the list vote fuck sake!!!!

In the constituency vote you are voting for an individual duh!!!!!

The list vote your voting for a party/branch office

So again just to spell it out CLCC no one voted for Kezia Kelly or Sarwar you think you get it yet ?

I know perfectly well how it works, I'm qualified to speak on it, I don't believe however that you are. So who decides how many MSPs are selected and from which lists, if not the votes of the electorate? "

Ah right there is that my dick is bigger than your dick shit again

Oh am so qualified to speak on it and fucking no you dont count = '' my dick is bigger than your dick'' attitude

Now CLCC you got it yet

On the constituency vote your voting for an individual but Kezia , Kelly and Sarwar were not on that ballot correct ? So duh no one voted their asses!!!

They however stood on the list vote where in that ballot you are voting for the party / branch office

The party/ branch office put forward the people to sit on the list vote not the voters

Get clued up how STV works in Scotland lol

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"Great stuff, very good to hear The SNP are streets ahead. When are you having your referendum vote on leaving the Union? Bet it can't come quick enough as the majority obviously want it.

Then there will be the sorting out of the small print of joining that other Union, the European Union.

A truly independent Scotland then..... "

..

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *hybloke67Man
over a year ago

ROMFORD


"Same poll

64.0% of 16-34 year olds back Scottish independence.

79.7% of 16-34 year olds back remaining in the EU.

Told you the youth are not dumb and is the future and they can see time is up on the UK union

Sooner or later Scotland will become independent"

Thing is with polls like this is as people get older and wiser they tend to change their thinking.

You go to work, buy a house, get married and start a family.

You then weigh up what is good and what is bad.

Would being and independent Scotland be better than part of the UK?

Nobody knows for sure if it's a yes or no.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

Some people have some serious stinky attitudes on here where is the fun on this site

Where comments like '' I'm qualified to speak on it, I don't believe however that you are''

How demeaning does that sound!

It really does come across like saying Oh am so qualified to speak on it and your not shut up = '' my dick is bigger than your dick'' attitude

sinking lower and lower

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *abioMan
over a year ago

Newcastle and Gateshead


"

The electorate never voted Kezia or Kelly or Sarwar as they never stood on the constituency vote they jumped on to the safe opinion which was the list vote which the voters dont get to vote on fuck sake

the same people didn't vote for nicola sturgeon TWICE.......got defeated TWICE, once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP!

so does the same thing apply?"

oooh.... i think i have just found another question kinky wont answer...

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"you do know that because of the way scottish elections work that result would basically mean that instead of having an snp majority administration, you would end up having a snp minority administraion instead....

so.... yey polls!!!!!

Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

And that is your embarrassed that you think its fucking great to have people on a list vote that is not elected by the people of Scotland to get in as an MSP

a couple of things....

1) you can't throw around the "blaming the way the system works" card if you have shown that you can actually get a majority under it....

2) you do realise that you are lambasting getting msp's in under list rules when about 40% of the snp msps you would have at the next election would be msp's you got because of the list.........

you really do know how to put your foot in your mouth.......

Come on if am gonna get accused off people of not answering question

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

Those three with others stood on a list vote not the constituency vote

You know the way it should be the people of Scotland electing MSP not MSP getting in through the list vote

you are right.... can i add two more names for you

All the current party leaders in Scotland, including Nicola Sturgeon and Ruth Davidson, have at some time benefited from the “safety net” set-up

I think people can now see without a shadow of a doubt now those accusing me of not answering questions themselves are doing the that very thing hehe

1.Who made sure that the SNP couldnt win majorities in Holyrood who designed it that way i wonder?

2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

1. No one

2. The electorate.

I feel embarrassed for you hehehehe

See people this proves people outside of Scotland have no clue on how things work lol

The electorate never voted Kezia or Kelly or Sarwar as they never stood on the constituency vote they jumped on to the safe opinion which was the list vote which the voters dont get to vote on fuck sake

No? The voter don't get to chose which party they want to vote for on the list? Who decides then? This should be fucking good!

Fucking hell!!!!

No one vote Kezia or Sarwar or Kelly they were on the list vote fuck sake!!!!

In the constituency vote you are voting for an individual duh!!!!!

The list vote your voting for a party/branch office

So again just to spell it out CLCC no one voted for Kezia Kelly or Sarwar you think you get it yet ?

I know perfectly well how it works, I'm qualified to speak on it, I don't believe however that you are. So who decides how many MSPs are selected and from which lists, if not the votes of the electorate?

Ah right there is that my dick is bigger than your dick shit again

Now CLCC you got it yet

On the constituency vote your voting for an individual but Kezia , Kelly and Sarwar were not on that ballot correct ? So duh no one voted their asses!!!

They however stood on the list vote where in that ballot you are voting for the party / branch office

The party/ branch office put forward the people to sit on the list vote not the voters

Get clued up how STV works in Scotland lol

You STILL haven't answered the question! Who picks who gets elected from the list. I say it's the voters, you say it's not, so who decides?

I am clued up on how it works, I've got the paper to prove it. "

Come in kinky, does the PM in Westminster determine how many MSPs from the Party List get elected? Maybe the Queen? Aliens? If not the electorate, when who?

I can't believe how ignorant you are about the system used in Scotland!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"Same poll

64.0% of 16-34 year olds back Scottish independence.

79.7% of 16-34 year olds back remaining in the EU.

Told you the youth are not dumb and is the future and they can see time is up on the UK union

Sooner or later Scotland will become independent

Thing is with polls like this is as people get older and wiser they tend to change their thinking.

You go to work, buy a house, get married and start a family.

You then weigh up what is good and what is bad.

Would being and independent Scotland be better than part of the UK?

Nobody knows for sure if it's a yes or no. "

Lets twist it would an independent England be better off part of the UK ?

I mean you have the UKIP fannies telling people Scottish people are subsidy junkies and we dont pay our own way or have any revenue thats made in Scotland

So why again if Scotland such a damn drain on the rest of the UK why keep Scotland ?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *hybloke67Man
over a year ago

ROMFORD


"Same poll

64.0% of 16-34 year olds back Scottish independence.

79.7% of 16-34 year olds back remaining in the EU.

Told you the youth are not dumb and is the future and they can see time is up on the UK union

Sooner or later Scotland will become independent

Thing is with polls like this is as people get older and wiser they tend to change their thinking.

You go to work, buy a house, get married and start a family.

You then weigh up what is good and what is bad.

Would being and independent Scotland be better than part of the UK?

Nobody knows for sure if it's a yes or no.

Lets twist it would an independent England be better off part of the UK ?

I mean you have the UKIP fannies telling people Scottish people are subsidy junkies and we dont pay our own way or have any revenue thats made in Scotland

So why again if Scotland such a damn drain on the rest of the UK why keep Scotland ? "

Well apart the fact that we are one nation.

We are family, work together, live together, fight and defend together. We have a common history, goals, aims and ambition.

I really have no idea why we keep you!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge

Kinky seems to have gone all shy, bless. Maybe someone else can help us out here. I say that the electorate are the ones who vote on the Party lists, Kinky however thinks that someone other than the electorate chose the MSPs on behalf of the good people of Scotland. Which one of us is right?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"Same poll

64.0% of 16-34 year olds back Scottish independence.

79.7% of 16-34 year olds back remaining in the EU.

Told you the youth are not dumb and is the future and they can see time is up on the UK union

Sooner or later Scotland will become independent

Thing is with polls like this is as people get older and wiser they tend to change their thinking.

You go to work, buy a house, get married and start a family.

You then weigh up what is good and what is bad.

Would being and independent Scotland be better than part of the UK?

Nobody knows for sure if it's a yes or no.

Lets twist it would an independent England be better off part of the UK ?

I mean you have the UKIP fannies telling people Scottish people are subsidy junkies and we dont pay our own way or have any revenue thats made in Scotland

So why again if Scotland such a damn drain on the rest of the UK why keep Scotland ?

Well apart the fact that we are one nation.

We are family, work together, live together, fight and defend together. We have a common history, goals, aims and ambition.

I really have no idea why we keep you!"

For fuck sake unionists need to shake themselves and come up one side thing

So now the UK is one nation and there is not 4 nations in the UK ? MAake your fucking mind up lol

Yeah history like the British empire you proud of that history ? hehehe

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"Same poll

64.0% of 16-34 year olds back Scottish independence.

79.7% of 16-34 year olds back remaining in the EU.

Told you the youth are not dumb and is the future and they can see time is up on the UK union

Sooner or later Scotland will become independent

Thing is with polls like this is as people get older and wiser they tend to change their thinking.

You go to work, buy a house, get married and start a family.

You then weigh up what is good and what is bad.

Would being and independent Scotland be better than part of the UK?

Nobody knows for sure if it's a yes or no.

Lets twist it would an independent England be better off part of the UK ?

I mean you have the UKIP fannies telling people Scottish people are subsidy junkies and we dont pay our own way or have any revenue thats made in Scotland

So why again if Scotland such a damn drain on the rest of the UK why keep Scotland ?

Well apart the fact that we are one nation.

We are family, work together, live together, fight and defend together. We have a common history, goals, aims and ambition.

I really have no idea why we keep you!

For fuck sake unionists need to shake themselves and come up one side thing

So now the UK is one nation and there is not 4 nations in the UK ? MAake your fucking mind up lol

Yeah history like the British empire you proud of that history ? hehehe"

If the UK is 4 countries, then give us your definition of a country

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

Ok lets test it eh who in here thinks i am right on the way Holyrood votes ie

''Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

OR CLCC

''Kinky seems to have gone all shy, bless. Maybe someone else can help us out here. I say that the electorate are the ones who vote on the Party lists, Kinky however thinks that someone other than the electorate chose the MSPs on behalf of the good people of Scotland. Which one of us is right?''

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *abioMan
over a year ago

Newcastle and Gateshead


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

"

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!"

But who voted for the SNP on the Party List? Kinky says it wasn't the electorate, so who was it?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"Same poll

64.0% of 16-34 year olds back Scottish independence.

79.7% of 16-34 year olds back remaining in the EU.

Told you the youth are not dumb and is the future and they can see time is up on the UK union

Sooner or later Scotland will become independent

Thing is with polls like this is as people get older and wiser they tend to change their thinking.

You go to work, buy a house, get married and start a family.

You then weigh up what is good and what is bad.

Would being and independent Scotland be better than part of the UK?

Nobody knows for sure if it's a yes or no.

Lets twist it would an independent England be better off part of the UK ?

I mean you have the UKIP fannies telling people Scottish people are subsidy junkies and we dont pay our own way or have any revenue thats made in Scotland

So why again if Scotland such a damn drain on the rest of the UK why keep Scotland ? "

Going by your favourite poll we have ukip fannies in Scotland! !!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *hybloke67Man
over a year ago

ROMFORD


"Same poll

64.0% of 16-34 year olds back Scottish independence.

79.7% of 16-34 year olds back remaining in the EU.

Told you the youth are not dumb and is the future and they can see time is up on the UK union

Sooner or later Scotland will become independent

Thing is with polls like this is as people get older and wiser they tend to change their thinking.

You go to work, buy a house, get married and start a family.

You then weigh up what is good and what is bad.

Would being and independent Scotland be better than part of the UK?

Nobody knows for sure if it's a yes or no.

Lets twist it would an independent England be better off part of the UK ?

I mean you have the UKIP fannies telling people Scottish people are subsidy junkies and we dont pay our own way or have any revenue thats made in Scotland

So why again if Scotland such a damn drain on the rest of the UK why keep Scotland ?

Well apart the fact that we are one nation.

We are family, work together, live together, fight and defend together. We have a common history, goals, aims and ambition.

I really have no idea why we keep you!

For fuck sake unionists need to shake themselves and come up one side thing

So now the UK is one nation and there is not 4 nations in the UK ? MAake your fucking mind up lol

Yeah history like the British empire you proud of that history ? hehehe"

I'm not ashamed of the British Empire what so ever.

That's who we are.

Even if Scotland was to become Independent your history would show you were part of the British Empire.

That is unless the SNP decide to change all the history books in Scotland!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"Same poll

64.0% of 16-34 year olds back Scottish independence.

79.7% of 16-34 year olds back remaining in the EU.

Told you the youth are not dumb and is the future and they can see time is up on the UK union

Sooner or later Scotland will become independent

Thing is with polls like this is as people get older and wiser they tend to change their thinking.

You go to work, buy a house, get married and start a family.

You then weigh up what is good and what is bad.

Would being and independent Scotland be better than part of the UK?

Nobody knows for sure if it's a yes or no.

Lets twist it would an independent England be better off part of the UK ?

I mean you have the UKIP fannies telling people Scottish people are subsidy junkies and we dont pay our own way or have any revenue thats made in Scotland

So why again if Scotland such a damn drain on the rest of the UK why keep Scotland ?

Well apart the fact that we are one nation.

We are family, work together, live together, fight and defend together. We have a common history, goals, aims and ambition.

I really have no idea why we keep you!

For fuck sake unionists need to shake themselves and come up one side thing

So now the UK is one nation and there is not 4 nations in the UK ? MAake your fucking mind up lol

Yeah history like the British empire you proud of that history ? hehehe

I'm not ashamed of the British Empire what so ever.

That's who we are.

Even if Scotland was to become Independent your history would show you were part of the British Empire.

That is unless the SNP decide to change all the history books in Scotland!"

Wow just fucking wow i have seen it all know the true colours of the hardcore yoons come out

So the british empire that apart of that history is Slavery and that is something to be proud of how ?

I am ashamed of the british empire

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge

So kinky can't define a country, and doesn't know who votes for the Party lists. Obviously they have never used their single transferable vote!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

Anyone else proud of the british empire ?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

CLCC am actually still waiting on you telling me who in Scotland voted for Kezia Dugdale ? James Kelly or Anas Sarwar on the regional / list vote ?

Side note i may not agree with Sarwar on alot of stuff but what he has had said about him from a fellow Labour member is shocking good to see Scottish Labour branch suspend that dickhead racist bastard! No need for it

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *hybloke67Man
over a year ago

ROMFORD


"Same poll

64.0% of 16-34 year olds back Scottish independence.

79.7% of 16-34 year olds back remaining in the EU.

Told you the youth are not dumb and is the future and they can see time is up on the UK union

Sooner or later Scotland will become independent

Thing is with polls like this is as people get older and wiser they tend to change their thinking.

You go to work, buy a house, get married and start a family.

You then weigh up what is good and what is bad.

Would being and independent Scotland be better than part of the UK?

Nobody knows for sure if it's a yes or no.

Lets twist it would an independent England be better off part of the UK ?

I mean you have the UKIP fannies telling people Scottish people are subsidy junkies and we dont pay our own way or have any revenue thats made in Scotland

So why again if Scotland such a damn drain on the rest of the UK why keep Scotland ?

Well apart the fact that we are one nation.

We are family, work together, live together, fight and defend together. We have a common history, goals, aims and ambition.

I really have no idea why we keep you!

For fuck sake unionists need to shake themselves and come up one side thing

So now the UK is one nation and there is not 4 nations in the UK ? MAake your fucking mind up lol

Yeah history like the British empire you proud of that history ? hehehe

I'm not ashamed of the British Empire what so ever.

That's who we are.

Even if Scotland was to become Independent your history would show you were part of the British Empire.

That is unless the SNP decide to change all the history books in Scotland!

Wow just fucking wow i have seen it all know the true colours of the hardcore yoons come out

So the british empire that apart of that history is Slavery and that is something to be proud of how ?

I am ashamed of the british empire "

Well the British Empire didn't invent slavery but were the first big nation to end it.

The Royal Navy patrolled the waters off Africa to release slaves.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"Same poll

64.0% of 16-34 year olds back Scottish independence.

79.7% of 16-34 year olds back remaining in the EU.

Told you the youth are not dumb and is the future and they can see time is up on the UK union

Sooner or later Scotland will become independent

Thing is with polls like this is as people get older and wiser they tend to change their thinking.

You go to work, buy a house, get married and start a family.

You then weigh up what is good and what is bad.

Would being and independent Scotland be better than part of the UK?

Nobody knows for sure if it's a yes or no.

Lets twist it would an independent England be better off part of the UK ?

I mean you have the UKIP fannies telling people Scottish people are subsidy junkies and we dont pay our own way or have any revenue thats made in Scotland

So why again if Scotland such a damn drain on the rest of the UK why keep Scotland ?

Well apart the fact that we are one nation.

We are family, work together, live together, fight and defend together. We have a common history, goals, aims and ambition.

I really have no idea why we keep you!

For fuck sake unionists need to shake themselves and come up one side thing

So now the UK is one nation and there is not 4 nations in the UK ? MAake your fucking mind up lol

Yeah history like the British empire you proud of that history ? hehehe

I'm not ashamed of the British Empire what so ever.

That's who we are.

Even if Scotland was to become Independent your history would show you were part of the British Empire.

That is unless the SNP decide to change all the history books in Scotland!

Wow just fucking wow i have seen it all know the true colours of the hardcore yoons come out

So the british empire that apart of that history is Slavery and that is something to be proud of how ?

I am ashamed of the british empire

Well the British Empire didn't invent slavery but were the first big nation to end it.

The Royal Navy patrolled the waters off Africa to release slaves.

"

Ah quick detour there

So do you still stand by this statement then '' I'm not ashamed of the British Empire what so ever''

Or are you ashamed now of the British empire ?

I will be clear it makes me sick to think we were ever part of slavery

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *hybloke67Man
over a year ago

ROMFORD


"Same poll

64.0% of 16-34 year olds back Scottish independence.

79.7% of 16-34 year olds back remaining in the EU.

Told you the youth are not dumb and is the future and they can see time is up on the UK union

Sooner or later Scotland will become independent

Thing is with polls like this is as people get older and wiser they tend to change their thinking.

You go to work, buy a house, get married and start a family.

You then weigh up what is good and what is bad.

Would being and independent Scotland be better than part of the UK?

Nobody knows for sure if it's a yes or no.

Lets twist it would an independent England be better off part of the UK ?

I mean you have the UKIP fannies telling people Scottish people are subsidy junkies and we dont pay our own way or have any revenue thats made in Scotland

So why again if Scotland such a damn drain on the rest of the UK why keep Scotland ?

Well apart the fact that we are one nation.

We are family, work together, live together, fight and defend together. We have a common history, goals, aims and ambition.

I really have no idea why we keep you!

For fuck sake unionists need to shake themselves and come up one side thing

So now the UK is one nation and there is not 4 nations in the UK ? MAake your fucking mind up lol

Yeah history like the British empire you proud of that history ? hehehe

I'm not ashamed of the British Empire what so ever.

That's who we are.

Even if Scotland was to become Independent your history would show you were part of the British Empire.

That is unless the SNP decide to change all the history books in Scotland!

Wow just fucking wow i have seen it all know the true colours of the hardcore yoons come out

So the british empire that apart of that history is Slavery and that is something to be proud of how ?

I am ashamed of the british empire

Well the British Empire didn't invent slavery but were the first big nation to end it.

The Royal Navy patrolled the waters off Africa to release slaves.

Ah quick detour there

So do you still stand by this statement then '' I'm not ashamed of the British Empire what so ever''

Or are you ashamed now of the British empire ?

I will be clear it makes me sick to think we were ever part of slavery "

Are you ashamed the British Empire helped bring an end to slavery?

I am most certainly not.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"Same poll

64.0% of 16-34 year olds back Scottish independence.

79.7% of 16-34 year olds back remaining in the EU.

Told you the youth are not dumb and is the future and they can see time is up on the UK union

Sooner or later Scotland will become independent

Thing is with polls like this is as people get older and wiser they tend to change their thinking.

You go to work, buy a house, get married and start a family.

You then weigh up what is good and what is bad.

Would being and independent Scotland be better than part of the UK?

Nobody knows for sure if it's a yes or no.

Lets twist it would an independent England be better off part of the UK ?

I mean you have the UKIP fannies telling people Scottish people are subsidy junkies and we dont pay our own way or have any revenue thats made in Scotland

So why again if Scotland such a damn drain on the rest of the UK why keep Scotland ?

Well apart the fact that we are one nation.

We are family, work together, live together, fight and defend together. We have a common history, goals, aims and ambition.

I really have no idea why we keep you!

For fuck sake unionists need to shake themselves and come up one side thing

So now the UK is one nation and there is not 4 nations in the UK ? MAake your fucking mind up lol

Yeah history like the British empire you proud of that history ? hehehe

I'm not ashamed of the British Empire what so ever.

That's who we are.

Even if Scotland was to become Independent your history would show you were part of the British Empire.

That is unless the SNP decide to change all the history books in Scotland!

Wow just fucking wow i have seen it all know the true colours of the hardcore yoons come out

So the british empire that apart of that history is Slavery and that is something to be proud of how ?

I am ashamed of the british empire

Well the British Empire didn't invent slavery but were the first big nation to end it.

The Royal Navy patrolled the waters off Africa to release slaves.

Ah quick detour there

So do you still stand by this statement then '' I'm not ashamed of the British Empire what so ever''

Or are you ashamed now of the British empire ?

I will be clear it makes me sick to think we were ever part of slavery

Are you ashamed the British Empire helped bring an end to slavery?

I am most certainly not."

No no dont shit out the question

Are you ashamed of the british empire thats history involved slavery ? Makes me sick how about you ?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"CLCC am actually still waiting on you telling me who in Scotland voted for Kezia Dugdale ? James Kelly or Anas Sarwar on the regional / list vote ?

Side note i may not agree with Sarwar on alot of stuff but what he has had said about him from a fellow Labour member is shocking good to see Scottish Labour branch suspend that dickhead racist bastard! No need for it

"

435,919 people.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"CLCC am actually still waiting on you telling me who in Scotland voted for Kezia Dugdale ? James Kelly or Anas Sarwar on the regional / list vote ?

Side note i may not agree with Sarwar on alot of stuff but what he has had said about him from a fellow Labour member is shocking good to see Scottish Labour branch suspend that dickhead racist bastard! No need for it

435,919 people. "

Oh my

CLCC on the regional /list vote you do NOT vote for individual's

On the 2nd ballot which is the regional/list vote you vote for the parties/branch offices

I repeat you do NOT for for individual'son the list vote!! lol

That CLCC means no one in the constituency of Kezia Dugdale or James Kelly or Anas Sarwar voted them in

They are an MSP through the list vote which divides the transferable votes

They were not elected by the people in the constituency they were rejected at the ballot box

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"CLCC am actually still waiting on you telling me who in Scotland voted for Kezia Dugdale ? James Kelly or Anas Sarwar on the regional / list vote ?

Side note i may not agree with Sarwar on alot of stuff but what he has had said about him from a fellow Labour member is shocking good to see Scottish Labour branch suspend that dickhead racist bastard! No need for it

435,919 people.

Oh my

CLCC on the regional /list vote you do NOT vote for individual's

On the 2nd ballot which is the regional/list vote you vote for the parties/branch offices

I repeat you do NOT for for individual'son the list vote!! lol

That CLCC means no one in the constituency of Kezia Dugdale or James Kelly or Anas Sarwar voted them in

They are an MSP through the list vote which divides the transferable votes

They were not elected by the people in the constituency they were rejected at the ballot box "

430,000 people voted for them!

How are the people on the list elected if people don't vote for them?!?!?!!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *abioMan
over a year ago

Newcastle and Gateshead


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!"

fancy answering this since you were the person who brought up the topic of the msp lists?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!

fancy answering this since you were the person who brought up the topic of the msp lists? "

Fabio, do you fancy telling kinky that it is your regular, average, everyday voter who decides which party they give their single transferable vote to?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!

fancy answering this since you were the person who brought up the topic of the msp lists?

Fabio, do you fancy telling kinky that it is your regular, average, everyday voter who decides which party they give their single transferable vote to? "

I am sure Fabio will be more than happy to tell you that in the Holyrood election on regional votes you do not vote for individuals you vote for parties/ branch offices lol

Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!

fancy answering this since you were the person who brought up the topic of the msp lists?

Fabio, do you fancy telling kinky that it is your regular, average, everyday voter who decides which party they give their single transferable vote to?

I am sure Fabio will be more than happy to tell you that in the Holyrood election on regional votes you do not vote for individuals you vote for parties/ branch offices lol

Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe "

Not one single person has said that you vote for individual on the STV. BUT you have said that the electorate don't vote for the list. So if it's not the electorate, THEN WHO THE FUCK VOTES FOR THEM?!?!?!?!?!??!?!!?!!!!!!!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *mmabluTV/TS
over a year ago

upton wirral


"I dont really take any notice of polls that only use a small amount of ppl,id like to see a poll done with over 100,000 ppl taking part getting into the housing schemes,16 to 18yr olds ect then im sure the snp would be well ahead

Imagine the SNP won every council, every Scottish seat in Westminster, every single seat in the Scottish parliament, and every Scottish MEP seat. What would change? "

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!

fancy answering this since you were the person who brought up the topic of the msp lists?

Fabio, do you fancy telling kinky that it is your regular, average, everyday voter who decides which party they give their single transferable vote to?

I am sure Fabio will be more than happy to tell you that in the Holyrood election on regional votes you do not vote for individuals you vote for parties/ branch offices lol

Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe

Not one single person has said that you vote for individual on the STV. BUT you have said that the electorate don't vote for the list. So if it's not the electorate, THEN WHO THE FUCK VOTES FOR THEM?!?!?!?!?!??!?!!?!!!!!!!"

Haw stop shouting first off

I asked this remember ? ''Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ? ''

You answered the electorate that is not true!!!! stop misleading people

None voted Kezia or Sarwar or Kelly to be an MSP fact!!!!

On the regional / list vote you vote for the party / branch office you dont vote for candidates on that ballot

So again Kezia didnt get elected by the voters fact!!!

ON the regional vote it gets divided up and each time it gets transferred so the next one gets on the list as MSP but people didnt vote for the likes of Kezia all they did was vote Scottish Labour branch how fucking hard is that to understand ?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *abioMan
over a year ago

Newcastle and Gateshead


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!

fancy answering this since you were the person who brought up the topic of the msp lists?

Fabio, do you fancy telling kinky that it is your regular, average, everyday voter who decides which party they give their single transferable vote to?

I am sure Fabio will be more than happy to tell you that in the Holyrood election on regional votes you do not vote for individuals you vote for parties/ branch offices lol

Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe "

yes she wasn't......

nicola sturgeon wasn't elected by constituency TWICE, by the public vote TWICE... and on one of those occasions she also happened to be the deputy leader of the snp.. and on both those occasions, she was rescued by being on the regional list.....

so again...... and want to take a stab on actually answering the question...

if you are knocking people in labour for doing it.... should you not be knocking sturgeon for doing in effect taking a double stab and getting in exactly the same way?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!

fancy answering this since you were the person who brought up the topic of the msp lists?

Fabio, do you fancy telling kinky that it is your regular, average, everyday voter who decides which party they give their single transferable vote to?

I am sure Fabio will be more than happy to tell you that in the Holyrood election on regional votes you do not vote for individuals you vote for parties/ branch offices lol

Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe

Not one single person has said that you vote for individual on the STV. BUT you have said that the electorate don't vote for the list. So if it's not the electorate, THEN WHO THE FUCK VOTES FOR THEM?!?!?!?!?!??!?!!?!!!!!!!

Haw stop shouting first off

I asked this remember ? ''Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ? ''

You answered the electorate that is not true!!!! stop misleading people

None voted Kezia or Sarwar or Kelly to be an MSP fact!!!!

On the regional / list vote you vote for the party / branch office you dont vote for candidates on that ballot

So again Kezia didnt get elected by the voters fact!!!

ON the regional vote it gets divided up and each time it gets transferred so the next one gets on the list as MSP but people didnt vote for the likes of Kezia all they did was vote Scottish Labour branch how fucking hard is that to understand ? "

So if the electorate don't vote,

Who

The

Fuck

Does?

THEY GET ELECTED BY THE ELECTORATE!!!!!!!!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!

fancy answering this since you were the person who brought up the topic of the msp lists?

Fabio, do you fancy telling kinky that it is your regular, average, everyday voter who decides which party they give their single transferable vote to?

I am sure Fabio will be more than happy to tell you that in the Holyrood election on regional votes you do not vote for individuals you vote for parties/ branch offices lol

Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe

yes she wasn't......

nicola sturgeon wasn't elected by constituency TWICE, by the public vote TWICE... and on one of those occasions she also happened to be the deputy leader of the snp.. and on both those occasions, she was rescued by being on the regional list.....

so again...... and want to take a stab on actually answering the question...

if you are knocking people in labour for doing it.... should you not be knocking sturgeon for doing in effect taking a double stab and getting in exactly the same way?

"

Mind telling CLCC that then and he is misleading people

Sorry i will answer it just had to correct CLCC for misleading people

btw thank you for backing me up as you will see i asked who in Scotland voted Kezia Dugdale and CLCC said the voters did not true

Now to answer your question _abio no i do not agree with the regional list vote i would honestly prefer for it to always be the constituents that vote people fair enough i answered it ?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!

fancy answering this since you were the person who brought up the topic of the msp lists?

Fabio, do you fancy telling kinky that it is your regular, average, everyday voter who decides which party they give their single transferable vote to?

I am sure Fabio will be more than happy to tell you that in the Holyrood election on regional votes you do not vote for individuals you vote for parties/ branch offices lol

Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe

yes she wasn't......

nicola sturgeon wasn't elected by constituency TWICE, by the public vote TWICE... and on one of those occasions she also happened to be the deputy leader of the snp.. and on both those occasions, she was rescued by being on the regional list.....

so again...... and want to take a stab on actually answering the question...

if you are knocking people in labour for doing it.... should you not be knocking sturgeon for doing in effect taking a double stab and getting in exactly the same way?

Mind telling CLCC that then and he is misleading people

Sorry i will answer it just had to correct CLCC for misleading people

btw thank you for backing me up as you will see i asked who in Scotland voted Kezia Dugdale and CLCC said the voters did not true

Now to answer your question _abio no i do not agree with the regional list vote i would honestly prefer for it to always be the constituents that vote people fair enough i answered it ? "

The voters vote. How fucking hard is that to grasp? How ignorant of your own system are you?????.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!

fancy answering this since you were the person who brought up the topic of the msp lists?

Fabio, do you fancy telling kinky that it is your regular, average, everyday voter who decides which party they give their single transferable vote to?

I am sure Fabio will be more than happy to tell you that in the Holyrood election on regional votes you do not vote for individuals you vote for parties/ branch offices lol

Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe

Not one single person has said that you vote for individual on the STV. BUT you have said that the electorate don't vote for the list. So if it's not the electorate, THEN WHO THE FUCK VOTES FOR THEM?!?!?!?!?!??!?!!?!!!!!!!

Haw stop shouting first off

I asked this remember ? ''Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ? ''

You answered the electorate that is not true!!!! stop misleading people

None voted Kezia or Sarwar or Kelly to be an MSP fact!!!!

On the regional / list vote you vote for the party / branch office you dont vote for candidates on that ballot

So again Kezia didnt get elected by the voters fact!!!

ON the regional vote it gets divided up and each time it gets transferred so the next one gets on the list as MSP but people didnt vote for the likes of Kezia all they did was vote Scottish Labour branch how fucking hard is that to understand ?

So if the electorate don't vote,

Who

The

Fuck

Does?

THEY GET ELECTED BY THE ELECTORATE!!!!!!!!"

See Fabio comment CLCC as he is clearly telling you no the elecorate didnt vote Kezia Dugdale in as a MSP getting it yet ?

On the regional vote people you vote for parties/ branch offices thats how Kezia got in as an unelected MSP through the list vote that divides up and transfers the votes

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

CLCC

try reading this

This is my question ok

'' Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe "

and this is Fabio's answer

yes she wasn't

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!

fancy answering this since you were the person who brought up the topic of the msp lists?

Fabio, do you fancy telling kinky that it is your regular, average, everyday voter who decides which party they give their single transferable vote to?

I am sure Fabio will be more than happy to tell you that in the Holyrood election on regional votes you do not vote for individuals you vote for parties/ branch offices lol

Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe

Not one single person has said that you vote for individual on the STV. BUT you have said that the electorate don't vote for the list. So if it's not the electorate, THEN WHO THE FUCK VOTES FOR THEM?!?!?!?!?!??!?!!?!!!!!!!

Haw stop shouting first off

I asked this remember ? ''Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ? ''

You answered the electorate that is not true!!!! stop misleading people

None voted Kezia or Sarwar or Kelly to be an MSP fact!!!!

On the regional / list vote you vote for the party / branch office you dont vote for candidates on that ballot

So again Kezia didnt get elected by the voters fact!!!

ON the regional vote it gets divided up and each time it gets transferred so the next one gets on the list as MSP but people didnt vote for the likes of Kezia all they did was vote Scottish Labour branch how fucking hard is that to understand ?

So if the electorate don't vote,

Who

The

Fuck

Does?

THEY GET ELECTED BY THE ELECTORATE!!!!!!!!

See Fabio comment CLCC as he is clearly telling you no the elecorate didnt vote Kezia Dugdale in as a MSP getting it yet ?

On the regional vote people you vote for parties/ branch offices thats how Kezia got in as an unelected MSP through the list vote that divides up and transfers the votes "

But it's the electorate that vote on the list. Right? So they are elected by the electorate. I can't believe how ignorant you are about this!

Like I have asked you multiple times, and you haven't answered, because you CAN'T answer, if the electorate don't vote on the list then WHO DOES?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

CLLC For fuck sake man register it

See in Kezia Dugdale constituency they rejected her to be an MSP right ? So people didnt vote for her

In the list vote where she stood those voters were voting for parties/ branches not candidates!!!

And on the regional vote parties/ branch office votes gets divided up and transferred each time

Again the electorate rejected Kezia Dugdale they didnt want her to be an MSP she only got in through the regional vote because of each party/branch office votes being transferred

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!

fancy answering this since you were the person who brought up the topic of the msp lists?

Fabio, do you fancy telling kinky that it is your regular, average, everyday voter who decides which party they give their single transferable vote to?

I am sure Fabio will be more than happy to tell you that in the Holyrood election on regional votes you do not vote for individuals you vote for parties/ branch offices lol

Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe

Not one single person has said that you vote for individual on the STV. BUT you have said that the electorate don't vote for the list. So if it's not the electorate, THEN WHO THE FUCK VOTES FOR THEM?!?!?!?!?!??!?!!?!!!!!!!

Haw stop shouting first off

I asked this remember ? ''Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ? ''

You answered the electorate that is not true!!!! stop misleading people

None voted Kezia or Sarwar or Kelly to be an MSP fact!!!!

On the regional / list vote you vote for the party / branch office you dont vote for candidates on that ballot

So again Kezia didnt get elected by the voters fact!!!

ON the regional vote it gets divided up and each time it gets transferred so the next one gets on the list as MSP but people didnt vote for the likes of Kezia all they did was vote Scottish Labour branch how fucking hard is that to understand ?

So if the electorate don't vote,

Who

The

Fuck

Does?

THEY GET ELECTED BY THE ELECTORATE!!!!!!!!

See Fabio comment CLCC as he is clearly telling you no the elecorate didnt vote Kezia Dugdale in as a MSP getting it yet ?

On the regional vote people you vote for parties/ branch offices thats how Kezia got in as an unelected MSP through the list vote that divides up and transfers the votes

But it's the electorate that vote on the list. Right? So they are elected by the electorate. I can't believe how ignorant you are about this!

Like I have asked you multiple times, and you haven't answered, because you CAN'T answer, if the electorate don't vote on the list then WHO DOES?

"

See kinky, you can't answer who votes for the Party lists if not the electorate! You think if you don't use reply and quote that no one will notice!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

Ok

CLCC to confirm are you saying Kezia Dugdale's constituency voted for her to be an MSP ?

She stood on the regional vote and on that ballot you do NOT vote for candidates you vote for parties so each parties /branch office votes gets divided up and transferred over each time

You clearly did say the voters voted Kezia in as an MSP that is a lie!!!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!

fancy answering this since you were the person who brought up the topic of the msp lists?

Fabio, do you fancy telling kinky that it is your regular, average, everyday voter who decides which party they give their single transferable vote to?

I am sure Fabio will be more than happy to tell you that in the Holyrood election on regional votes you do not vote for individuals you vote for parties/ branch offices lol

Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe

Not one single person has said that you vote for individual on the STV. BUT you have said that the electorate don't vote for the list. So if it's not the electorate, THEN WHO THE FUCK VOTES FOR THEM?!?!?!?!?!??!?!!?!!!!!!!

Haw stop shouting first off

I asked this remember ? ''Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ? ''

You answered the electorate that is not true!!!! stop misleading people

None voted Kezia or Sarwar or Kelly to be an MSP fact!!!!

On the regional / list vote you vote for the party / branch office you dont vote for candidates on that ballot

So again Kezia didnt get elected by the voters fact!!!

ON the regional vote it gets divided up and each time it gets transferred so the next one gets on the list as MSP but people didnt vote for the likes of Kezia all they did was vote Scottish Labour branch how fucking hard is that to understand ?

So if the electorate don't vote,

Who

The

Fuck

Does?

THEY GET ELECTED BY THE ELECTORATE!!!!!!!!

See Fabio comment CLCC as he is clearly telling you no the elecorate didnt vote Kezia Dugdale in as a MSP getting it yet ?

On the regional vote people you vote for parties/ branch offices thats how Kezia got in as an unelected MSP through the list vote that divides up and transfers the votes

But it's the electorate that vote on the list. Right? So they are elected by the electorate. I can't believe how ignorant you are about this!

Like I have asked you multiple times, and you haven't answered, because you CAN'T answer, if the electorate don't vote on the list then WHO DOES?

See kinky, you can't answer who votes for the Party lists if not the electorate! You think if you don't use reply and quote that no one will notice! "

Yet AGAIN trying to avoid the reply and quote button thinking that no one will see how daft you are. Honestly kinky, trying to claim that MSPs are unelected, is RIDICULOUS levels of trolling, even by your standards!

I know you can't answer who voted for them, if not the electorate, so I KNOW you won't answer this one either! Have you ever voted using your STV? a simple yes or no will do.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!

fancy answering this since you were the person who brought up the topic of the msp lists?

Fabio, do you fancy telling kinky that it is your regular, average, everyday voter who decides which party they give their single transferable vote to?

I am sure Fabio will be more than happy to tell you that in the Holyrood election on regional votes you do not vote for individuals you vote for parties/ branch offices lol

Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe

Not one single person has said that you vote for individual on the STV. BUT you have said that the electorate don't vote for the list. So if it's not the electorate, THEN WHO THE FUCK VOTES FOR THEM?!?!?!?!?!??!?!!?!!!!!!!

Haw stop shouting first off

I asked this remember ? ''Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ? ''

You answered the electorate that is not true!!!! stop misleading people

None voted Kezia or Sarwar or Kelly to be an MSP fact!!!!

On the regional / list vote you vote for the party / branch office you dont vote for candidates on that ballot

So again Kezia didnt get elected by the voters fact!!!

ON the regional vote it gets divided up and each time it gets transferred so the next one gets on the list as MSP but people didnt vote for the likes of Kezia all they did was vote Scottish Labour branch how fucking hard is that to understand ?

So if the electorate don't vote,

Who

The

Fuck

Does?

THEY GET ELECTED BY THE ELECTORATE!!!!!!!!

See Fabio comment CLCC as he is clearly telling you no the elecorate didnt vote Kezia Dugdale in as a MSP getting it yet ?

On the regional vote people you vote for parties/ branch offices thats how Kezia got in as an unelected MSP through the list vote that divides up and transfers the votes

But it's the electorate that vote on the list. Right? So they are elected by the electorate. I can't believe how ignorant you are about this!

Like I have asked you multiple times, and you haven't answered, because you CAN'T answer, if the electorate don't vote on the list then WHO DOES?

See kinky, you can't answer who votes for the Party lists if not the electorate! You think if you don't use reply and quote that no one will notice!

Yet AGAIN trying to avoid the reply and quote button thinking that no one will see how daft you are. Honestly kinky, trying to claim that MSPs are unelected, is RIDICULOUS levels of trolling, even by your standards!

I know you can't answer who voted for them, if not the electorate, so I KNOW

you won't answer this one either! Have you ever voted using your STV? a simple yes or no will do. "

right in the regional vote which is the list vote you the Scottish people vote for parties/ branch offices you with me ?

On the ballot paper on the regional list vote you do NOT vote for a candidate you only for a vote party/ branch office

On the constituency vote where Kezia did NOT stand in she was NOT voted in by her constituency got it

There for she is an unelected MSP she didnt get a elected by her constituency

Tell me this are you saying Fabio is now wrong when she clearly said no she want voted in by her constituency ?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!

fancy answering this since you were the person who brought up the topic of the msp lists?

Fabio, do you fancy telling kinky that it is your regular, average, everyday voter who decides which party they give their single transferable vote to?

I am sure Fabio will be more than happy to tell you that in the Holyrood election on regional votes you do not vote for individuals you vote for parties/ branch offices lol

Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe

Not one single person has said that you vote for individual on the STV. BUT you have said that the electorate don't vote for the list. So if it's not the electorate, THEN WHO THE FUCK VOTES FOR THEM?!?!?!?!?!??!?!!?!!!!!!!

Haw stop shouting first off

I asked this remember ? ''Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ? ''

You answered the electorate that is not true!!!! stop misleading people

None voted Kezia or Sarwar or Kelly to be an MSP fact!!!!

On the regional / list vote you vote for the party / branch office you dont vote for candidates on that ballot

So again Kezia didnt get elected by the voters fact!!!

ON the regional vote it gets divided up and each time it gets transferred so the next one gets on the list as MSP but people didnt vote for the likes of Kezia all they did was vote Scottish Labour branch how fucking hard is that to understand ?

So if the electorate don't vote,

Who

The

Fuck

Does?

THEY GET ELECTED BY THE ELECTORATE!!!!!!!!

See Fabio comment CLCC as he is clearly telling you no the elecorate didnt vote Kezia Dugdale in as a MSP getting it yet ?

On the regional vote people you vote for parties/ branch offices thats how Kezia got in as an unelected MSP through the list vote that divides up and transfers the votes

But it's the electorate that vote on the list. Right? So they are elected by the electorate. I can't believe how ignorant you are about this!

Like I have asked you multiple times, and you haven't answered, because you CAN'T answer, if the electorate don't vote on the list then WHO DOES?

See kinky, you can't answer who votes for the Party lists if not the electorate! You think if you don't use reply and quote that no one will notice!

Yet AGAIN trying to avoid the reply and quote button thinking that no one will see how daft you are. Honestly kinky, trying to claim that MSPs are unelected, is RIDICULOUS levels of trolling, even by your standards!

I know you can't answer who voted for them, if not the electorate, so I KNOW

you won't answer this one either! Have you ever voted using your STV? a simple yes or no will do.

right in the regional vote which is the list vote you the Scottish people vote for parties/ branch offices you with me ?

On the ballot paper on the regional list vote you do NOT vote for a candidate you only for a vote party/ branch office

On the constituency vote where Kezia did NOT stand in she was NOT voted in by her constituency got it

There for she is an unelected MSP she didnt get a elected by her constituency

Tell me this are you saying Fabio is now wrong when she clearly said no she want voted in by her constituency ? "

Hahahahahaha so you can't even answer if you have ever voted using the STV

No one has claimed in this thread that she was voted by a constituency, she was on the list, like surgeon has done, like other SNP MSPs!!!!!!!!!! But they are still elected. Or do you think there are unelected SNP MSPs too?

Obviously the STV system is too complicated for you to grasp, let's try a list only system, like the one used for MEPs. Are MEPs elected?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *abioMan
over a year ago

Newcastle and Gateshead


"CLCC

try reading this

This is my question ok

'' Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe "

and this is Fabio's answer

yes she wasn't"

actually kinky, not you are spinning my answer....

yes she was voted in by a constiuancy as such....HOWEVER she was voted by the labour party, to represent Labour under the regional vote which was done via proportial representation.......

the same way nicola sturgeon did for the SNP...... TWICE!

so again.... if you are going to condemn kezia for getting in via the regional list, the i expect you to condemn Nicola Sturgeon with the same gusto for getting voted in via the regional list TWICE.......

at the moment you are condemning kezia, but not condemning nicola..... and that is why you are being hypocritical.....

in fact, there is an arguement that you could be more critical of nicola for using the same loopehole TWICE....

so.... do you finally care to correct that by using BOTH names in the same damning statements

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge

According to kinky, Nicola Sturgeon has sat as an UNELECTED MSP for 2 whole parliaments!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!

fancy answering this since you were the person who brought up the topic of the msp lists?

Fabio, do you fancy telling kinky that it is your regular, average, everyday voter who decides which party they give their single transferable vote to?

I am sure Fabio will be more than happy to tell you that in the Holyrood election on regional votes you do not vote for individuals you vote for parties/ branch offices lol

Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe

Not one single person has said that you vote for individual on the STV. BUT you have said that the electorate don't vote for the list. So if it's not the electorate, THEN WHO THE FUCK VOTES FOR THEM?!?!?!?!?!??!?!!?!!!!!!!

Haw stop shouting first off

I asked this remember ? ''Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ? ''

You answered the electorate that is not true!!!! stop misleading people

None voted Kezia or Sarwar or Kelly to be an MSP fact!!!!

On the regional / list vote you vote for the party / branch office you dont vote for candidates on that ballot

So again Kezia didnt get elected by the voters fact!!!

ON the regional vote it gets divided up and each time it gets transferred so the next one gets on the list as MSP but people didnt vote for the likes of Kezia all they did was vote Scottish Labour branch how fucking hard is that to understand ?

So if the electorate don't vote,

Who

The

Fuck

Does?

THEY GET ELECTED BY THE ELECTORATE!!!!!!!!

See Fabio comment CLCC as he is clearly telling you no the elecorate didnt vote Kezia Dugdale in as a MSP getting it yet ?

On the regional vote people you vote for parties/ branch offices thats how Kezia got in as an unelected MSP through the list vote that divides up and transfers the votes

But it's the electorate that vote on the list. Right? So they are elected by the electorate. I can't believe how ignorant you are about this!

Like I have asked you multiple times, and you haven't answered, because you CAN'T answer, if the electorate don't vote on the list then WHO DOES?

See kinky, you can't answer who votes for the Party lists if not the electorate! You think if you don't use reply and quote that no one will notice!

Yet AGAIN trying to avoid the reply and quote button thinking that no one will see how daft you are. Honestly kinky, trying to claim that MSPs are unelected, is RIDICULOUS levels of trolling, even by your standards!

I know you can't answer who voted for them, if not the electorate, so I KNOW

you won't answer this one either! Have you ever voted using your STV? a simple yes or no will do.

right in the regional vote which is the list vote you the Scottish people vote for parties/ branch offices you with me ?

On the ballot paper on the regional list vote you do NOT vote for a candidate you only for a vote party/ branch office

On the constituency vote where Kezia did NOT stand in she was NOT voted in by her constituency got it

There for she is an unelected MSP she didnt get a elected by her constituency

Tell me this are you saying Fabio is now wrong when she clearly said no she want voted in by her constituency ?

Hahahahahaha so you can't even answer if you have ever voted using the STV

No one has claimed in this thread that she was voted by a constituency, she was on the list, like surgeon has done, like other SNP MSPs!!!!!!!!!! But they are still elected. Or do you think there are unelected SNP MSPs too?

Obviously the STV system is too complicated for you to grasp, let's try a list only system, like the one used for MEPs. Are MEPs elected? "

You are as bad as Centaur you have a serious chip on your shoulder what have a rattled your cage that much sorry

Anyone can read above as i did ask this

''2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

CLCC you replied to that saying '' 2. The electorate'' correct ?

Wrong the electorate never voted for Kezia to be an MSP she was rejected by the voters at the ballot paper

You are the one that doesnt have a scooby doo on how the STV works

Also remember this demeaning remark you said to me yet to even say sorry over

'' I'm qualified to speak on it, I don't believe however that you are''

How demeaning does that sound!

It really does come across like saying Oh am so qualified to speak on it and your not = '' my dick is bigger than your dick'' attitude

Do you get this is a fucking swinging site i have no problem with you we just disagree on things but you go way over the line calm down man

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

All bow down to CLCC he thinks he is '' I'm qualified to speak on it and thinks am not yet knows nothing about me

Demeaning much ? If this is the state of the UK i want no part of it

where people seem to have this attitude of haha my dick is bigger than your dick ie i'm qualified to speak on it and your not

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond

Any you enjoy your night CLCC am away to shag the wife

You too Fabio its been good see ya soon lol

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"CLCC

try reading this

This is my question ok

'' Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe "

and this is Fabio's answer

yes she wasn't

actually kinky, not you are spinning my answer....

yes she was voted in by a constiuancy as such....HOWEVER she was voted by the labour party, to represent Labour under the regional vote which was done via proportial representation.......

the same way nicola sturgeon did for the SNP...... TWICE!

so again.... if you are going to condemn kezia for getting in via the regional list, the i expect you to condemn Nicola Sturgeon with the same gusto for getting voted in via the regional list TWICE.......

at the moment you are condemning kezia, but not condemning nicola..... and that is why you are being hypocritical.....

in fact, there is an arguement that you could be more critical of nicola for using the same loopehole TWICE....

so.... do you finally care to correct that by using BOTH names in the same damning statements "

The difference being Sturgeon fitted in well and is running the SNP well, even though I disagree with many of her actions

Kezia was chosen by Labour and no Scots could accept or follow her, most thought she was a "pathetic wee lassie"

What was left of Labour votes after many walked away when Jim Murphy destroyed Scottish Labour were totally demolished when Kezia took over.

Both Jim Murphy & Kezia destroyed Scottish faith in Labour

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *LCCCouple
over a year ago

Cambridge


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!

fancy answering this since you were the person who brought up the topic of the msp lists?

Fabio, do you fancy telling kinky that it is your regular, average, everyday voter who decides which party they give their single transferable vote to?

I am sure Fabio will be more than happy to tell you that in the Holyrood election on regional votes you do not vote for individuals you vote for parties/ branch offices lol

Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe

Not one single person has said that you vote for individual on the STV. BUT you have said that the electorate don't vote for the list. So if it's not the electorate, THEN WHO THE FUCK VOTES FOR THEM?!?!?!?!?!??!?!!?!!!!!!!

Haw stop shouting first off

I asked this remember ? ''Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ? ''

You answered the electorate that is not true!!!! stop misleading people

None voted Kezia or Sarwar or Kelly to be an MSP fact!!!!

On the regional / list vote you vote for the party / branch office you dont vote for candidates on that ballot

So again Kezia didnt get elected by the voters fact!!!

ON the regional vote it gets divided up and each time it gets transferred so the next one gets on the list as MSP but people didnt vote for the likes of Kezia all they did was vote Scottish Labour branch how fucking hard is that to understand ?

So if the electorate don't vote,

Who

The

Fuck

Does?

THEY GET ELECTED BY THE ELECTORATE!!!!!!!!

See Fabio comment CLCC as he is clearly telling you no the elecorate didnt vote Kezia Dugdale in as a MSP getting it yet ?

On the regional vote people you vote for parties/ branch offices thats how Kezia got in as an unelected MSP through the list vote that divides up and transfers the votes

But it's the electorate that vote on the list. Right? So they are elected by the electorate. I can't believe how ignorant you are about this!

Like I have asked you multiple times, and you haven't answered, because you CAN'T answer, if the electorate don't vote on the list then WHO DOES?

See kinky, you can't answer who votes for the Party lists if not the electorate! You think if you don't use reply and quote that no one will notice!

Yet AGAIN trying to avoid the reply and quote button thinking that no one will see how daft you are. Honestly kinky, trying to claim that MSPs are unelected, is RIDICULOUS levels of trolling, even by your standards!

I know you can't answer who voted for them, if not the electorate, so I KNOW

you won't answer this one either! Have you ever voted using your STV? a simple yes or no will do.

right in the regional vote which is the list vote you the Scottish people vote for parties/ branch offices you with me ?

On the ballot paper on the regional list vote you do NOT vote for a candidate you only for a vote party/ branch office

On the constituency vote where Kezia did NOT stand in she was NOT voted in by her constituency got it

There for she is an unelected MSP she didnt get a elected by her constituency

Tell me this are you saying Fabio is now wrong when she clearly said no she want voted in by her constituency ?

Hahahahahaha so you can't even answer if you have ever voted using the STV

No one has claimed in this thread that she was voted by a constituency, she was on the list, like surgeon has done, like other SNP MSPs!!!!!!!!!! But they are still elected. Or do you think there are unelected SNP MSPs too?

Obviously the STV system is too complicated for you to grasp, let's try a list only system, like the one used for MEPs. Are MEPs elected?

You are as bad as Centaur you have a serious chip on your shoulder what have a rattled your cage that much sorry

Anyone can read above as i did ask this

''2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

CLCC you replied to that saying '' 2. The electorate'' correct ?

Wrong the electorate never voted for Kezia to be an MSP she was rejected by the voters at the ballot paper

You are the one that doesnt have a scooby doo on how the STV works

Also remember this demeaning remark you said to me yet to even say sorry over

'' I'm qualified to speak on it, I don't believe however that you are''

How demeaning does that sound!

It really does come across like saying Oh am so qualified to speak on it and your not = '' my dick is bigger than your dick'' attitude

Do you get this is a fucking swinging site i have no problem with you we just disagree on things but you go way over the line calm down man

"

Saying that members of the Scottish parliament are unelected is just a straight up lie.

Yet AGAIN your ignorance of the topic at hand as made you look foolish, that is your fault. If you don't know how a system works, go and educate yourself, or listen to people who do know how it works.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"Fucking hell

Right the parties /branch office in Scotland decide what candidates stand on the list vote in a Holyrood election not the voters but the members of that party/ branch offce

1. Those candidates who are on the ballot of the constituency vote are elected by the voters

2. The list vote you are voting for a party /branch office not a candidate and those on the list vote are selected by the party / branch office to stand on said list vote

thats how STV works in Holyrood

so when nicola sturgeon gets defeated in the constituency vote TWICE.... once whilst she was deputy leader of the SNP.... and yet still becomes an msp because of the list, which you seem to be deriding for everyone else.....

is that okay?

because i am sure you were saying a bit higher in this very thread that the list was a bad thing!!!!

fancy answering this since you were the person who brought up the topic of the msp lists?

Fabio, do you fancy telling kinky that it is your regular, average, everyday voter who decides which party they give their single transferable vote to?

I am sure Fabio will be more than happy to tell you that in the Holyrood election on regional votes you do not vote for individuals you vote for parties/ branch offices lol

Kezia Dugdale was not voted in by her constituency isn't that correct Fabio ? Only asking since CLCC needs your back up hehe

Not one single person has said that you vote for individual on the STV. BUT you have said that the electorate don't vote for the list. So if it's not the electorate, THEN WHO THE FUCK VOTES FOR THEM?!?!?!?!?!??!?!!?!!!!!!!

Haw stop shouting first off

I asked this remember ? ''Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ? ''

You answered the electorate that is not true!!!! stop misleading people

None voted Kezia or Sarwar or Kelly to be an MSP fact!!!!

On the regional / list vote you vote for the party / branch office you dont vote for candidates on that ballot

So again Kezia didnt get elected by the voters fact!!!

ON the regional vote it gets divided up and each time it gets transferred so the next one gets on the list as MSP but people didnt vote for the likes of Kezia all they did was vote Scottish Labour branch how fucking hard is that to understand ?

So if the electorate don't vote,

Who

The

Fuck

Does?

THEY GET ELECTED BY THE ELECTORATE!!!!!!!!

See Fabio comment CLCC as he is clearly telling you no the elecorate didnt vote Kezia Dugdale in as a MSP getting it yet ?

On the regional vote people you vote for parties/ branch offices thats how Kezia got in as an unelected MSP through the list vote that divides up and transfers the votes

But it's the electorate that vote on the list. Right? So they are elected by the electorate. I can't believe how ignorant you are about this!

Like I have asked you multiple times, and you haven't answered, because you CAN'T answer, if the electorate don't vote on the list then WHO DOES?

See kinky, you can't answer who votes for the Party lists if not the electorate! You think if you don't use reply and quote that no one will notice!

Yet AGAIN trying to avoid the reply and quote button thinking that no one will see how daft you are. Honestly kinky, trying to claim that MSPs are unelected, is RIDICULOUS levels of trolling, even by your standards!

I know you can't answer who voted for them, if not the electorate, so I KNOW

you won't answer this one either! Have you ever voted using your STV? a simple yes or no will do.

right in the regional vote which is the list vote you the Scottish people vote for parties/ branch offices you with me ?

On the ballot paper on the regional list vote you do NOT vote for a candidate you only for a vote party/ branch office

On the constituency vote where Kezia did NOT stand in she was NOT voted in by her constituency got it

There for she is an unelected MSP she didnt get a elected by her constituency

Tell me this are you saying Fabio is now wrong when she clearly said no she want voted in by her constituency ?

Hahahahahaha so you can't even answer if you have ever voted using the STV

No one has claimed in this thread that she was voted by a constituency, she was on the list, like surgeon has done, like other SNP MSPs!!!!!!!!!! But they are still elected. Or do you think there are unelected SNP MSPs too?

Obviously the STV system is too complicated for you to grasp, let's try a list only system, like the one used for MEPs. Are MEPs elected?

You are as bad as Centaur you have a serious chip on your shoulder what have a rattled your cage that much sorry

Anyone can read above as i did ask this

''2. Who in Scotland elected Kezia Dugdale , James Kelly and Anas Sarwar ?

CLCC you replied to that saying '' 2. The electorate'' correct ?

Wrong the electorate never voted for Kezia to be an MSP she was rejected by the voters at the ballot paper

You are the one that doesnt have a scooby doo on how the STV works

Also remember this demeaning remark you said to me yet to even say sorry over

'' I'm qualified to speak on it, I don't believe however that you are''

How demeaning does that sound!

It really does come across like saying Oh am so qualified to speak on it and your not = '' my dick is bigger than your dick'' attitude

Do you get this is a fucking swinging site i have no problem with you we just disagree on things but you go way over the line calm down man

Saying that members of the Scottish parliament are unelected is just a straight up lie.

Yet AGAIN your ignorance of the topic at hand as made you look foolish, that is your fault. If you don't know how a system works, go and educate yourself, or listen to people who do know how it works."

No lie Kezias constituency never voted for her

Btw Kezia was not on the constituency vote ballot paper nice try and misleading people

So if she is not on the constituency ballot how does one for Kezia then ?

The regional vote is for Parties / branch offices thats what you voting for do not sit there and tell me how the hell Holyrood election work when your not even in Scotland

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *icklybitMan
over a year ago

Ayrshire

Was Scotland on the EU referendum ballot paper?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"Was Scotland on the EU referendum ballot paper? "

No

Was extra powers , devo max , Home Rule on the Scottish referendum ballot paper ?

Why is it you point that out but shy away from the fact extra powers was not on the ballot in 2014 but its ok just on fly to offer devo max to try and swing people against independence lol

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *icklybitMan
over a year ago

Ayrshire

No, but independence was on that ballot paper, and it was rejected by the majority if the people in Scotland.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 
 

By *inkyHnS OP   Couple
over a year ago

The Council of Elrond


"No, but independence was on that ballot paper, and it was rejected by the majority if the people in Scotland. "

Is that you trying a dig ?

Well at least you admited devo max was not on the ballot paper but hey unionists couldnt care less

So see when you use that shite about Scotland not being on the EU referendum just remember extra powers was not on the Scottish referendum ballot paper but you seem happy to accept that wonder why

So your point means nothing

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
back to top