FabSwingers.com mobile

Already registered?
Login here

Back to forum list
Back to Politics

USA brokering Ukraine ceasefire

Jump to newest
 

By *0shadesOfFilth OP   Man
4 weeks ago

nearby

Trump has said this afternoon US team on way to Russia 'right now' to discuss Ukraine ceasefire plan.

Zelenskiy says Ukraine does not recognise any Russian occupied territory

Will Putin agree to the USA/UA proposal and what next if he doesn’t

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *uffleskloofMan
4 weeks ago

Walsall

I imagine it depends on whether Putin feels he has more to gain by going along with the peace process.

In terms of the situation in Ukraine alone it’s hard to see why Russia would agree to anything. Russia is clearly winning the war and has been for some time.

The only options realistically are a Russian victory or some sort of peace deal.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ggdrasil66Man
4 weeks ago

Saltdean

I’m hoping that Putin will accept the deal without any exceptions. It will certainly make Trump’s negotiation power look much stronger. A total end to the fighting would be preferable, but I can’t see Putin agreeing to that, I doubt anyone with any sense would trust him.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ulie.your. bottom. slutTV/TS
4 weeks ago

Glasgow


"I’m hoping that Putin will accept the deal without any exceptions. It will certainly make Trump’s negotiation power look much stronger. A total end to the fighting would be preferable, but I can’t see Putin agreeing to that, I doubt anyone with any sense would trust him. "

I don't know any politician you can trust.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *abioMan
4 weeks ago

Newcastle and Gateshead


"Trump has said this afternoon US team on way to Russia 'right now' to discuss Ukraine ceasefire plan.

Zelenskiy says Ukraine does not recognise any Russian occupied territory

Will Putin agree to the USA/UA proposal and what next if he doesn’t "

There is zero chance he agrees to a ceasefire whilst Ukrainians holds any Russia territory…. He is going to say that he can’t give back the 4 Ukrainian regions he annexed as that would be against the Russian federation constitution!

Basically he is going to string trump along and play for time….

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
4 weeks ago

in Lancashire


"Trump has said this afternoon US team on way to Russia 'right now' to discuss Ukraine ceasefire plan.

Zelenskiy says Ukraine does not recognise any Russian occupied territory

Will Putin agree to the USA/UA proposal and what next if he doesn’t

There is zero chance he agrees to a ceasefire whilst Ukrainians holds any Russia territory…. He is going to say that he can’t give back the 4 Ukrainian regions he annexed as that would be against the Russian federation constitution!

Basically he is going to string trump along and play for time…."

Trump knows that, it's a game of saving face ..

Far easier to say to Zelensky give up the areas that were annexed and accept that to save further loss of life but he also needs to not look weak..

That an aggressor is going to be rewarded by keeping territory it invaded sits badly but it's where we are..

The problem is it still doesn't deter Putin from doing the same with other neighbouring states in the future and kicking the can down the road of the west stopping Russia militarily..

Which at some point will be necessary..

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *usie pTV/TS
4 weeks ago

taunton

I don't for one minute think anyone is going to tell Putin what he can or cannot have or do, least of all some lunatic powered crazed American president, there is only one thing that is going to attempt to stop him and that is world war 3 if it is not already upon us. We should have been over there long ago helping to kick his butt back into Russia. I very much hope I am proven wrong.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *uffleskloofMan
4 weeks ago

Walsall


"I don't for one minute think anyone is going to tell Putin what he can or cannot have or do, least of all some lunatic powered crazed American president, there is only one thing that is going to attempt to stop him and that is world war 3 if it is not already upon us. We should have been over there long ago helping to kick his butt back into Russia. I very much hope I am proven wrong."

Are you in Ukraine at the moment “kicking Russia’s butt”?

Or is it something you expect other people to be doing while you sit on the sofa?

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ophieslutTV/TS
4 weeks ago

Central

Whatever Putin agrees to, it's going to be almost impossible to trust him. He might just view a ceasefire as a useful opportunity to restock and plan. And if he breaks any agreement, what impact will it have on him? It will probably happen, eventually, so that he keeps his puppet going and only because he won't feel bothered about breaking rules.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *uddy laneMan
4 weeks ago

dudley

If NATO push forward, Russia will push back against NATO.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ove2pleaseseukMan
4 weeks ago

Hastings


"If NATO push forward, Russia will push back against NATO."

But surly Russia is at its weakest now so a push might do it. The problem now is the support from North Korea

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ulie.your. bottom. slutTV/TS
4 weeks ago

Glasgow


"If NATO push forward, Russia will push back against NATO.

But surly Russia is at its weakest now so a push might do it. The problem now is the support from North Korea "

You seem to basing your assertion of the news we get here. I've noticed that since the war started, the media here seems to amplify any Ukraine news, often splashing it has a breakthrough. Remember how they were going to Kursk.

Any Russians victories are passed on as non news or a small gain.

I remember when the war began and the western military support for Ukraine began, and the sanctions were announced, how the concensus was Russia wouldn't be able to fight for more than 6 months.

The stupidest thing one can do is underestimate the enemy.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
4 weeks ago

in Lancashire

The first casualty in war is truth..

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *uffleskloofMan
4 weeks ago

Walsall


"If NATO push forward, Russia will push back against NATO.

But surly Russia is at its weakest now so a push might do it. The problem now is the support from North Korea

You seem to basing your assertion of the news we get here. I've noticed that since the war started, the media here seems to amplify any Ukraine news, often splashing it has a breakthrough. Remember how they were going to Kursk.

Any Russians victories are passed on as non news or a small gain.

I remember when the war began and the western military support for Ukraine began, and the sanctions were announced, how the concensus was Russia wouldn't be able to fight for more than 6 months.

The stupidest thing one can do is underestimate the enemy."

Indeed so. Even the quality British press has been pushing the “Ukraine is winning” propaganda for the last few years.

Meanwhile in the real world business confidence in the UK is lower than in Russia. Which probably gives some indication of how close to collapse the Russian economy is.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *0shadesOfFilth OP   Man
4 weeks ago

nearby


"If NATO push forward, Russia will push back against NATO.

But surly Russia is at its weakest now so a push might do it. The problem now is the support from North Korea

You seem to basing your assertion of the news we get here. I've noticed that since the war started, the media here seems to amplify any Ukraine news, often splashing it has a breakthrough. Remember how they were going to Kursk.

Any Russians victories are passed on as non news or a small gain.

I remember when the war began and the western military support for Ukraine began, and the sanctions were announced, how the concensus was Russia wouldn't be able to fight for more than 6 months.

The stupidest thing one can do is underestimate the enemy."

And that the military resources if 28 nato states along with other allies have failed miserably to provide Ukraine with adequate and timely weapons supplies to give them the upper hand

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ulie.your. bottom. slutTV/TS
4 weeks ago

Glasgow


"If NATO push forward, Russia will push back against NATO.

But surly Russia is at its weakest now so a push might do it. The problem now is the support from North Korea

You seem to basing your assertion of the news we get here. I've noticed that since the war started, the media here seems to amplify any Ukraine news, often splashing it has a breakthrough. Remember how they were going to Kursk.

Any Russians victories are passed on as non news or a small gain.

I remember when the war began and the western military support for Ukraine began, and the sanctions were announced, how the concensus was Russia wouldn't be able to fight for more than 6 months.

The stupidest thing one can do is underestimate the enemy.

And that the military resources if 28 nato states along with other allies have failed miserably to provide Ukraine with adequate and timely weapons supplies to give them the upper hand "

The cynic in me says it was never about giving Ukraine the upper hand or even the possibility of a very unlikely win, given the nuclear escalation risk.

It was about using Ukraine as proxy to get Russia embroiled in a bloody and expensive war. At the same time getting paid of old weapon stock that would otherwise be worthless.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ophieslutTV/TS
4 weeks ago

Central


"If NATO push forward, Russia will push back against NATO.

But surly Russia is at its weakest now so a push might do it. The problem now is the support from North Korea

You seem to basing your assertion of the news we get here. I've noticed that since the war started, the media here seems to amplify any Ukraine news, often splashing it has a breakthrough. Remember how they were going to Kursk.

Any Russians victories are passed on as non news or a small gain.

I remember when the war began and the western military support for Ukraine began, and the sanctions were announced, how the concensus was Russia wouldn't be able to fight for more than 6 months.

The stupidest thing one can do is underestimate the enemy.

And that the military resources if 28 nato states along with other allies have failed miserably to provide Ukraine with adequate and timely weapons supplies to give them the upper hand

The cynic in me says it was never about giving Ukraine the upper hand or even the possibility of a very unlikely win, given the nuclear escalation risk.

It was about using Ukraine as proxy to get Russia embroiled in a bloody and expensive war. At the same time getting paid of old weapon stock that would otherwise be worthless.

"

The rhetoric wasn't matched to their behaviour, which shouted that it was about minimal effort and investment that was valuable, that would only support Ukraine to feebly get by

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *0shadesOfFilth OP   Man
4 weeks ago

nearby

The latest appears to be Putin may agree to a ceasefire conditional that could include the demilitarisation of Ukraine, an end to western military aid, and a commitment to keeping Kyiv out of Nato. Russia may also push for a ban on foreign troop deployments in Ukraine and international recognition of Putin’s claims to Crimea and the four Ukrainian regions Russia annexed in 2022.

Putin could also revisit some of his broader demands from 2021, which go beyond Ukraine, including a call for Nato to halt the deployment of weapons in member states that joined after 1997, when the alliance began expanding into former communist countries.

Can’t see Ukraine nor Europe agreeing to this, but USA may well do….

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
4 weeks ago

in Lancashire

Stall, stall and stall..

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ophieslutTV/TS
4 weeks ago

Central


"The latest appears to be Putin may agree to a ceasefire conditional that could include the demilitarisation of Ukraine, an end to western military aid, and a commitment to keeping Kyiv out of Nato. Russia may also push for a ban on foreign troop deployments in Ukraine and international recognition of Putin’s claims to Crimea and the four Ukrainian regions Russia annexed in 2022.

Putin could also revisit some of his broader demands from 2021, which go beyond Ukraine, including a call for Nato to halt the deployment of weapons in member states that joined after 1997, when the alliance began expanding into former communist countries.

Can’t see Ukraine nor Europe agreeing to this, but USA may well do…. "

It's almost like Putin may as well demand everything that he wants from a final settlement now . Trump potentially is so weak and wants it ending, that he might give in to everything that he demands.

Putin might have been better getting out of the way first, to validate his true motivation and interest levels

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *otMe66Man
4 weeks ago

Terra Firma

Trump isn’t involved in low level negotiations or putting together detailed plans. He sets the direction or objective, delegates, and expects his team to deliver. He has instructed his team to end the war, but the media tend to conflate Trump's leadership direction with the actual plan.

He has told Putin he wants the war to end and he has set his team the task to mediate. This is how you start the process from a leadership perspective, leader to leader, which is needed to get the ball rolling.

There is going to be a lot of hot air and misguides before any ink hits the page.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *antra MassageMan
4 weeks ago

Dublin and midlands

Nobody has mentioned the Ukrainian hasty withdrawal from Kursk with loss of equipment and heavy casualties , just two days ago. They were about to be encircled, so local unit commanders decided withdrawal was the best option. I haven't heard this mentioned in MSM.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *eroy1000Man
4 weeks ago

milton keynes


"Nobody has mentioned the Ukrainian hasty withdrawal from Kursk with loss of equipment and heavy casualties , just two days ago. They were about to be encircled, so local unit commanders decided withdrawal was the best option. I haven't heard this mentioned in MSM. "

BBC have been reporting on the situation in Kursk though often mixed in with other stories on Ukraine

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *illedbydeathCouple
4 weeks ago

dorset

Who cares what head money laundering zalensky thinks?

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *iman2100Man
4 weeks ago

Glasgow


"Nobody has mentioned the Ukrainian hasty withdrawal from Kursk with loss of equipment and heavy casualties , just two days ago. They were about to be encircled, so local unit commanders decided withdrawal was the best option. I haven't heard this mentioned in MSM. "

So, Ukraine enters the poorly defended Kursk region to acheive three things. Firstly to embarrass Putin and force him to redirect troops to away from the south west to take back the territory. Secondly to shorten the distance between the Ukrainian army and the key Russian munitions storage areas so they could be hit by drone strikes. Thirdly to weaken the Russian defence of Crimea in preparation for an all out attack to take back the peninsular. It is now the right moment for a strategic withdrawal.

Others will say the Glorious Victorious Russian Army has ejected the disgusting Invaders and returned the Russian motherland to its former glory!!

Ce la guerre!

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
3 weeks ago

in Lancashire

Going well for Ukraine isn't it..

Trump as a negotiator has been well and truly played by Putin, didn't help that he showed weakness before they even talked..

But hey, they get to watch ice hockey..

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *hrill CollinsMan
3 weeks ago

The Outer Rim

not only has ukraine been thrown under the bus .... donald trump is driving the bus .... then he'll probably reverse over them out of spite too

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *otMe66Man
3 weeks ago

Terra Firma


"Going well for Ukraine isn't it..

Trump as a negotiator has been well and truly played by Putin, didn't help that he showed weakness before they even talked..

But hey, they get to watch ice hockey.. "

I’m not sure we should expect immediate success.

Trump is not really negotiating with Putin, they are discussing what has been proposed by their teams, this is the time the US get to understand Putin's thoughts beyond that of his negotiators. That will allow for the negotiations to become more meaningful going forward.

However, it would be crazy to think Putin will stop and agree to anything without obtaining the most favourable outcome, because who is going to stop him?

It will come to an end, but not in Ukraine's favour. The take away for me is nobody was talking of a ceasefire and bringing this war to an end until Trump arrived. The message was keep going, we will support you from over here but we wont get too involved because...

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *hrill CollinsMan
1 week ago

The Outer Rim

and two weeks later still fuck all has happened. this was meant to be in the bag by 21st January ... we can safely chalk this up as yet another in a long line of abysmal failures for trump

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
1 week ago

in Lancashire

Almost like he's been outmanoeuvred by Putin..

He'll throw a strop no doubt but if he thinks Putin will change his tack he's more deluded than usual..

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *0shadesOfFilth OP   Man
1 week ago

nearby

Trumps threat of 25%~50% oil tariffs. Will it make any impact on Russia

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
1 week ago

in Lancashire


"Trumps threat of 25%~50% oil tariffs. Will it make any impact on Russia "

Not sure, they'll probably cut their quota to avoid it and sell more to India or wherever..

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *0shadesOfFilth OP   Man
1 week ago

nearby


"and two weeks later still fuck all has happened. this was meant to be in the bag by 21st January ... we can safely chalk this up as yet another in a long line of abysmal failures for trump"

Cut trump some slack a minute, he’s tried for a peace settlement. Putin is disingenuous for a settlement which is a poke in the eye for Trump. Trump could yet swing back to further support for Ukraine.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *otMe66Man
1 week ago

Terra Firma


"and two weeks later still fuck all has happened. this was meant to be in the bag by 21st January ... we can safely chalk this up as yet another in a long line of abysmal failures for trump

Cut trump some slack a minute, he’s tried for a peace settlement. Putin is disingenuous for a settlement which is a poke in the eye for Trump. Trump could yet swing back to further support for Ukraine. "

Exactly

The Putin conundrum: End hostilities and take what I have gained, or fight on to take more but risk renewed support from US.

Diplomacy and negotiation isn't a shake of the hand at this level.....

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *hrill CollinsMan
1 week ago

The Outer Rim


"

Cut trump some slack a minute, he’s tried for a peace settlement. Putin is disingenuous for a settlement which is a poke in the eye for Trump. Trump could yet swing back to further support for Ukraine. "

he's failed ... again.

and to top it all he's just trying for a mineral deal with vlad instead .... useless

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *hrill CollinsMan
1 week ago

The Outer Rim

Aye, so just to recap .... today the kremilin anounces that trumps peace plan is unacceptable.

Fail!!

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ermbiMan
1 week ago

Ballyshannon


"and two weeks later still fuck all has happened. this was meant to be in the bag by 21st January ... we can safely chalk this up as yet another in a long line of abysmal failures for trump

Cut trump some slack a minute, he’s tried for a peace settlement. Putin is disingenuous for a settlement which is a poke in the eye for Trump. Trump could yet swing back to further support for Ukraine. "

Let's not cut Trump any slack. He wants a deal out of Ukraine for mining minerals etc. He and Russia will pillage it just like what happened in East Germany after WW2. Trump isn't interested in peace. Only what he can get for himself and his supporters.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *0shadesOfFilth OP   Man
1 week ago

nearby


"Aye, so just to recap .... today the kremilin anounces that trumps peace plan is unacceptable.

Fail!!"

He’s tried. Now Putin is reported to be arranging 160,000 more conscripts.

Bring on more military support for Ukraine and more sanctions on Russia. Where’s the European army to defend Ukraine that’s gone v quiet too.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *otMe66Man
1 week ago

Terra Firma

Putin is playing a very good game, whether you side with him or not it can’t be denied the pressure he has applied right now is extraordinary.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *0shadesOfFilth OP   Man
1 week ago

nearby


"Putin is playing a very good game, whether you side with him or not it can’t be denied the pressure he has applied right now is extraordinary. "

He has certainly measured Europe well.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *otMe66Man
1 week ago

Terra Firma


"Putin is playing a very good game, whether you side with him or not it can’t be denied the pressure he has applied right now is extraordinary.

He has certainly measured Europe well. "

Not the first time and probably not the last.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 
 

By *hrill CollinsMan
7 days ago

The Outer Rim

he's certainly played trump like cheap fiddle ..... fabs trump fanboys need some seasoning for that egg on their face.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
Post new Message to Thread
back to top