FabSwingers.com mobile

Already registered?
Login here

Back to forum list
Back to Politics

Hamas ceasefire terms

Jump to newest
 

By *mateur100 OP   Man
13 weeks ago

nr faversham

I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By (user no longer on site)
13 weeks ago


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces "

Because ceasefire is a good thing?

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *mateur100 OP   Man
13 weeks ago

nr faversham


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Because ceasefire is a good thing? "

And it's ok to take hostages to achieve that which you have caused?

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By (user no longer on site)
13 weeks ago


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Because ceasefire is a good thing?

And it's ok to take hostages to achieve that which you have caused?"

I don’t believe I said anything of the sort.

All wars end with ceasefire and talks. Ceasefire is good.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *mateur100 OP   Man
13 weeks ago

nr faversham


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Because ceasefire is a good thing?

And it's ok to take hostages to achieve that which you have caused?

I don’t believe I said anything of the sort.

All wars end with ceasefire and talks. Ceasefire is good. "

This is a temporary ceasefire

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By (user no longer on site)
13 weeks ago


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Because ceasefire is a good thing?

And it's ok to take hostages to achieve that which you have caused?

I don’t believe I said anything of the sort.

All wars end with ceasefire and talks. Ceasefire is good.

This is a temporary ceasefire "

Which is better than no ceasefire, don’t you agree?

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *astandFeistyCouple
13 weeks ago

Bournemouth


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Because ceasefire is a good thing?

And it's ok to take hostages to achieve that which you have caused?

I don’t believe I said anything of the sort.

All wars end with ceasefire and talks. Ceasefire is good.

This is a temporary ceasefire

Which is better than no ceasefire, don’t you agree?"

I'll agree but should Israel agree to the release of prisoners in order to get the ceasefire?

I think this was the point the OP was making, Hamas have offered unrealistic terms knowing it'll be turned down and then they can say 'we tried'.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *mateur100 OP   Man
13 weeks ago

nr faversham


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Because ceasefire is a good thing?

And it's ok to take hostages to achieve that which you have caused?

I don’t believe I said anything of the sort.

All wars end with ceasefire and talks. Ceasefire is good.

This is a temporary ceasefire

Which is better than no ceasefire, don’t you agree?

I'll agree but should Israel agree to the release of prisoners in order to get the ceasefire?

I think this was the point the OP was making, Hamas have offered unrealistic terms knowing it'll be turned down and then they can say 'we tried'."

I don't agree as I think all this does is allow 145 days for rearming and then the terrorist attacks restart soon after

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *uddy laneMan
13 weeks ago

dudley

Talks face to face are a good thing, you get to see the whites of the eyes but I dought the ministers of the hamas political party would leave the safety of their protection in qatar.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
13 weeks ago

in Lancashire

Hamas have set terms which they know won't be accepted by Netanyahu, which is probably what Iran also knew when they were drawn up..

Hamas/Iran also know in an election year for POTUS there's pressure on Biden who has both pledged military support to Israel and is in disagreement with Netanyahu and the hard liners in the Knesset over the future of Gaza) Palestinians..

And Netanyahu is more and more in a position where he is losing support and the longer it drags on with the hostages still not freed that more division grows..

And as more innocent Palestinians are killed and maimed the attacks continue on ships and the threat from Hezbollah grows..

Tbh anyone who can negotiate anything acceptable to all sides deserves the Nobel peace prize, if it works..

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *uddy laneMan
13 weeks ago

dudley


"Hamas have set terms which they know won't be accepted by Netanyahu, which is probably what Iran also knew when they were drawn up..

Hamas/Iran also know in an election year for POTUS there's pressure on Biden who has both pledged military support to Israel and is in disagreement with Netanyahu and the hard liners in the Knesset over the future of Gaza) Palestinians..

And Netanyahu is more and more in a position where he is losing support and the longer it drags on with the hostages still not freed that more division grows..

And as more innocent Palestinians are killed and maimed the attacks continue on ships and the threat from Hezbollah grows..

Tbh anyone who can negotiate anything acceptable to all sides deserves the Nobel peace prize, if it works..

"

That's all well and good but a peace prize should never be perched on the back of the crapper in a cell. See were I went with that.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
13 weeks ago

in Lancashire


"Hamas have set terms which they know won't be accepted by Netanyahu, which is probably what Iran also knew when they were drawn up..

Hamas/Iran also know in an election year for POTUS there's pressure on Biden who has both pledged military support to Israel and is in disagreement with Netanyahu and the hard liners in the Knesset over the future of Gaza) Palestinians..

And Netanyahu is more and more in a position where he is losing support and the longer it drags on with the hostages still not freed that more division grows..

And as more innocent Palestinians are killed and maimed the attacks continue on ships and the threat from Hezbollah grows..

Tbh anyone who can negotiate anything acceptable to all sides deserves the Nobel peace prize, if it works..

That's all well and good but a peace prize should never be perched on the back of the crapper in a cell. See were I went with that. "

It sort of epitomises the whole ongoing shit show that the region has been for many decades..

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *resesse_MelioremCouple
13 weeks ago

Border of London


"

It sort of epitomises the whole ongoing shit show that the region has been for many decades..

"

Millennia.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
13 weeks ago

in Lancashire


"

It sort of epitomises the whole ongoing shit show that the region has been for many decades..

Millennia."

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *an DeLyonMan
13 weeks ago

County Durham


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces "

Tell that to the families of the hostages.. if you dare

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ohnnyTwoNotesMan
13 weeks ago

golden fields


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces "

Read about how peace was achieved with n Northern Ireland. That will help you understand.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *lfasoCouple
13 weeks ago

South East


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Because ceasefire is a good thing?

And it's ok to take hostages to achieve that which you have caused?

I don’t believe I said anything of the sort.

All wars end with ceasefire and talks. Ceasefire is good.

This is a temporary ceasefire

Which is better than no ceasefire, don’t you agree?"

The situation prior to October 7 was much less destructive definitely.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *andE2000Man
12 weeks ago

Bathgate

[Removed by poster at 12/02/24 22:02:58]

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *andE2000Man
12 weeks ago

Bathgate


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces "

Your moral campus is indicating south

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *hrimper36Couple
12 weeks ago

Central France dept 36


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Your moral campus is indicating south"

I do love an entertaining typo.

T

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *bsolutely nutsMan
12 weeks ago

Canterbury


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Your moral campus is indicating south

I do love an entertaining typo.

T"

Maybe it isn't a typo and the poster is hankering for their days as a student

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *andE2000Man
12 weeks ago

Bathgate


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Your moral campus is indicating south

I do love an entertaining typo.

T

Maybe it isn't a typo and the poster is hankering for their days as a student "

A students who makes typos is a way better human being than a racist genocide supporter who thinks Palestinian lives don't m

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *resesse_MelioremCouple
12 weeks ago

Border of London


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Your moral campus is indicating south

I do love an entertaining typo.

T

Maybe it isn't a typo and the poster is hankering for their days as a student

A students who makes typos is a way better human being than a racist genocide supporter who thinks Palestinian lives don't m"

A students make fewer typos, usually?

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *verysmileMan
12 weeks ago

CANTERBURY


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Your moral campus is indicating south

I do love an entertaining typo.

T

Maybe it isn't a typo and the poster is hankering for their days as a student

A students who makes typos is a way better human being than a racist genocide supporter who thinks Palestinian lives don't m

A students make fewer typos, usually?"

True

Plus their lower level of inner hatred and acceptance of alternative viewpoints is usually more akin to a great debater rather than people who consider themselves masters

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
12 weeks ago

in Lancashire


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Your moral campus is indicating south

I do love an entertaining typo.

T

Maybe it isn't a typo and the poster is hankering for their days as a student

A students who makes typos is a way better human being than a racist genocide supporter who thinks Palestinian lives don't m"

Surely all innocent lives matter..?

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *oolyCoolyCplCouple
12 weeks ago

Newcastle under Lyme


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces "

Is it right to keep a person in prison without trial for months or years on end? It happens more often than you think, even in the UK, and Israel absolutely is far worse than here for it.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
12 weeks ago

in Lancashire


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Is it right to keep a person in prison without trial for months or years on end? It happens more often than you think, even in the UK, and Israel absolutely is far worse than here for it."

Valid point, there was a report that when the first hostage exchange took place and Israel let out x amount of Palestinians that the number released was equal to those they had locked up under 'administrative detention' since the 7th Oct..

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *andE2000Man
11 weeks ago

Bathgate

[Removed by poster at 18/02/24 20:56:20]

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *mateur100 OP   Man
11 weeks ago

nr faversham


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Is it right to keep a person in prison without trial for months or years on end? It happens more often than you think, even in the UK, and Israel absolutely is far worse than here for it.

Valid point, there was a report that when the first hostage exchange took place and Israel let out x amount of Palestinians that the number released was equal to those they had locked up under 'administrative detention' since the 7th Oct.."

We're talking about a terrorist organisation here

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
11 weeks ago

in Lancashire


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Is it right to keep a person in prison without trial for months or years on end? It happens more often than you think, even in the UK, and Israel absolutely is far worse than here for it.

Valid point, there was a report that when the first hostage exchange took place and Israel let out x amount of Palestinians that the number released was equal to those they had locked up under 'administrative detention' since the 7th Oct..

We're talking about a terrorist organisation here "

Of which not all Palestinians are members..

Administrative detention was tried by us in NI in 71, even though it was based on intelligence and aimed at known members of the IRA it still picked up people who were not terrorists and was one of the biggest recruitment campaigns for them..

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By (user no longer on site)
11 weeks ago

It may be unpalatable to sit round a table with terrorists, but that’s ultimately where it has to end. It’s no use pretending otherwise.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *resesse_MelioremCouple
11 weeks ago

Border of London


"It may be unpalatable to sit round a table with terrorists, but that’s ultimately where it has to end. It’s no use pretending otherwise. "

100% this.

Most of what we hear is theatrical posing, too. The "leaks" we get about any discussions, deals, etc. are all leaked for a reason. Likewise with political rhetoric from all sides.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
11 weeks ago

in Lancashire


"It may be unpalatable to sit round a table with terrorists, but that’s ultimately where it has to end. It’s no use pretending otherwise. "

Thatcher knew that and the talks started under her eventually led to the GFA..

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *andE2000Man
11 weeks ago

Bathgate


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Is it right to keep a person in prison without trial for months or years on end? It happens more often than you think, even in the UK, and Israel absolutely is far worse than here for it.

Valid point, there was a report that when the first hostage exchange took place and Israel let out x amount of Palestinians that the number released was equal to those they had locked up under 'administrative detention' since the 7th Oct..

We're talking about a terrorist organisation here "

You mean Israel?

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *otMe66Man
11 weeks ago

Terra Firma


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Is it right to keep a person in prison without trial for months or years on end? It happens more often than you think, even in the UK, and Israel absolutely is far worse than here for it.

Valid point, there was a report that when the first hostage exchange took place and Israel let out x amount of Palestinians that the number released was equal to those they had locked up under 'administrative detention' since the 7th Oct..

We're talking about a terrorist organisation here

You mean Israel?"

Your comments and the way you conduct a continuous attack on Jewish people, should be used to promote better understandings of how NOT to communicate or negotiate.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *andE2000Man
11 weeks ago

Bathgate

[Removed by poster at 19/02/24 00:14:45]

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *andE2000Man
11 weeks ago

Bathgate

[Removed by poster at 19/02/24 00:14:54]

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *andE2000Man
11 weeks ago

Bathgate


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Is it right to keep a person in prison without trial for months or years on end? It happens more often than you think, even in the UK, and Israel absolutely is far worse than here for it.

Valid point, there was a report that when the first hostage exchange took place and Israel let out x amount of Palestinians that the number released was equal to those they had locked up under 'administrative detention' since the 7th Oct..

We're talking about a terrorist organisation here

You mean Israel?

Your comments and the way you conduct a continuous attack on Jewish people, should be used to promote better understandings of how NOT to communicate or negotiate.

"

Facts that offend you are still facts.

I

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *andE2000Man
11 weeks ago

Bathgate


"I fail to understand why Israel, or anyone else for that matter, would entertain a deal with terrorists that includes the exchange of HOSTAGES for CRIMINALS... nevermind the 145 days that would allow for the re-arming of terrorist forces

Is it right to keep a person in prison without trial for months or years on end? It happens more often than you think, even in the UK, and Israel absolutely is far worse than here for it.

Valid point, there was a report that when the first hostage exchange took place and Israel let out x amount of Palestinians that the number released was equal to those they had locked up under 'administrative detention' since the 7th Oct..

We're talking about a terrorist organisation here

You mean Israel?

Your comments and the way you conduct a continuous attack on Jewish people, should be used to promote better understandings of how NOT to communicate or negotiate.

"

So you negotiate on the basis that the side who invide, take your home, Murder your children on a daily basis for 75 years and build their ideology on ethnically cleansing an entire nation, commits a genocide and brags about it is the victim good guys. And the side being at the receiving end are terrorists.

Once you establish that, you negotiate right? According to you that's how one can negotiate properly. Or else you accuse them of being "Jew haters"

You're such a Muslim lover.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *resesse_MelioremCouple
11 weeks ago

Border of London


"

So you negotiate on the basis that the side who invide, take your home, Murder your children on a daily basis for 75 years and build their ideology on ethnically cleansing an entire nation, commits a genocide and brags about it is the victim good guys. And the side being at the receiving end are terrorists.

Once you establish that, you negotiate right? According to you that's how one can negotiate properly. Or else you accuse them of being "Jew haters"

You're such a Muslim lover. "

What is your suggested basis for negotiations?

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *andE2000Man
11 weeks ago

Bathgate

[Removed by poster at 19/02/24 02:05:50]

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *andE2000Man
11 weeks ago

Bathgate

[Removed by poster at 19/02/24 02:07:23]

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *andE2000Man
11 weeks ago

Bathgate

[Removed by poster at 19/02/24 02:11:27]

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *andE2000Man
11 weeks ago

Bathgate


"

So you negotiate on the basis that the side who invide, take your home, Murder your children on a daily basis for 75 years and build their ideology on ethnically cleansing an entire nation, commits a genocide and brags about it is the victim good guys. And the side being at the receiving end are terrorists.

Once you establish that, you negotiate right? According to you that's how one can negotiate properly. Or else you accuse them of being "Jew haters"

You're such a Muslim lover.

What is your suggested basis for negotiations?"

1- Human rights are not a privilege of of one nation at the expanse of another.

2- Apartheid is Evil and must be abolished and outlawed

3- The Powerful doesn't get to define terrorism as a tool to further marginalise and oppress the already oppressed. And they don't get decide who is a terrorist and who isn't to further colonial oppressive aims

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By (user no longer on site)
11 weeks ago

Looks like Starmer has stiffened (at last) on ceasefire.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *andE2000Man
11 weeks ago

Bathgate


"Looks like Starmer has stiffened (at last) on ceasefire."

A lip service to rescue millions of votes he already lost

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ony 2016Man
11 weeks ago

Huddersfield /derby cinemas


"Looks like Starmer has stiffened (at last) on ceasefire.

A lip service to rescue millions of votes he already lost"

Doubt very much the votes lost would have been in the "millions"

Might even have gained some votes

But now appearing to have reached the correct verdict

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *andE2000Man
11 weeks ago

Bathgate


"Looks like Starmer has stiffened (at last) on ceasefire.

A lip service to rescue millions of votes he already lost

Doubt very much the votes lost would have been in the "millions"

Might even have gained some votes

But now appearing to have reached the correct verdict "

I suspect the Turnout will be very poor this time around.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 
 

By *enSiskoMan
11 weeks ago

Cestus 3


"Looks like Starmer has stiffened (at last) on ceasefire.

A lip service to rescue millions of votes he already lost

Doubt very much the votes lost would have been in the "millions"

Might even have gained some votes

But now appearing to have reached the correct verdict

I suspect the Turnout will be very poor this time around. "

Starmer had no choice but to change his stance on this issue, as he was losing the muslim support, eventually he will have to demand a ceasefire to get the muslim support back.

As will Biden.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
Post new Message to Thread
back to top