Join us FREE, we're FREE to use
Web's largest swingers site since 2006.
Already registered?
Login here
Back to forum list |
Back to The Lounge |
Jump to newest |
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Glad you resurrected this post. I was enjoying it until the stupid comments at the end. Who should vote? It's a matter for the people of Scotland only; that is, those living in Scotland only. It's all about self-determination of a country. There are no other mongrel alliances like UK or GB in the world ie, 3 separate, self determiming countries, coming under the banner of the largest but in the Commonwealth, how many times have we here voted for another country's right to leave? Lots of the nitty gritty arguments will be within Scotland and not properly reported elsewhere so how can a non-resident Scot make a reasoned decision? " We let them vote at general elections - the non-resident voting issue is clearly going to be a difficult one. Personally I can't wait to see how the SNP intend to deal with the issues around transport - will Scotrail be allowed to run trains to London? Will the Uk rump govt pay to subsidize cross border trains? The lovely idea of the country lanes I travel having border posts, or more likely hordes of cross border shoppers exploiting tax differences, is beyond comedy. Will Berwick Rangers fans (both of them) have to go through passport checks for every away game? | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"From what i have read, the proposed referendum would be for all people currently living in Scotland regardless of ethnicity (if you can actually genetically differentiate 'tween Lowland Scots and English) but not offered to those English dwellers who claim Scots heritage. Basically, if you pay your taxes in Scotland you get to vote, if not tough. A Scots vote for independence is constitutionally a Scottish concern, nothing to do with the English - assuming Call Me Dave does change the rules to allow a referendum to be legally binding, currently referenda (sp?) are not legally binding. However, If Devo Max is proposed (something to which i am opposed) then that will alter the Constitution of the UK and ALL British people should be given a say as to whether it should be accepted. I'm in no way a supporter of the Current UK Prime Minister but i agree with him on one point - the Scots should be offered a straight question, are you in or out. My View? Scotland out of the Union." Scotland Act S.30 allows for extensions to the powers of the Scottish Parliament by legislative order - given that there isn't a British constitution anyway, S.30 would seem to be all the powers needed to enact most of Devo Max. On a more general point, since what passes for a British constitution is actually just a mess of pretence and precedent the precedent is clearly established that only the people who live within the area effected get to vote in a devolution referendum... Your proposal that only people who payb taxes should vote is a bit nineteenth century, by the way. I know it's not what you mean but.... Also, the Calman proposals explicitly included some forms of overseas voting... | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"From what i have read, the proposed referendum would be for all people currently living in Scotland regardless of ethnicity (if you can actually genetically differentiate 'tween Lowland Scots and English) but not offered to those English dwellers who claim Scots heritage. Basically, if you pay your taxes in Scotland you get to vote, if not tough. A Scots vote for independence is constitutionally a Scottish concern, nothing to do with the English - assuming Call Me Dave does change the rules to allow a referendum to be legally binding, currently referenda (sp?) are not legally binding. However, If Devo Max is proposed (something to which i am opposed) then that will alter the Constitution of the UK and ALL British people should be given a say as to whether it should be accepted. I'm in no way a supporter of the Current UK Prime Minister but i agree with him on one point - the Scots should be offered a straight question, are you in or out. My View? Scotland out of the Union. Scotland Act S.30 allows for extensions to the powers of the Scottish Parliament by legislative order - given that there isn't a British constitution anyway, S.30 would seem to be all the powers needed to enact most of Devo Max. On a more general point, since what passes for a British constitution is actually just a mess of pretence and precedent the precedent is clearly established that only the people who live within the area effected get to vote in a devolution referendum... Your proposal that only people who payb taxes should vote is a bit nineteenth century, by the way. I know it's not what you mean but.... Also, the Calman proposals explicitly included some forms of overseas voting..." OK then, only people currently residing in Scotland get to vote, hows that? That i believe is the position of the SNP at the moment - i can't see how they can propose non-residents have a vote, how could you organise that? You'd have every braveheart fantasist queueing up with increasingly spurious claims to 'Scottishness'. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"From what i have read, the proposed referendum would be for all people currently living in Scotland regardless of ethnicity (if you can actually genetically differentiate 'tween Lowland Scots and English) but not offered to those English dwellers who claim Scots heritage. Basically, if you pay your taxes in Scotland you get to vote, if not tough. A Scots vote for independence is constitutionally a Scottish concern, nothing to do with the English - assuming Call Me Dave does change the rules to allow a referendum to be legally binding, currently referenda (sp?) are not legally binding. However, If Devo Max is proposed (something to which i am opposed) then that will alter the Constitution of the UK and ALL British people should be given a say as to whether it should be accepted. I'm in no way a supporter of the Current UK Prime Minister but i agree with him on one point - the Scots should be offered a straight question, are you in or out. My View? Scotland out of the Union. Scotland Act S.30 allows for extensions to the powers of the Scottish Parliament by legislative order - given that there isn't a British constitution anyway, S.30 would seem to be all the powers needed to enact most of Devo Max. On a more general point, since what passes for a British constitution is actually just a mess of pretence and precedent the precedent is clearly established that only the people who live within the area effected get to vote in a devolution referendum... Your proposal that only people who payb taxes should vote is a bit nineteenth century, by the way. I know it's not what you mean but.... Also, the Calman proposals explicitly included some forms of overseas voting... OK then, only people currently residing in Scotland get to vote, hows that? That i believe is the position of the SNP at the moment - i can't see how they can propose non-residents have a vote, how could you organise that? You'd have every braveheart fantasist queueing up with increasingly spurious claims to 'Scottishness'." EROs already have lists of overseas voters who are entitled to vote in elections. Arrangements for servicemen and women and diplomats to vote are long established, even though the individuals in question are often resident abroad for long periods. if I were the SNP I'd be getting lots of expats to register to vote at mam and dad's house - perfecly legal and simple to arrange. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"A Scotsman living abroad is still a Scotsman is he not, and as such as he has the freedom to return to Scotland as and when he wishes. If Scotland does vote for independence then it will have it's own passport and those Scots currently riding on a British passport would want the new Scottish document, one would presume. So, if a Scot living abroad is not deemed to be 'Scottish enough' to vote for independence, how will he then obtain a Scottish passport?" By that argument you would have to include a lot of Americans claim Scotish ancestry! in fact I do believe there are some Chinese who have a Scotish claim... Something about a clan who visited and stayed there before Marco Polo found a route, This was the reason for the my idea of a 5 year house swap option, those that vote no and really do not wish to give up the UK passport can move south, whilst those that currently live outside Scotland but want to be part of an independant country and carry a Scots passport can move north. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I do have to wonder what the implications could be upon independence if the EU insists that the Scots should have to re apply for membership of the EU....because currently new full membership of the EU is tied in with joing the Euro (I believe)." Scotland may well decide that independence means independence from the EU also until such time that they've stood on their own two feet for some time and can decide for themselves if and when they want to join the EU rather than be pushed into it as some sort of caveat for independence from the UK. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I do have to wonder what the implications could be upon independence if the EU insists that the Scots should have to re apply for membership of the EU....because currently new full membership of the EU is tied in with joing the Euro (I believe). Scotland may well decide that independence means independence from the EU also until such time that they've stood on their own two feet for some time and can decide for themselves if and when they want to join the EU rather than be pushed into it as some sort of caveat for independence from the UK." Then as an independent nation, outside of the EU and it's freedom of movement and labour, that must surely mean that Scots living in England and Wales would need to apply for a visa to work and reside here? And vice versa of course.... | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I do have to wonder what the implications could be upon independence if the EU insists that the Scots should have to re apply for membership of the EU....because currently new full membership of the EU is tied in with joing the Euro (I believe). Scotland may well decide that independence means independence from the EU also until such time that they've stood on their own two feet for some time and can decide for themselves if and when they want to join the EU rather than be pushed into it as some sort of caveat for independence from the UK. Then as an independent nation, outside of the EU and it's freedom of movement and labour, that must surely mean that Scots living in England and Wales would need to apply for a visa to work and reside here? And vice versa of course...." But that won't happen will it, due to the special status that will exist between the two countries. I don't see Scottish borders being closed to English traffic, nor do I foresee Scots being denied access to England in much the same way they enjoy now. Freedom of movement will remain the same but how a Scot claims unemployment benefit, for example, in England could well be different though. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Nope,, Scotland just luvved being the guinea pigs for the poll tax idea though, yip, appreciated that one. " That had more to do with Scotland being a Labour stronghold against a Tory govt than anything else. Labour play the same tactics when ordered to make cuts in Labour-held constituencies - they cut front line services to show how aggressive the Tories are being when they could make cuts in other areas that are not so vital. It's called politics, and the people who suffer are those in the direct line of fire. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"but how a Scot claims unemployment benefit, for example, in England could well be different though." Another state process that may or may not apply in any independant Scotland, the welfare system would need to be recrafted a good chance to look around and see what works where. There will always be a generation of issues and overlaps, families will be divided if there are two passports in the future some will be on the other side of the border... Only way this works is if you draw a line and work on which side you are on on the day of independance. Give it a couple of hundred years and it won't matter muchcos we will all be a province of the great Lichtenstein empire anyway Disclaimer: other empires may exist and no preference is implied blah blah... | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Re the EU question. I genuinely don't know this- what happened when Slovakia the Ch Rebublic parted? Were they in the EU as one, beforehand? Scotland has a similar population to Slovakia " No they were outside of the EU at the time. It is a long way from an amicable split, I know people there who were close friends before the split who threatened violence if the other turned up at a party in Italy Weirdly there are less problems between Serbian, Croatian, and Bosnian people than there are between Czech Republic and Slovakia | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"So how come there are no border controls between NI and Eire? No barrier between most European countries and their neighbours, not even passport control? Why suddenly such a deal-breaker between Scotland and England?" Thats down to the Schengen Agreement, which came on the news last year when France wanted to pull out of it as far as Italy is concerned. I expect something similar would be agreed even if the EU is not involved. However my mother in law came to England from Ireland in 1951 without a passport, lived here all her life paid taxes etc. but can't get a UK passport | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"So how come there are no border controls between NI and Eire? No barrier between most European countries and their neighbours, not even passport control? Why suddenly such a deal-breaker between Scotland and England?" Because both Eire and NI (The United Kingdom/Greast Britain) are members of the EU.....the question is what if the Scots gain independence then turn their back on joining the EU? Freedom of movement then?....and as Wishy says, what about welfare benefits and health care? | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"You watch things change once I claim my rightful inheritance and lands. " Bobby the Bruce? | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"So how come there are no border controls between NI and Eire? No barrier between most European countries and their neighbours, not even passport control? Why suddenly such a deal-breaker between Scotland and England? Thats down to the Schengen Agreement, which came on the news last year when France wanted to pull out of it as far as Italy is concerned. I expect something similar would be agreed even if the EU is not involved. However my mother in law came to England from Ireland in 1951 without a passport, lived here all her life paid taxes etc. but can't get a UK passport " As regards the Irish passport issue, it's because the split was not a simple one in 1922 - hence the differing constitutional settlements in the 20s and 30s in Ireland. If Scotland wants independence, it will have to settle all these issues. The tri-partite noegtiations, between London and Edinburgh, and Edinburgh and Strasbourg, would be fascinating.... | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I don't really understand how in this day and age, Mr C could wade in, in the way he did and not realise he was aiding the Nationalist cause so much! He's our top politician for goodness sake. Even if he lacks savvy, which I tust he doesn't, where were his aides and advisors? I gather he went off half-cocked and caused a lot of concern behind the scenes by his mishandling of the timing of the referendum. I read today it is now timed to be late 2014 after all " Oh i think i understand, the blokes a muppet end of.. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Oh i think i understand, the blokes a muppet end of.." I wish, personally I think he is a devious git who is very good at misdirecton... if he looks to be shooting himself in the foot take a good look around you can bet your life something nasty is coming and he doens't want you to see it yet! | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"So how come there are no border controls between NI and Eire? No barrier between most European countries and their neighbours, not even passport control? Why suddenly such a deal-breaker between Scotland and England?" It's not a deal-breaker, it's an issue that has to be addressed. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"If - a BIG if - Scotland elect to separate from the UK, we have to be absolutely practical here and understand that Scotland simply cannot be cut adrift from the UK and told to 'sink or swim'. There will have to be a transitional period between full UK membership with all the benefits that entails and full independence. It could take as long as five years to sort out how Scotland develops it's own welfare system independent of the UK but during those five years Westminster MUST supply the funds needed for Scotland to make that transition, whilst at the same time the UK govt must also provide a mechanism for Scotland to develop it's own manufacturing base, services sector and natural resources that it can use to develop it's own economy. Scotland will fail as an independent nation if it doesn't have those safeguards in place." So a bit like having your 20 year old son leave home, then not being able to afford living in his own pad after all....and coming back home? Or.....like placing a bet in Ladbrokes, your horse comes fifth but you still get your stake back? | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"And then there is the issue of the standing army in Devomax. Mr S has been against most/all military involvement from Bosnia onwards. What if he says no and Westminster says yes? Do the Scottish regiments stay at home? The NHS? How will that work? Trident? Sure there are more" This is exactly why there can't be a referendum in Cameron's timeframe. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"If - a BIG if - Scotland elect to separate from the UK, we have to be absolutely practical here and understand that Scotland simply cannot be cut adrift from the UK and told to 'sink or swim'. There will have to be a transitional period between full UK membership with all the benefits that entails and full independence. It could take as long as five years to sort out how Scotland develops it's own welfare system independent of the UK but during those five years Westminster MUST supply the funds needed for Scotland to make that transition, whilst at the same time the UK govt must also provide a mechanism for Scotland to develop it's own manufacturing base, services sector and natural resources that it can use to develop it's own economy. Scotland will fail as an independent nation if it doesn't have those safeguards in place. So a bit like having your 20 year old son leave home, then not being able to afford living in his own pad after all....and coming back home? Or.....like placing a bet in Ladbrokes, your horse comes fifth but you still get your stake back?" No, not at all like it. You'd want your 20y/o son to turn to you if things don't pan out for him. It's not quite the same when an entire country decides to break away. You know that. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"And then there is the issue of the standing army in Devomax. Mr S has been against most/all military involvement from Bosnia onwards. What if he says no and Westminster says yes? Do the Scottish regiments stay at home? The NHS? How will that work? Trident? Sure there are more" My contribution to the original thread had a big "but", some of your questions are exactly what I was alluding to. A huge range/list of questions, most of which Alex Salmond has so far just glossed over!! | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"You watch things change once I claim my rightful inheritance and lands. Bobby the Bruce? " King Robert and its on my passport!!!! | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"And then there is the issue of the standing army in Devomax. Mr S has been against most/all military involvement from Bosnia onwards. What if he says no and Westminster says yes? Do the Scottish regiments stay at home? The NHS? How will that work? Trident? Sure there are more My contribution to the original thread had a big "but", some of your questions are exactly what I was alluding to. A huge range/list of questions, most of which Alex Salmond has so far just glossed over!!" . Well, I look forward to the forthcoming informed debate . | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Re the EU question. I genuinely don't know this- what happened when Slovakia the Ch Rebublic parted? Were they in the EU as one, beforehand? Scotland has a similar population to Slovakia " scotland will have to reapply for membership, strasbourg have confirmed this. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"And then there is the issue of the standing army in Devomax. Mr S has been against most/all military involvement from Bosnia onwards. What if he says no and Westminster says yes? Do the Scottish regiments stay at home? The NHS? How will that work? Trident? Sure there are more My contribution to the original thread had a big "but", some of your questions are exactly what I was alluding to. A huge range/list of questions, most of which Alex Salmond has so far just glossed over!!. Well, I look forward to the forthcoming informed debate . " Yes, most definitely! | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"And then there is the issue of the standing army in Devomax. Mr S has been against most/all military involvement from Bosnia onwards. What if he says no and Westminster says yes? Do the Scottish regiments stay at home? The NHS? How will that work? Trident? Sure there are more My contribution to the original thread had a big "but", some of your questions are exactly what I was alluding to. A huge range/list of questions, most of which Alex Salmond has so far just glossed over!!" cut trident,the scottish submarine bases and the armed forces and thousands of scots are out of work... As i said on the original thread there are far too many unanswered questions | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"The SNP have clearly laid out their policies for Trident and air bases etc so it isn't unanswered; it's just that you don't know. There are minutiae to be decided. Like I said, bring on the INFORMED debate" so, they no longer belong to the British army, what is the snps policy to deal with the unemployed ex service men i wait to be informed | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"The SNP have clearly laid out their policies for Trident and air bases etc so it isn't unanswered; it's just that you don't know. There are minutiae to be decided. Like I said, bring on the INFORMED debate" I never know nuffin!! | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Something that niggles me is the SNP's desire to break up the UK to then go straight into a relationship of dependancy with the EU. " Although as said previously, I approve of it in principle but so far there are too many unanswered questions, the above is one of the reasons I'll be voting against. What is the point of getting independence from London, to then be ruled by a bunch of unelected eejits in Brussels?? | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
Post new Message to Thread |
back to top |