FabSwingers.com mobile

Join us FREE, we're FREE to use

Web's largest swingers site since 2006.

Already registered?
Login here

Back to forum list
Back to The Lounge

I broke someone's arm !!!

Jump to newest
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york

No not during sex I've had a preseason friendly tonight and I got smashed in the neck 'accidently' by the other teams blindside flanker so the next time he made a break for itwo I chopped his ankles out and and he snapped his arm as he landed, I feel like a bit of a pick but I dont think I did anything out of order, comments and thoughts guys ??

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *icketysplitsWoman
over a year ago

Way over Yonder, that's where I'm bound

Someone getting a broken arm at a 'friendly' seems a little extreme to me.

You deliberately 'chopped his ankles out' in retaliation so I think that is out of order.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

grabs popcorn!

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)

While the consequence is certainly more extreme than you intended, I think you were out of order.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)

To add to my comment... when I was a kid I broke someone's ankle, sort of. They were going for a ball I'd passed to them and fell badly. Freak accident.

*I* didn't do anything out of order.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"No not during sex I've had a preseason friendly tonight and I got smashed in the neck 'accidently' by the other teams blindside flanker so the next time he made a break for itwo I chopped his ankles out and and he snapped his arm as he landed, I feel like a bit of a pick but I dont think I did anything out of order, comments and thoughts guys ?? "

I think that’s the nature of the beast. You didn’t intend to injure someone, nobody ever does. If he’d landed differently all would have been fine.. I think as long as you were genuinely sorry and made that clear then you shouldn’t beat yourself up

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"While the consequence is certainly more extreme than you intended, I think you were out of order. "

It was a tap tackle cause he made a break for it nothing illegal but I could have hit his knee's there was nothing wrong with the tackle he just put his arm out as he fell which is like a school boy error

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"While the consequence is certainly more extreme than you intended, I think you were out of order.

It was a tap tackle cause he made a break for it nothing illegal but I could have hit his knee's there was nothing wrong with the tackle he just put his arm out as he fell which is like a school boy error "

I didn't say it was illegal. And blaming the injured party for an instinctive reaction is disgusting. Shame on you.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *nsatiable_nymphWoman
over a year ago

Somewhere down south


" grabs popcorn!"

*pulls up a chair*

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions "

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it "

That’s not how it read... it read he did x so first opportunity I did y

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"While the consequence is certainly more extreme than you intended, I think you were out of order.

It was a tap tackle cause he made a break for it nothing illegal but I could have hit his knee's there was nothing wrong with the tackle he just put his arm out as he fell which is like a school boy error

I didn't say it was illegal. And blaming the injured party for an instinctive reaction is disgusting. Shame on you. "

It was how he fell at the level of rugby where players have been playing for 10+ years easy you shouldn't be putting ya hands out after a tackle

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *olgateMan
over a year ago

on the road to nowhere in particular

I thought injuring people was compulsory in rugby?

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"I thought injuring people was compulsory in rugby? "

If ya do it properly you won't get hurt

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ob198XaMan
over a year ago

teleford

I put a girl on crunches for a month playing mixed touch rugby! Still feel bad about that... worst still I didnt get her number

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"No not during sex I've had a preseason friendly tonight and I got smashed in the neck 'accidently' by the other teams blindside flanker so the next time he made a break for itwo I chopped his ankles out and and he snapped his arm as he landed, I feel like a bit of a pick but I dont think I did anything out of order, comments and thoughts guys ?? "

Genuine question "is chopping his ankles out" a legitimate tackle or a foul?

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ust RachelTV/TS
over a year ago

Horsham


"While the consequence is certainly more extreme than you intended, I think you were out of order.

It was a tap tackle cause he made a break for it nothing illegal but I could have hit his knee's there was nothing wrong with the tackle he just put his arm out as he fell which is like a school boy error

I didn't say it was illegal. And blaming the injured party for an instinctive reaction is disgusting. Shame on you.

It was how he fell at the level of rugby where players have been playing for 10+ years easy you shouldn't be putting ya hands out after a tackle "

But it is human nature to put your hand out, regardless of what you are doing at the time off the fall.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"I put a girl on crunches for a month playing mixed touch rugby! Still feel bad about that... worst still I didnt get her number "

How is that do able in touch I don't think I've ever seen a injury in tag

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *innie The MinxWoman
over a year ago

Under the Duvet

Who knew bingo could be so dangerous!

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"No not during sex I've had a preseason friendly tonight and I got smashed in the neck 'accidently' by the other teams blindside flanker so the next time he made a break for itwo I chopped his ankles out and and he snapped his arm as he landed, I feel like a bit of a pick but I dont think I did anything out of order, comments and thoughts guys ??

Genuine question "is chopping his ankles out" a legitimate tackle or a foul?"

The technical name is a tap tackle and yeah it's completely legal

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it "

I’m with you on this.. ‘you’ didn’t ‘break’ his arm.. his arm broke as he fell. As a regional hockey player I understand contest and contact happens and a lot of the time it’s retaliation, it’s just how it is. It sucks that his arm broke but if I was in his position I wouldn’t blame u

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it

I’m with you on this.. ‘you’ didn’t ‘break’ his arm.. his arm broke as he fell. As a regional hockey player I understand contest and contact happens and a lot of the time it’s retaliation, it’s just how it is. It sucks that his arm broke but if I was in his position I wouldn’t blame u "

Finally someone who agrees

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ELLONS AND CREAMWoman
over a year ago

stourbridge area

[Removed by poster at 31/07/18 22:09:14]

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions "

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ary for funMan
over a year ago

Chelmsford


"No not during sex I've had a preseason friendly tonight and I got smashed in the neck 'accidently' by the other teams blindside flanker so the next time he made a break for itwo I chopped his ankles out and and he snapped his arm as he landed, I feel like a bit of a pick but I dont think I did anything out of order, comments and thoughts guys ?? "
. Should of stamped on his arm mate!!

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"No not during sex I've had a preseason friendly tonight and I got smashed in the neck 'accidently' by the other teams blindside flanker so the next time he made a break for itwo I chopped his ankles out and and he snapped his arm as he landed, I feel like a bit of a pick but I dont think I did anything out of order, comments and thoughts guys ??

Genuine question "is chopping his ankles out" a legitimate tackle or a foul?

The technical name is a tap tackle and yeah it's completely legal "

I don't think you did anything wrong then or any need to feel guilty. I;d feel bad that someone got injured but it's the nature of the beast, it wasn't deliberate and it wasn't against the rules. Shit happens

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

You know the risks when you play rugby. He'll be gutted he will miss a few months of playing, but it's par for the course.

I used to watch my son play from age 11 to 16. It was brutal and people broke things.

I was glad when he left school and didn't have to play any more.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"You know the risks when you play rugby. He'll be gutted he will miss a few months of playing, but it's par for the course.

I used to watch my son play from age 11 to 16. It was brutal and people broke things.

I was glad when he left school and didn't have to play any more."

Did he go to private school ??

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

If it’s a legal tackle then why would you even ask the question? I played semi pro football for about 6 years so have lost count of how many times I’ve been kicked but for 99% of the time it was just part of the game

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

"

If that;ls the case, he;s a bit daft for playing a sport like Rugby where there is a degree of inevitability regarding injuries.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *heBirminghamWeekendMan
over a year ago

here


"No not during sex I've had a preseason friendly tonight and I got smashed in the neck 'accidently' by the other teams blindside flanker so the next time he made a break for itwo I chopped his ankles out and and he snapped his arm as he landed, I feel like a bit of a pick but I dont think I did anything out of order, comments and thoughts guys ?? "

Why are you asking for comments and thoughts. You clearly already have it straight in your head that what you did and how you did it was ok.

Stick with that and carry on.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ELLONS AND CREAMWoman
over a year ago

stourbridge area

Im glad your neck is ok ....

But you went in for the. Kill.....hope you wll help him financially if needs be ...

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"If it’s a legal tackle then why would you even ask the question? I played semi pro football for about 6 years so have lost count of how many times I’ve been kicked but for 99% of the time it was just part of the game"

Because in rugby the high level of physicality means that the risk is huge when playing at a high level I'm more about the fact that I feel like a prat because I could of wrapped his arms

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ob198XaMan
over a year ago

teleford


"I put a girl on crunches for a month playing mixed touch rugby! Still feel bad about that... worst still I didnt get her number

How is that do able in touch I don't think I've ever seen a injury in tag "

I don't fully recall. She was through the back line and I was chasing her down full pelt, I think she tried to dodge as I intercepted but I must have clipped her foot and she went down hard and awkward, wrecking her knee as she did

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"Im glad your neck is ok ....

But you went in for the. Kill.....hope you wll help him financially if needs be ... "

Rfu covers all players up to 100,000 it was a clean break he's fine

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

If that;ls the case, he;s a bit daft for playing a sport like Rugby where there is a degree of inevitability regarding injuries. "

Disagree, the original post was made out like the OP sought revenge for a tackle on him

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

If that;ls the case, he;s a bit daft for playing a sport like Rugby where there is a degree of inevitability regarding injuries.

Disagree, the original post was made out like the OP sought revenge for a tackle on him"

Yes but I fixed the post cause it was my fault I didn't explain it properly

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ELLONS AND CREAMWoman
over a year ago

stourbridge area


"Im glad your neck is ok ....

But you went in for the. Kill.....hope you wll help him financially if needs be ...

Rfu covers all players up to 100,000 it was a clean break he's fine "

How do you know he is fine.....

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

If it's a legal tackle then I don't see the problem?

All part of the game.

Send him some flowers and grapes

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"Im glad your neck is ok ....

But you went in for the. Kill.....hope you wll help him financially if needs be ...

Rfu covers all players up to 100,000 it was a clean break he's fine

How do you know he is fine....."

Cause I got his number of the team manager and phoned him he said clean break and he's been give some pain killer he bears no grudge at all

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
over a year ago

in Lancashire


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it

I’m with you on this.. ‘you’ didn’t ‘break’ his arm.. his arm broke as he fell. As a regional hockey player I understand contest and contact happens and a lot of the time it’s retaliation, it’s just how it is. It sucks that his arm broke but if I was in his position I wouldn’t blame u "

This..

The Op tap tackled the guy which happens thousands of times each season in training at all levels of the game and does not lead to injuries..

To be fair to the Op he had reason after the neck tackle to take the guy out legally and also to have hurt him deliberately but didn't..

Best I say nothing about breaking a guys nose back in the 70s after he gouged me, and him a commissioned officer too..

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
over a year ago

in Lancashire


"Im glad your neck is ok ....

But you went in for the. Kill.....hope you wll help him financially if needs be ... "

In for the kill?

Got to win the prize for totally ott comment..

It was a tap tackle..

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ve 66Woman
over a year ago

Blackwood

As far as I'm concerned rugby is a man's game and you should all know the dangers.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *alking DisasterWoman
over a year ago

South Oxfordshire


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it "

Two wrongs don't make a right. You must have been taught that as a child?

You should have had a straight red and a disciplinary hearing.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it

Two wrongs don't make a right. You must have been taught that as a child?

You should have had a straight red and a disciplinary hearing."

For a completely legal tackle for the last time it was the way he fell

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"Im glad your neck is ok ....

But you went in for the. Kill.....hope you wll help him financially if needs be ...

In for the kill?

Got to win the prize for totally ott comment..

It was a tap tackle.. "

You sound like a rugby guy so can you reiterate to the rest of the forum that by using a tap tackle I put myself In for danger

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *alking DisasterWoman
over a year ago

South Oxfordshire


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it

Two wrongs don't make a right. You must have been taught that as a child?

You should have had a straight red and a disciplinary hearing.

For a completely legal tackle for the last time it was the way he fell "

You said in the original post that it was retaliation. That is a red card in any sport.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *imbo59seMan
over a year ago

North Norfolk area

It's a physical game. There's a reason it's called a contact sport. By playing it, you accept the risks.....both ways.

I played a good/high standard for 30 years, took the knocks and handed them out.....part of the game.

Don't see the point of this thread tbh

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"You know the risks when you play rugby. He'll be gutted he will miss a few months of playing, but it's par for the course.

I used to watch my son play from age 11 to 16. It was brutal and people broke things.

I was glad when he left school and didn't have to play any more.

Did he go to private school ?? "

No. His school was a sports specialist school, particularly rugby. If they didn't play rugby they weren't allowed to play football.

They played against private schools sometimes; including the one Tony Blair's son went to. I think it was the London Oratory.

They also played against local rugby club teams.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it

Two wrongs don't make a right. You must have been taught that as a child?

You should have had a straight red and a disciplinary hearing.

For a completely legal tackle for the last time it was the way he fell

You said in the original post that it was retaliation. That is a red card in any sport."

It was my bad for not explainin properly please read the thread before passing judgement and it's not a red card for retaliation if that was the case every player who was tackled by a player and then tackled them could be sent off

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *urchoicenowCouple
over a year ago

Ashford

As an ex ref, it was a blindside flanker. He has done much worse

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Not being a rugby guy I presume he had the ball?

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
over a year ago

in Lancashire


"Im glad your neck is ok ....

But you went in for the. Kill.....hope you wll help him financially if needs be ...

In for the kill?

Got to win the prize for totally ott comment..

It was a tap tackle..

You sound like a rugby guy so can you reiterate to the rest of the forum that by using a tap tackle I put myself In for danger "

True, there is more chance of an injury to the player carrying out a tap tackle as opposed to Wrapping the other player..

Flailing boots etc..

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"As an ex ref, it was a blindside flanker. He has done much worse"

Can you also explain that by me using a tap tackle I put myself in more danger

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"No not during sex I've had a preseason friendly tonight and I got smashed in the neck 'accidently' by the other teams blindside flanker so the next time he made a break for itwo I chopped his ankles out and and he snapped his arm as he landed, I feel like a bit of a pick but I dont think I did anything out of order, comments and thoughts guys ?? "

Hope you gave him a soapy wank in changing rooms after ?

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"Im glad your neck is ok ....

But you went in for the. Kill.....hope you wll help him financially if needs be ...

In for the kill?

Got to win the prize for totally ott comment..

It was a tap tackle..

You sound like a rugby guy so can you reiterate to the rest of the forum that by using a tap tackle I put myself In for danger

True, there is more chance of an injury to the player carrying out a tap tackle as opposed to Wrapping the other player..

Flailing boots etc..

"

I may have a stud mark 2 cm away from one of my vertebrae

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *alking DisasterWoman
over a year ago

South Oxfordshire


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it

Two wrongs don't make a right. You must have been taught that as a child?

You should have had a straight red and a disciplinary hearing.

For a completely legal tackle for the last time it was the way he fell

You said in the original post that it was retaliation. That is a red card in any sport.

It was my bad for not explainin properly please read the thread before passing judgement and it's not a red card for retaliation if that was the case every player who was tackled by a player and then tackled them could be sent off "

I have read the whole thread. I only can see that he did a bad tackle on you, then some unknown time afterwards you saw the chance to do a tackle on him ("taking his legs out" I believe were your words). That is retaliation and a red card.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"No not during sex I've had a preseason friendly tonight and I got smashed in the neck 'accidently' by the other teams blindside flanker so the next time he made a break for itwo I chopped his ankles out and and he snapped his arm as he landed, I feel like a bit of a pick but I dont think I did anything out of order, comments and thoughts guys ??

Hope you gave him a soapy wank in changing rooms after ?"

I didn't get the chance tbh mate I'll have to tug him off at some point

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Not very friendly....

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *urchoicenowCouple
over a year ago

Ashford


"As an ex ref, it was a blindside flanker. He has done much worse

Can you also explain that by me using a tap tackle I put myself in more danger "

More danger of being called a twonk if you miss.

Think they are talking about catching the boot in the face if mistimed, but see more danger in putting head in wrong place from front tackle.

Still prefer front as more chance of desirable result

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it

Two wrongs don't make a right. You must have been taught that as a child?

You should have had a straight red and a disciplinary hearing.

For a completely legal tackle for the last time it was the way he fell

You said in the original post that it was retaliation. That is a red card in any sport.

It was my bad for not explainin properly please read the thread before passing judgement and it's not a red card for retaliation if that was the case every player who was tackled by a player and then tackled them could be sent off

I have read the whole thread. I only can see that he did a bad tackle on you, then some unknown time afterwards you saw the chance to do a tackle on him ("taking his legs out" I believe were your words). That is retaliation and a red card."

So your telling me the premise of the game tackling should be a red card if the ref think's I did it on retaliation.... jesus Christ it's literally the premise of the game if I wanted l to seriously hurt him I could, but I put a clean tackle in and he got hurt when he fell that's not on me i didn't intend to break his fucking arm it was the way he fell

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
over a year ago

in Lancashire


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it

Two wrongs don't make a right. You must have been taught that as a child?

You should have had a straight red and a disciplinary hearing.

For a completely legal tackle for the last time it was the way he fell

You said in the original post that it was retaliation. That is a red card in any sport.

It was my bad for not explainin properly please read the thread before passing judgement and it's not a red card for retaliation if that was the case every player who was tackled by a player and then tackled them could be sent off

I have read the whole thread. I only can see that he did a bad tackle on you, then some unknown time afterwards you saw the chance to do a tackle on him ("taking his legs out" I believe were your words). That is retaliation and a red card."

Tap tackling is taking the legs out of the other player, it's not illegal and you will see it every game at all levels up to and including international..

The Op could have used a different phrase but he was not at fault for the way the other guy landed, when you tap tackle another player it's not down to you how they land and as said its legal and occurs not only in a training session but in proper games..

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *layfulfoxMan
over a year ago

nowhere

Can't beat a good tap tackle, makes the player look silly when they hit the deck and looks like they were hardly touched

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it

Two wrongs don't make a right. You must have been taught that as a child?

You should have had a straight red and a disciplinary hearing.

For a completely legal tackle for the last time it was the way he fell

You said in the original post that it was retaliation. That is a red card in any sport.

It was my bad for not explainin properly please read the thread before passing judgement and it's not a red card for retaliation if that was the case every player who was tackled by a player and then tackled them could be sent off

I have read the whole thread. I only can see that he did a bad tackle on you, then some unknown time afterwards you saw the chance to do a tackle on him ("taking his legs out" I believe were your words). That is retaliation and a red card.

Tap tackling is taking the legs out of the other player, it's not illegal and you will see it every game at all levels up to and including international..

The Op could have used a different phrase but he was not at fault for the way the other guy landed, when you tap tackle another player it's not down to you how they land and as said its legal and occurs not only in a training session but in proper games.. "

Thannnnnnnk you I like this ref

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
over a year ago

in Lancashire


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it

Two wrongs don't make a right. You must have been taught that as a child?

You should have had a straight red and a disciplinary hearing.

For a completely legal tackle for the last time it was the way he fell

You said in the original post that it was retaliation. That is a red card in any sport.

It was my bad for not explainin properly please read the thread before passing judgement and it's not a red card for retaliation if that was the case every player who was tackled by a player and then tackled them could be sent off

I have read the whole thread. I only can see that he did a bad tackle on you, then some unknown time afterwards you saw the chance to do a tackle on him ("taking his legs out" I believe were your words). That is retaliation and a red card.

Tap tackling is taking the legs out of the other player, it's not illegal and you will see it every game at all levels up to and including international..

The Op could have used a different phrase but he was not at fault for the way the other guy landed, when you tap tackle another player it's not down to you how they land and as said its legal and occurs not only in a training session but in proper games..

Thannnnnnnk you I like this ref "

Just an old prop/hooked.. ??

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
over a year ago

in Lancashire

Hooker..

Bloody phone

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it

Two wrongs don't make a right. You must have been taught that as a child?

You should have had a straight red and a disciplinary hearing.

For a completely legal tackle for the last time it was the way he fell

You said in the original post that it was retaliation. That is a red card in any sport.

It was my bad for not explainin properly please read the thread before passing judgement and it's not a red card for retaliation if that was the case every player who was tackled by a player and then tackled them could be sent off

I have read the whole thread. I only can see that he did a bad tackle on you, then some unknown time afterwards you saw the chance to do a tackle on him ("taking his legs out" I believe were your words). That is retaliation and a red card.

Tap tackling is taking the legs out of the other player, it's not illegal and you will see it every game at all levels up to and including international..

The Op could have used a different phrase but he was not at fault for the way the other guy landed, when you tap tackle another player it's not down to you how they land and as said its legal and occurs not only in a training session but in proper games..

Thannnnnnnk you I like this ref

Just an old prop/hooked.. ?? "

I'm the new breed of prop mate I run like an outside centre kick like a fly half tackle like a brick wall and look good doing (last bits only half true )

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
over a year ago

in Lancashire


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it

Two wrongs don't make a right. You must have been taught that as a child?

You should have had a straight red and a disciplinary hearing.

For a completely legal tackle for the last time it was the way he fell

You said in the original post that it was retaliation. That is a red card in any sport.

It was my bad for not explainin properly please read the thread before passing judgement and it's not a red card for retaliation if that was the case every player who was tackled by a player and then tackled them could be sent off

I have read the whole thread. I only can see that he did a bad tackle on you, then some unknown time afterwards you saw the chance to do a tackle on him ("taking his legs out" I believe were your words). That is retaliation and a red card.

Tap tackling is taking the legs out of the other player, it's not illegal and you will see it every game at all levels up to and including international..

The Op could have used a different phrase but he was not at fault for the way the other guy landed, when you tap tackle another player it's not down to you how they land and as said its legal and occurs not only in a training session but in proper games..

Thannnnnnnk you I like this ref

Just an old prop/hooked.. ??

I'm the new breed of prop mate I run like an outside centre kick like a fly half tackle like a brick wall and look good doing (last bits only half true ) "

Games changed a lot, we used to run for the first half then trundle the rest while the pretty boys away from the pack were like gazelles..

Clean ones..

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"You did it with intent, you wanted revenge for something so clearly acted without thought of the potential consequences.

Bang out of order imo, the other lad may be self employed and could now be fucked for work because of your actions

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it

Two wrongs don't make a right. You must have been taught that as a child?

You should have had a straight red and a disciplinary hearing.

For a completely legal tackle for the last time it was the way he fell

You said in the original post that it was retaliation. That is a red card in any sport.

It was my bad for not explainin properly please read the thread before passing judgement and it's not a red card for retaliation if that was the case every player who was tackled by a player and then tackled them could be sent off

I have read the whole thread. I only can see that he did a bad tackle on you, then some unknown time afterwards you saw the chance to do a tackle on him ("taking his legs out" I believe were your words). That is retaliation and a red card.

Tap tackling is taking the legs out of the other player, it's not illegal and you will see it every game at all levels up to and including international..

The Op could have used a different phrase but he was not at fault for the way the other guy landed, when you tap tackle another player it's not down to you how they land and as said its legal and occurs not only in a training session but in proper games..

Thannnnnnnk you I like this ref

Just an old prop/hooked.. ??

I'm the new breed of prop mate I run like an outside centre kick like a fly half tackle like a brick wall and look good doing (last bits only half true )

Games changed a lot, we used to run for the first half then trundle the rest while the pretty boys away from the pack were like gazelles..

Clean ones.. "

You've got adapt these days or ya screwed you'll just get decked every game

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *hips n FursMan
over a year ago

Huddersfield

Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle."

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"No not during sex I've had a preseason friendly tonight and I got smashed in the neck 'accidently' by the other teams blindside flanker so the next time he made a break for itwo I chopped his ankles out and and he snapped his arm as he landed, I feel like a bit of a pick but I dont think I did anything out of order, comments and thoughts guys ?? "

Nature of the beast mate .... rugby is rugby ... unfortunately a lot of people won’t get it

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *alking DisasterWoman
over a year ago

South Oxfordshire


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it "

I'm not arguing about the tackle, I'm arguing about the retaliation part of it. He got a broken arm because you intentionally tackled him because he tackled you.

If if wasn't retaliation, you would never have mentioned that he had tackled you earlier!

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


" grabs popcorn!"
and tin hat puts phone on silent

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *mmmMaybeCouple
over a year ago

West Wales

If it was a legal tackle what's the issue? The outcome of which was a broken arm. Such is life.Rugby is a tough game & injuries for legal tackles have been worse in the past.

IMO retaliation is when you just slide up & boot him six foot in the air (illegally) I don't see how thinking "If I get a chance legally to stick you on the floor I will" would be seen as wrong in any contact sport as part of the game is winning over your opponent mentally as well as physically.

He stuck out his arm & it broke & yes it is a natural thing to do but you can overcome the natural instinct to do it. MotoGP riders would be the ones that come to mind due to it usually ending in a snapped collarbone or worse a wrist.

I've been put in the kitty litter on a track day by someone fed up with being overtaken by a little 250 on his 1000cc bike & broke my leg & I was self employed!!

His bike was destroyed so I guess instant Karma kicked in.

Contact sport is what it is, I think you did all you needed to do both on & off the pitch so don't fret about it.

S

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ndtheswingersMan
over a year ago

colchester


"While the consequence is certainly more extreme than you intended, I think you were out of order.

It was a tap tackle cause he made a break for it nothing illegal but I could have hit his knee's there was nothing wrong with the tackle he just put his arm out as he fell which is like a school boy error "

I think this is your answer, nothing illegal, he should know not to put his arm out as he fell.

Not guilty your honour

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it

I'm not arguing about the tackle, I'm arguing about the retaliation part of it. He got a broken arm because you intentionally tackled him because he tackled you.

If if wasn't retaliation, you would never have mentioned that he had tackled you earlier!"

He could of paralysed me ffs

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it

I'm not arguing about the tackle, I'm arguing about the retaliation part of it. He got a broken arm because you intentionally tackled him because he tackled you.

If if wasn't retaliation, you would never have mentioned that he had tackled you earlier!

He could of paralysed me ffs"

So u broke his arm in return for that

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it

I'm not arguing about the tackle, I'm arguing about the retaliation part of it. He got a broken arm because you intentionally tackled him because he tackled you.

If if wasn't retaliation, you would never have mentioned that he had tackled you earlier!

He could of paralysed me ffs

So u broke his arm in return for that "

No it was more the instant karma side of it

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Some of my greatest friends are people I’ve had raging on field battles with, unless you’re talking to people who play the game they won’t understand.

Don’t sweat it pal, sure he doesn’t hold you responsible.

#sporthurts

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *W ChapMan
over a year ago

Swindon


"

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it "
So the fact you're defending yourself would seem you think you've done nothing wrong....so why post the question in the first place. Esp on a site like this??

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"

Mate I play first team rugby it was a clean break considering I called the guy and he's cool with it, I was more trying to point out the karma of him hitting my neck deliberately which could have paralysed me and me making a clean tackle and he was injured I never set out to break his arm it was how he fell that did it So the fact you're defending yourself would seem you think you've done nothing wrong....so why post the question in the first place. Esp on a site like this??"

I was just wondering opinion's but when people who don't know the game say that all retaliation should be a red card I went off on one

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *W ChapMan
over a year ago

Swindon


"

So the fact you're defending yourself would seem you think you've done nothing wrong....so why post the question in the first place. Esp on a site like this??

I was just wondering opinion's but when people who don't know the game say that all retaliation should be a red card I went off on one"
The people you should be asking are rugby players, not on as swinging site where most of the people here, including me, know fuck all about Rugby.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Hate when that happens

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *alking DisasterWoman
over a year ago

South Oxfordshire


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it

I'm not arguing about the tackle, I'm arguing about the retaliation part of it. He got a broken arm because you intentionally tackled him because he tackled you.

If if wasn't retaliation, you would never have mentioned that he had tackled you earlier!

He could of paralysed me ffs"

So you tackled him in retaliation.

The actual tackle might be legal, but it was in retaliation which is a red card offence (or at least a yellow card and a stint in the sin bin - depending on the version of rugby you play).

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *rincess peachWoman
over a year ago

shits creek

A clean tackle and chopping his ankles out sound like 2 different things. Then that's me knowing fuck all about rugby.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *heBirminghamWeekendMan
over a year ago

here

Oh my ... this could go all the way to 176

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *hips n FursMan
over a year ago

Huddersfield


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it

I'm not arguing about the tackle, I'm arguing about the retaliation part of it. He got a broken arm because you intentionally tackled him because he tackled you.

If if wasn't retaliation, you would never have mentioned that he had tackled you earlier!

He could of paralysed me ffs

So you tackled him in retaliation.

The actual tackle might be legal, but it was in retaliation which is a red card offence (or at least a yellow card and a stint in the sin bin - depending on the version of rugby you play)."

So as a ref,how would you determine that it was retaliation.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it

I'm not arguing about the tackle, I'm arguing about the retaliation part of it. He got a broken arm because you intentionally tackled him because he tackled you.

If if wasn't retaliation, you would never have mentioned that he had tackled you earlier!

He could of paralysed me ffs

So you tackled him in retaliation.

The actual tackle might be legal, but it was in retaliation which is a red card offence (or at least a yellow card and a stint in the sin bin - depending on the version of rugby you play)."

Wasn't gonna pull this card but I've played rugby for 12 years and I've never seen someone being sent off for retaliation have you ever played rugby at all love like seriously

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *alking DisasterWoman
over a year ago

South Oxfordshire


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it

I'm not arguing about the tackle, I'm arguing about the retaliation part of it. He got a broken arm because you intentionally tackled him because he tackled you.

If if wasn't retaliation, you would never have mentioned that he had tackled you earlier!

He could of paralysed me ffs

So you tackled him in retaliation.

The actual tackle might be legal, but it was in retaliation which is a red card offence (or at least a yellow card and a stint in the sin bin - depending on the version of rugby you play).

Wasn't gonna pull this card but I've played rugby for 12 years and I've never seen someone being sent off for retaliation have you ever played rugby at all love like seriously "

Never played, but watched and seen players being sent off for retaliation.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *alking DisasterWoman
over a year ago

South Oxfordshire

At the end of the day, you know that you broke someone's arm through an act of retaliation. You wanted to get some sympathy or something, so posted on here.

Now you're backtracking because you know half the forum are disgusted with your actions.

I would suggest you ask admin to remove this thread, otherwise your name will only be known as a thug who thinks it's ok to break someone's arm in retaliation.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"

So the fact you're defending yourself would seem you think you've done nothing wrong....so why post the question in the first place. Esp on a site like this??

I was just wondering opinion's but when people who don't know the game say that all retaliation should be a red card I went off on one The people you should be asking are rugby players, not on as swinging site where most of the people here, including me, know fuck all about Rugby.

"

And LOVE a chance to have a go at a single man.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *heBirminghamWeekendMan
over a year ago

here


"Wasn't gonna pull this card but I've played rugby for 12 years and I've never seen someone being sent off for retaliation have you ever played rugby at all love like seriously "

Hahahaha lol funny

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
over a year ago

in Lancashire


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it

I'm not arguing about the tackle, I'm arguing about the retaliation part of it. He got a broken arm because you intentionally tackled him because he tackled you.

If if wasn't retaliation, you would never have mentioned that he had tackled you earlier!

He could of paralysed me ffs

So you tackled him in retaliation.

The actual tackle might be legal, but it was in retaliation which is a red card offence (or at least a yellow card and a stint in the sin bin - depending on the version of rugby you play).

Wasn't gonna pull this card but I've played rugby for 12 years and I've never seen someone being sent off for retaliation have you ever played rugby at all love like seriously

Never played, but watched and seen players being sent off for retaliation."

But not through tap tackling you haven't..

It is not thuggish behaviour to tap tackle an opposition player, it is not the fault of the tackler how the tackled player lands whatever intentions were behind the tackle which any player, ex player or official will tell you is impossible to decide..

It is a legal tackle..

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

It always amazes me that people can have such a strong opinion on subjects they blatantly know fuck all about.

I don’t know why, I’ve been here long enough.

As for the former ‘referee’ handing a card out for a tap tackle

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *alking DisasterWoman
over a year ago

South Oxfordshire


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it

I'm not arguing about the tackle, I'm arguing about the retaliation part of it. He got a broken arm because you intentionally tackled him because he tackled you.

If if wasn't retaliation, you would never have mentioned that he had tackled you earlier!

He could of paralysed me ffs

So you tackled him in retaliation.

The actual tackle might be legal, but it was in retaliation which is a red card offence (or at least a yellow card and a stint in the sin bin - depending on the version of rugby you play).

Wasn't gonna pull this card but I've played rugby for 12 years and I've never seen someone being sent off for retaliation have you ever played rugby at all love like seriously

Never played, but watched and seen players being sent off for retaliation.

But not through tap tackling you haven't..

It is not thuggish behaviour to tap tackle an opposition player, it is not the fault of the tackler how the tackled player lands whatever intentions were behind the tackle which any player, ex player or official will tell you is impossible to decide..

It is a legal tackle..

"

It's the retaliation part that is illegal though. He has admitted it himself on numerous occasions, he decided to tackle the player solely because of the tackle the other player had done on him earlier.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
over a year ago

in Lancashire


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it

I'm not arguing about the tackle, I'm arguing about the retaliation part of it. He got a broken arm because you intentionally tackled him because he tackled you.

If if wasn't retaliation, you would never have mentioned that he had tackled you earlier!

He could of paralysed me ffs

So you tackled him in retaliation.

The actual tackle might be legal, but it was in retaliation which is a red card offence (or at least a yellow card and a stint in the sin bin - depending on the version of rugby you play).

Wasn't gonna pull this card but I've played rugby for 12 years and I've never seen someone being sent off for retaliation have you ever played rugby at all love like seriously

Never played, but watched and seen players being sent off for retaliation.

But not through tap tackling you haven't..

It is not thuggish behaviour to tap tackle an opposition player, it is not the fault of the tackler how the tackled player lands whatever intentions were behind the tackle which any player, ex player or official will tell you is impossible to decide..

It is a legal tackle..

It's the retaliation part that is illegal though. He has admitted it himself on numerous occasions, he decided to tackle the player solely because of the tackle the other player had done on him earlier."

Retaliation is part and parcel of every contact sport so unless you want to ban all sport your barking up a none existent tree..

It is impossible to define if the legal tackle in question during play or training was made with retaliation in mind..

It's only because the op has said it that anyone is aware, you've called him a thug yet ignored his contacting the other guy afterwards..?

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *alking DisasterWoman
over a year ago

South Oxfordshire


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it

I'm not arguing about the tackle, I'm arguing about the retaliation part of it. He got a broken arm because you intentionally tackled him because he tackled you.

If if wasn't retaliation, you would never have mentioned that he had tackled you earlier!

He could of paralysed me ffs

So you tackled him in retaliation.

The actual tackle might be legal, but it was in retaliation which is a red card offence (or at least a yellow card and a stint in the sin bin - depending on the version of rugby you play).

Wasn't gonna pull this card but I've played rugby for 12 years and I've never seen someone being sent off for retaliation have you ever played rugby at all love like seriously

Never played, but watched and seen players being sent off for retaliation.

But not through tap tackling you haven't..

It is not thuggish behaviour to tap tackle an opposition player, it is not the fault of the tackler how the tackled player lands whatever intentions were behind the tackle which any player, ex player or official will tell you is impossible to decide..

It is a legal tackle..

It's the retaliation part that is illegal though. He has admitted it himself on numerous occasions, he decided to tackle the player solely because of the tackle the other player had done on him earlier.

Retaliation is part and parcel of every contact sport so unless you want to ban all sport your barking up a none existent tree..

It is impossible to define if the legal tackle in question during play or training was made with retaliation in mind..

It's only because the op has said it that anyone is aware, you've called him a thug yet ignored his contacting the other guy afterwards..?

"

A quick Google search shows that players do get sent of for retaliation.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it

I'm not arguing about the tackle, I'm arguing about the retaliation part of it. He got a broken arm because you intentionally tackled him because he tackled you.

If if wasn't retaliation, you would never have mentioned that he had tackled you earlier!

He could of paralysed me ffs

So you tackled him in retaliation.

The actual tackle might be legal, but it was in retaliation which is a red card offence (or at least a yellow card and a stint in the sin bin - depending on the version of rugby you play).

Wasn't gonna pull this card but I've played rugby for 12 years and I've never seen someone being sent off for retaliation have you ever played rugby at all love like seriously

Never played, but watched and seen players being sent off for retaliation.

But not through tap tackling you haven't..

It is not thuggish behaviour to tap tackle an opposition player, it is not the fault of the tackler how the tackled player lands whatever intentions were behind the tackle which any player, ex player or official will tell you is impossible to decide..

It is a legal tackle..

It's the retaliation part that is illegal though. He has admitted it himself on numerous occasions, he decided to tackle the player solely because of the tackle the other player had done on him earlier.

Retaliation is part and parcel of every contact sport so unless you want to ban all sport your barking up a none existent tree..

It is impossible to define if the legal tackle in question during play or training was made with retaliation in mind..

It's only because the op has said it that anyone is aware, you've called him a thug yet ignored his contacting the other guy afterwards..?

A quick Google search shows that players do get sent of for retaliation."

Yes, but it would have to be seen by someone at the time for him to be sent off - it wasn’t, so it’s just the OP saying what he did (which he may have over egged anyway).

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xplorer13Man
over a year ago

glenrothes


"No not during sex I've had a preseason friendly tonight and I got smashed in the neck 'accidently' by the other teams blindside flanker so the next time he made a break for itwo I chopped his ankles out and and he snapped his arm as he landed, I feel like a bit of a pick but I dont think I did anything out of order, comments and thoughts guys ?? "

I don't think you will ever have sex again !!! ????

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *alking DisasterWoman
over a year ago

South Oxfordshire


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it

I'm not arguing about the tackle, I'm arguing about the retaliation part of it. He got a broken arm because you intentionally tackled him because he tackled you.

If if wasn't retaliation, you would never have mentioned that he had tackled you earlier!

He could of paralysed me ffs

So you tackled him in retaliation.

The actual tackle might be legal, but it was in retaliation which is a red card offence (or at least a yellow card and a stint in the sin bin - depending on the version of rugby you play).

Wasn't gonna pull this card but I've played rugby for 12 years and I've never seen someone being sent off for retaliation have you ever played rugby at all love like seriously

Never played, but watched and seen players being sent off for retaliation.

But not through tap tackling you haven't..

It is not thuggish behaviour to tap tackle an opposition player, it is not the fault of the tackler how the tackled player lands whatever intentions were behind the tackle which any player, ex player or official will tell you is impossible to decide..

It is a legal tackle..

It's the retaliation part that is illegal though. He has admitted it himself on numerous occasions, he decided to tackle the player solely because of the tackle the other player had done on him earlier.

Retaliation is part and parcel of every contact sport so unless you want to ban all sport your barking up a none existent tree..

It is impossible to define if the legal tackle in question during play or training was made with retaliation in mind..

It's only because the op has said it that anyone is aware, you've called him a thug yet ignored his contacting the other guy afterwards..?

A quick Google search shows that players do get sent of for retaliation.

Yes, but it would have to be seen by someone at the time for him to be sent off - it wasn’t, so it’s just the OP saying what he did (which he may have over egged anyway).

"

So I'm right? Players do get sent off for retaliation?

My post above said that he could have been sent off for retaliation. I was immediately jumped on to say it could never ever happen.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

I remember when I was 15 years old in a continuous fight in kickboxing, I landed a kick on this girls mouth somehow and she ended up swallowing a tooth, blood everywhere, the girl stopped for a moment, had a drink and then looked at me, ohhh fuck did she look at me and then came towards me like something possessed, she put me right on my arse!

In sport, in any sport, you can't help wanting to get someone back if they hurt you.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *heBirminghamWeekendMan
over a year ago

here

Since this has turned into such an excellent discussion on the laws of rugby union what’s everyones thoughts on the RFU lowering the definition of a high tackle from above the line of the shoulders to above the line of the armpit. It’s only being trialed at the moment in certain games, but could be brought in across the board.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ouple in LancashireCouple
over a year ago

in Lancashire


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it

I'm not arguing about the tackle, I'm arguing about the retaliation part of it. He got a broken arm because you intentionally tackled him because he tackled you.

If if wasn't retaliation, you would never have mentioned that he had tackled you earlier!

He could of paralysed me ffs

So you tackled him in retaliation.

The actual tackle might be legal, but it was in retaliation which is a red card offence (or at least a yellow card and a stint in the sin bin - depending on the version of rugby you play).

Wasn't gonna pull this card but I've played rugby for 12 years and I've never seen someone being sent off for retaliation have you ever played rugby at all love like seriously

Never played, but watched and seen players being sent off for retaliation.

But not through tap tackling you haven't..

It is not thuggish behaviour to tap tackle an opposition player, it is not the fault of the tackler how the tackled player lands whatever intentions were behind the tackle which any player, ex player or official will tell you is impossible to decide..

It is a legal tackle..

It's the retaliation part that is illegal though. He has admitted it himself on numerous occasions, he decided to tackle the player solely because of the tackle the other player had done on him earlier.

Retaliation is part and parcel of every contact sport so unless you want to ban all sport your barking up a none existent tree..

It is impossible to define if the legal tackle in question during play or training was made with retaliation in mind..

It's only because the op has said it that anyone is aware, you've called him a thug yet ignored his contacting the other guy afterwards..?

A quick Google search shows that players do get sent of for retaliation.

Yes, but it would have to be seen by someone at the time for him to be sent off - it wasn’t, so it’s just the OP saying what he did (which he may have over egged anyway).

So I'm right? Players do get sent off for retaliation?

My post above said that he could have been sent off for retaliation. I was immediately jumped on to say it could never ever happen."

Not said a player can't be sent off for retaliation, that's common but tap tackling is legal so how a ref can define that a tap tackle was made legally but with retaliation in the mind of the tackler is pretty nigh on impossible..

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *izzy RascallMan
over a year ago

Cardiff

Someone broke my leg in January. I carried on playing as there wasn't long left and just used 1 leg. I was in goals.

I only went to A+E on the Monday as the shape didn't seem right. I was just as supreme as the staff as I walked around on it with a limp. Was back playing 5 weeks later.

The guy who done it sent an apology to my club. I still say it was intentional and was built up frustration. I made sure I had him though, he went over the top of me and went flying

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it

I'm not arguing about the tackle, I'm arguing about the retaliation part of it. He got a broken arm because you intentionally tackled him because he tackled you.

If if wasn't retaliation, you would never have mentioned that he had tackled you earlier!

He could of paralysed me ffs

So you tackled him in retaliation.

The actual tackle might be legal, but it was in retaliation which is a red card offence (or at least a yellow card and a stint in the sin bin - depending on the version of rugby you play).

Wasn't gonna pull this card but I've played rugby for 12 years and I've never seen someone being sent off for retaliation have you ever played rugby at all love like seriously

Never played, but watched and seen players being sent off for retaliation."

Yeah for punches thrown

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it

I'm not arguing about the tackle, I'm arguing about the retaliation part of it. He got a broken arm because you intentionally tackled him because he tackled you.

If if wasn't retaliation, you would never have mentioned that he had tackled you earlier!

He could of paralysed me ffs

So you tackled him in retaliation.

The actual tackle might be legal, but it was in retaliation which is a red card offence (or at least a yellow card and a stint in the sin bin - depending on the version of rugby you play).

Wasn't gonna pull this card but I've played rugby for 12 years and I've never seen someone being sent off for retaliation have you ever played rugby at all love like seriously

Never played, but watched and seen players being sent off for retaliation.

But not through tap tackling you haven't..

It is not thuggish behaviour to tap tackle an opposition player, it is not the fault of the tackler how the tackled player lands whatever intentions were behind the tackle which any player, ex player or official will tell you is impossible to decide..

It is a legal tackle..

It's the retaliation part that is illegal though. He has admitted it himself on numerous occasions, he decided to tackle the player solely because of the tackle the other player had done on him earlier."

Because he made a break for it should I have just let him run and score

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"Funniest thread I've seen for a while...a fucking red card for a tap tackle.

I tried to explain to her mate she was having non of it

I'm not arguing about the tackle, I'm arguing about the retaliation part of it. He got a broken arm because you intentionally tackled him because he tackled you.

If if wasn't retaliation, you would never have mentioned that he had tackled you earlier!

He could of paralysed me ffs

So you tackled him in retaliation.

The actual tackle might be legal, but it was in retaliation which is a red card offence (or at least a yellow card and a stint in the sin bin - depending on the version of rugby you play).

Wasn't gonna pull this card but I've played rugby for 12 years and I've never seen someone being sent off for retaliation have you ever played rugby at all love like seriously

Never played, but watched and seen players being sent off for retaliation.

But not through tap tackling you haven't..

It is not thuggish behaviour to tap tackle an opposition player, it is not the fault of the tackler how the tackled player lands whatever intentions were behind the tackle which any player, ex player or official will tell you is impossible to decide..

It is a legal tackle..

It's the retaliation part that is illegal though. He has admitted it himself on numerous occasions, he decided to tackle the player solely because of the tackle the other player had done on him earlier.

Retaliation is part and parcel of every contact sport so unless you want to ban all sport your barking up a none existent tree..

It is impossible to define if the legal tackle in question during play or training was made with retaliation in mind..

It's only because the op has said it that anyone is aware, you've called him a thug yet ignored his contacting the other guy afterwards..?

A quick Google search shows that players do get sent of for retaliation."

Yes for punche's thrown there is no rule in the book that has anything to do with retaliation the only place where ithe comes close is during high tackles and punches thrown

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york

Walking can I genuinely talk to you on the phone cause i think you are getting massively confused just inbox me your number or kick cause I'm getting frustrated now

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *alking DisasterWoman
over a year ago

South Oxfordshire


"Walking can I genuinely talk to you on the phone cause i think you are getting massively confused just inbox me your number or kick cause I'm getting frustrated now "

Absolutely not.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *ighland gentlemanMan
over a year ago

Ardgay


"Since this has turned into such an excellent discussion on the laws of rugby union what’s everyones thoughts on the RFU lowering the definition of a high tackle from above the line of the shoulders to above the line of the armpit. It’s only being trialed at the moment in certain games, but could be brought in across the board.

"

Not just the RFU, elsewhere in the world too.

Going to be a bugger to ref in my opinion.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"Walking can I genuinely talk to you on the phone cause i think you are getting massively confused just inbox me your number or kick cause I'm getting frustrated now

Absolutely not."

Cause you know you've been spurting shit cause you like to have a go at a single man cause it make's you feel big sorry to be harsh but truths the truth

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"While the consequence is certainly more extreme than you intended, I think you were out of order.

It was a tap tackle cause he made a break for it nothing illegal but I could have hit his knee's there was nothing wrong with the tackle he just put his arm out as he fell which is like a school boy error "

So now you are saying that it was his fault...

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"While the consequence is certainly more extreme than you intended, I think you were out of order.

It was a tap tackle cause he made a break for it nothing illegal but I could have hit his knee's there was nothing wrong with the tackle he just put his arm out as he fell which is like a school boy error

So now you are saying that it was his fault... "

Didn't wanna come out and say that but yeah

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *iSTARessWoman
over a year ago

London

Sounds pretty spiteful and bang out of order.

Someone who used to be close to me called me a spiteful cunt on social media recently. I could ruin his career but risen above it.

Accidents happen, doesn't sound like an accident

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *heBirminghamWeekendMan
over a year ago

here


"Since this has turned into such an excellent discussion on the laws of rugby union what’s everyones thoughts on the RFU lowering the definition of a high tackle from above the line of the shoulders to above the line of the armpit. It’s only being trialed at the moment in certain games, but could be brought in across the board.

Not just the RFU, elsewhere in the world too.

Going to be a bugger to ref in my opinion.

"

Yes, it’s a world rugny trial.

I think the current high tackle is quite difficult to distinguish, so Lowering the height will make it easier, I think, to see the over the line/high tackles.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *alking DisasterWoman
over a year ago

South Oxfordshire


"Walking can I genuinely talk to you on the phone cause i think you are getting massively confused just inbox me your number or kick cause I'm getting frustrated now

Absolutely not.

Cause you know you've been spurting shit cause you like to have a go at a single man cause it make's you feel big sorry to be harsh but truths the truth "

No.

I don't want to talk to a thug who retaliated and caused someone to break their arm. You can say anything you like to me on this public forum. You are never getting me alone.

I am not spouting shit, some of the people that were supporting you earlier agreed that you can be sent off for retaliation. Just because the ref didn't see it this time does not mean he won't see it next time and send you off.

The fact that I'm a stubborn female that won't back down to your intimidating behaviour is what's pissing you off now.

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *heBirminghamWeekendMan
over a year ago

here


"Walking can I genuinely talk to you on the phone cause i think you are getting massively confused just inbox me your number or kick cause I'm getting frustrated now

Absolutely not.

Cause you know you've been spurting shit cause you like to have a go at a single man cause it make's you feel big sorry to be harsh but truths the truth "

Grow up!

Suspect your not going to last long here

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"Walking can I genuinely talk to you on the phone cause i think you are getting massively confused just inbox me your number or kick cause I'm getting frustrated now

Absolutely not.

Cause you know you've been spurting shit cause you like to have a go at a single man cause it make's you feel big sorry to be harsh but truths the truth

No.

I don't want to talk to a thug who retaliated and caused someone to break their arm. You can say anything you like to me on this public forum. You are never getting me alone.

I am not spouting shit, some of the people that were supporting you earlier agreed that you can be sent off for retaliation. Just because the ref didn't see it this time does not mean he won't see it next time and send you off.

The fact that I'm a stubborn female that won't back down to your intimidating behaviour is what's pissing you off now."

1.he didn't see a tap tackle no he saw it was legal

2.can we just leave this now actual rugby players understand

3. THE GUY HIT ME IN MY NECK AND COULD OF FUCKING PARALYSED ME

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 

By *xxx30 OP   Man
over a year ago

york


"Walking can I genuinely talk to you on the phone cause i think you are getting massively confused just inbox me your number or kick cause I'm getting frustrated now

Absolutely not.

Cause you know you've been spurting shit cause you like to have a go at a single man cause it make's you feel big sorry to be harsh but truths the truth

No.

I don't want to talk to a thug who retaliated and caused someone to break their arm. You can say anything you like to me on this public forum. You are never getting me alone.

I am not spouting shit, some of the people that were supporting you earlier agreed that you can be sent off for retaliation. Just because the ref didn't see it this time does not mean he won't see it next time and send you off.

The fact that I'm a stubborn female that won't back down to your intimidating behaviour is what's pissing you off now."

I'm not a intimidating person at all l

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
 
 

By *ugby 123Couple
Forum Mod
over a year ago

O o O oo

Maybe it is time to leave it there

 (thread closed by moderator)

Reply privately
back to top