Join us FREE, we're FREE to use
Web's largest swingers site since 2006.
Already registered?
Login here
Back to forum list |
Back to The Lounge |
Jump to newest |
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"How can you say it's been proven to be no better when so many millions of people act every day purely for religious reasons? " I didn't say it, it was from the other thread. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"How can you say it's been proven to be no better when so many millions of people act every day purely for religious reasons? I didn't say it, it was from the other thread." Lol sorry OP, wasn't aimed at you but the other chap who replied to the original post. Fact is we will never know will we? | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"How can you say it's been proven to be no better when so many millions of people act every day purely for religious reasons? I didn't say it, it was from the other thread. Lol sorry OP, wasn't aimed at you but the other chap who replied to the original post. Fact is we will never know will we?" lol its ok and your right. I don't think we will never know. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
""It has always struck me as profoundly ironic that if; hypothetically, the existence of a God or Gods could be proven, we would no longer have any need for religion. Personally, I take the view (like Einstein) that religion is a childish, primitive way of understanding what is ultimately the actual way the universe works. I strongly suspect (as Einstein, Niels Bohr and Heisenburg did) that, as the laws of physics are fixed and immutable under normal conditions, that there is some kind of intelligence behind the way the universe works. Whether you want to call that 'God' (I see no other appropriate term for it), I don't know. Einstein considered the profound feelings of awe and wonder that many physicists and other scientists get when considering the vastness of the universe and the incredible way in which it works to be the same as a religious person gets when contemplating God; it's just that the religious response is a more primitive, primal, childlike way of considering the actual truth about the universe. Einstein considered the scientific approach, whilst on the same lines, to be a more rational but at the same time more profound way of understanding what was to him essentially the same thing. My own interpretation is that the ideas _xpressed about the universe by religion are not 'wrong' as such, they are just primitive. I look at religion to science (in particular the physical sciences) to be like alchemy ultimately became to chemistry: it wasn't that the basic ideas that alchemy was all about were wrong, it was just that the way alchemy investigated these phenomena lacked the empiricism and rational application chemistry later had, and, just in the same way chemistry took the discoveries that were actually made by alchemy and incorporated them into itself-chemistry 'swallowed' alchemy, likewise I think once we get to the bottom of things as to how the universe works science will 'swallow' religion. Without getting ridiculously cosmic about things, I don't see the central tenets of religion in itself to be wrong or inherently bad-as I find the ideas of awe at the complexity and vastness of the universe and in particular the idea there is something behind the fixed laws of the universe to be right, based on the evidence. However, it is the tribalistic, irrational, and above all emotional response to the way some humans apply religion-and it goes just the same to other non-religious philosophies too-that is the problem. Religion in itself is not bad (merely primitive), it is only when it is tacked to ideas of nationalism, racism, prejudice, xenophobia, sectarianism and any form of hatred for fellow human beings that it becomes a bad thing. It is not religion that needs to be done away with, it is these attitudes. As for atheism, personally I think that will just be one of those philosophies, like communism, that will be shown to be wrong. That said, I would like to point out that the idea there is a personal God, one who cares about what you do with your daily life, who cares about sin, who answers prayer and who cares about where you stick your genitals or what rituals you perform or what meat you eat on a given day-the God who interferes with the laws of physics rather than bring responsible for them-that God is impossible. We are not talking about some old dude sat on a cloud with a big beard. But likewise, I do not think we are alone and the universe is as meaningless as some would have us believe. The truth is, I suspect, as it all too often is, somewhere inbetween the two extremes-those of religion and atheism in this case. A good post but I remain unconvinced (I appreciate your aim is not to necessarily convince me). Whether a primitive follower of religion or a genius at the level of Einstein, the moment individuals blame a 'God' is that moment of awe. The moment the reality is beyond their comprehension. Einstein proved primitive religious thinking to be just that but, in my opinion, was no closer to understanding 'awe'. In time a genius will come along and make Einstein seem primitive. The question still remains, does awe = god? I am not convinced it does. Just because we don't understand something doesn't mean we have to make up an 'intelligent designer'." But Einstein did not consider 'God' as he concieved of it to have created the universe, he was of the opinion that 'God' or whatever you wish to call it *is* the universe. " He considered the Universe to be 'God' because he hit his limit of understanding. His 'awe' moment was based on different evidence than that of a sun worshipper who sees a solar eclipse as clear evidence of their god, but I have no reason to believe his awe moment is any more valid in claiming any form of 'god'. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I think they should all have a fight, and the winner can be the recognised world religion, i'm rooting for buddha, cos i reckon he do kung fu n shit " Maybe we should bring back Bill and Ted to do one more excellent adventure, what a movie that could be!! | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"The other thread got filled up quick. If religion was to drop of the face of the earth tomorrow do you think the world would be a better place? Continue here." Yes! | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I think they should all have a fight, and the winner can be the recognised world religion, i'm rooting for buddha, cos i reckon he do kung fu n shit " Isn't that just what they've been doing for the last couple of millenia?! I don't buy into the "religion causes war" thing - the vast majority of wars have been over money. Strip away the religious bullshit reasons and there's always wealth at the root, whether it's land, resources or "loot". | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"The other thread got filled up quick. If religion was to drop of the face of the earth tomorrow do you think the world would be a better place? Continue here." Religion is (and has always been) used to control the thinking and lives of masses of people. If religion disappeared tomorrow someone would invent an equivalent to enable those in power to manipulate those they control. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"The other thread got filled up quick. If religion was to drop of the face of the earth tomorrow do you think the world would be a better place? Continue here." I'm an Atheist so yes | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"The other thread got filled up quick. If religion was to drop of the face of the earth tomorrow do you think the world would be a better place? Continue here. I'm an Atheist so yes " what's that got to do with anything? | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
" how years ago they would drill holes in heads to relive evil spirit headaches.. " You mean trepanning-relieving pressure on the brain (caused by haemmoraghes or clots) by drilling holes in the skull? That thing that surgeons still totally do in 2014? That also works? | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"The other thread got filled up quick. If religion was to drop of the face of the earth tomorrow do you think the world would be a better place? Continue here." It would be flowers and roses and we would all dance round the maypole in bliss even in November. OR it could be like 1950's CCCP where religion was banned and everybody informed on everyone else and millions disappeared. I am not sure which one would be the outcome but one would for sure. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
" how years ago they would drill holes in heads to relive evil spirit headaches.. You mean trepanning-relieving pressure on the brain (caused by haemmoraghes or clots) by drilling holes in the skull? That thing that surgeons still totally do in 2014? That also works?" . Err no I meant when they would drill a hole in your head because you suffered migraines or putting radium on pottery, watch dials, children's toys or heroin for children's cough's (coincidentally manufactured by those wonderful people that gave us zyklon b) or reprogramming crazy people with electric shock treatment... You know all the crazy shit we do when we don't know the answer to stuff that scares or fascinates us. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Nobody's answered my question about Islam and Judaism yet..." . Every single human in the world is 99.99% genetically identical, in fact recently they found evidence to suggest we once got down to only 1000 mating pairs, and as a statistic your nearly guaranteed to be a 5th cousin to nearly anyone in the world. I really can't see how one can be born Jewish or Islamic, your just born a homo-sapien, every other label is given to you by the society your born into. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Anyway, there is no God... Stephen Hawking said so. " Only he didn't. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Anyway, there is no God... Stephen Hawking said so. Only he didn't." . I read the other day he believes the biggest danger to mankind is AI.. Him and that wheelchair are at war! | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Anyway, there is no God... Stephen Hawking said so. Only he didn't.. I read the other day he believes the biggest danger to mankind is AI.." You gotta admit though; that was a tetrible film. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Its interesting that you should mention islam, judaism and catholicism as not only do those three religions have seperate legal codes that define them -respectively, shariah, talmudic and canon law-unlike other religions-they also have the provision in those laws that it is impossible for one to leave said religion once they join it-again, unlike other religions." . Yeah but that's just the equivalent of fab saying once you join them your fabbers for life and you can't join any other site, of course your free to join another site, but if you instill the fact your a fabber for life deep into your culture it will retain some tangible belief perse. Most importantly for me is that people are free to practise religion or non religion, I'm not anti Muslim or anti Semite but I do dislike intensely the way those certain religions indoctrinate and control there flock to the point of repressing people. I also dislike intensely the political influence both those religions seek to influence other states by. Judaism in particular! | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Anyway, there is no God... Stephen Hawking said so. Only he didn't.. I read the other day he believes the biggest danger to mankind is AI.. You gotta admit though; that was a tetrible film." ...Not a patch on A.L.F | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Anyway, there is no God... Stephen Hawking said so. Only he didn't." Correct, I don't think he actually put it that way, it was something like, 'there is no need of a god, everything is explained' regarding the coming into existence of the universe and everything since. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I say bring back the old gods, these new ones are shit n boring..........give us some lightning, fly down and have sex with our mums and fuckin release the kraken! " I'm already released. LOL | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"The other thread got filled up quick. If religion was to drop of the face of the earth tomorrow do you think the world would be a better place? Continue here. I'm an Atheist so yes " As an atheist you should look at the evidence not just what you feel or believe. And the evidence does not support the statement. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Yes; I get that, but being a 'jew' or 'muslim' is not a question of belief in those religions, it is a question of law. Law and ritual is of paramount importance in those religions, much more than faith or belief. So, if one can totally disbelieve in God and still legitimately be considered Jewish, how then would Judaism disappear? " There is being Jewish as in being Christian and there is being Jewish as in being English. One is religion the other has little or nothing to do with religion. As for religious law in Judaism or Islam, it's only valid while people believe in the religion that underpins them: while people have faith. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"The other thread got filled up quick. If religion was to drop of the face of the earth tomorrow do you think the world would be a better place? Continue here. Religion is (and has always been) used to control the thinking and lives of masses of people. If religion disappeared tomorrow someone would invent an equivalent to enable those in power to manipulate those they control. " Not unlike the media today | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"No there have been more wars faught over religion but if there were no religion people would find something else to fight over religion isn't the reason for bad things it's an excuse bad people hide behind humans can not coexist we will never live in peace" Fought * | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Anyway, there is no God... Stephen Hawking said so. Only he didn't.. I read the other day he believes the biggest danger to mankind is AI.. You gotta admit though; that was a tetrible film." WHAT ! I cried at that film | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"The other thread got filled up quick. If religion was to drop of the face of the earth tomorrow do you think the world would be a better place? Continue here. I'm an Atheist so yes As an atheist you should look at the evidence not just what you feel or believe. And the evidence does not support the statement." What I meant was; an atheist is not forced to be anti-religion. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Its interesting that you should mention islam, judaism and catholicism as not only do those three religions have seperate legal codes that define them -respectively, shariah, talmudic and canon law-unlike other religions-they also have the provision in those laws that it is impossible for one to leave said religion once they join it-again, unlike other religions." I think there a big difference between Canon Law, law about the governance of the (catholic) church and shariah or Talmudic law which govern how to run your life. The catholic position on salvation is the same as all christian churches, that is, you are saved by God's grace and God's grace alone not by actions or obedience to law. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Yes; I get that, but being a 'jew' or 'muslim' is not a question of belief in those religions, it is a question of law. Law and ritual is of paramount importance in those religions, much more than faith or belief. So, if one can totally disbelieve in God and still legitimately be considered Jewish, how then would Judaism disappear? There is being Jewish as in being Christian and there is being Jewish as in being English. One is religion the other has little or nothing to do with religion. As for religious law in Judaism or Islam, it's only valid while people believe in the religion that underpins them: while people have faith." Not so; an particularly not as regards judaism. The only criteria talmuldic law specifies for someone to be considered jewish is that either their mother is jewish, or they formally convert to judaism. Faith and belief have nothing to do with it. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Its interesting that you should mention islam, judaism and catholicism as not only do those three religions have seperate legal codes that define them -respectively, shariah, talmudic and canon law-unlike other religions-they also have the provision in those laws that it is impossible for one to leave said religion once they join it-again, unlike other religions. I think there a big difference between Canon Law, law about the governance of the (catholic) church and shariah or Talmudic law which govern how to run your life. The catholic position on salvation is the same as all christian churches, that is, you are saved by God's grace and God's grace alone not by actions or obedience to law." Yup. Precisely what makes them different to Judaism and Islam, where you attain salvation through your actions, by good works and by obeying the law. A particular jew or muslim can choose to disregard the law, but all that makes them is a 'bad' jew or a 'bad' muslim. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Because they'll find something else to be tribalistic about. Nations, skin colour etc." This. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Its interesting that you should mention islam, judaism and catholicism as not only do those three religions have seperate legal codes that define them -respectively, shariah, talmudic and canon law-unlike other religions-they also have the provision in those laws that it is impossible for one to leave said religion once they join it-again, unlike other religions. I think there a big difference between Canon Law, law about the governance of the (catholic) church and shariah or Talmudic law which govern how to run your life. The catholic position on salvation is the same as all christian churches, that is, you are saved by God's grace and God's grace alone not by actions or obedience to law. Yup. Precisely what makes them different to Judaism and Islam, where you attain salvation through your actions, by good works and by obeying the law. A particular jew or muslim can choose to disregard the law, but all that makes them is a 'bad' jew or a 'bad' muslim." The Christian position on being a Christian is similar; Once baptized a Christian you are always a Christian. You may be a good Christian, a bad Christian, a heretical Christian or even a schismatic Christian but you are still a Christian. There are a few Christian sects that don't believe that but generally it is accepted belief through out. That's why all Christian churches baptise people as Christian and not as Catholic, C of E, Methodist etc. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"The catholic position on salvation is the same as all christian churches, that is, you are saved by God's grace and God's grace alone not by actions or obedience to law." if that is true then how come ex-communication has been and is a serious threat to Catholics? bottom line the thread title is a moot point, wont happen and if we didn't have religion there is still money, resources, left handers v right handers humans are just like that. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"The catholic position on salvation is the same as all christian churches, that is, you are saved by God's grace and God's grace alone not by actions or obedience to law. if that is true then how come ex-communication has been and is a serious threat to Catholics? bottom line the thread title is a moot point, wont happen and if we didn't have religion there is still money, resources, left handers v right handers humans are just like that. " It's not just the Catholic church that does ex-communication. It's quite complicated but I'll try to put it simply. The basic tenant of Christian faith is as I've said. Saved by grace alone. However most churches, including the Catholic, Anglican, Methodists, Orthodox and Lutheran go on from there You are saved by grace if you believe you are saved. If you believe you are saved by God's Grace then you must believe in God. If you believe in God and that you are saved then you must believe it is right to do God's will on earth. It is God's will that 'this' church is his church and 'this' church does the will of God. If you want to do the will of God you must obey his church If you are not willing to do the will of God then you must either not believe in God or not believe you are saved by God. If you are not saved by God then you are not part of the true community of the church. If you are not part of the true community of the church then you are ex-communicated. The full argument is much more in depth than this but it's basically that. And, for the record, this is not my belief, just an explanation of the rational. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"The other thread got filled up quick. If religion was to drop of the face of the earth tomorrow do you think the world would be a better place? Continue here. Religion is (and has always been) used to control the thinking and lives of masses of people. If religion disappeared tomorrow someone would invent an equivalent to enable those in power to manipulate those they control. Not unlike the media today " As I said if religion disappeared someone would invent an equivalent to enable those in power to manipulate those they control... | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"The other thread got filled up quick. If religion was to drop of the face of the earth tomorrow do you think the world would be a better place? Continue here. Religion is (and has always been) used to control the thinking and lives of masses of people. If religion disappeared tomorrow someone would invent an equivalent to enable those in power to manipulate those they control. Not unlike the media today As I said if religion disappeared someone would invent an equivalent to enable those in power to manipulate those they control... " I was sort off agreeing with you about the control through religion, except that I think there is a bit more too religion than just an 'opium of masses' used to control people whereas I don't think that is the case for the current controlling method of the mass media. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Yes; I get that, but being a 'jew' or 'muslim' is not a question of belief in those religions, it is a question of law. Law and ritual is of paramount importance in those religions, much more than faith or belief. So, if one can totally disbelieve in God and still legitimately be considered Jewish, how then would Judaism disappear? " I think history has proven that it would not. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"The other thread got filled up quick. If religion was to drop of the face of the earth tomorrow do you think the world would be a better place? Continue here. Religion is (and has always been) used to control the thinking and lives of masses of people. If religion disappeared tomorrow someone would invent an equivalent to enable those in power to manipulate those they control. Not unlike the media today As I said if religion disappeared someone would invent an equivalent to enable those in power to manipulate those they control... I was sort off agreeing with you about the control through religion, except that I think there is a bit more too religion than just an 'opium of masses' used to control people whereas I don't think that is the case for the current controlling method of the mass media. " I was just going one further and suggesting that most people in the West (and the rest of the world for that matter) sit down every night and give homage to the gods of the box in the corner and would never question the word of the the holy bearers of the news according to Fox delivered by the acolytes of News International and Sky! | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"The other thread got filled up quick. If religion was to drop of the face of the earth tomorrow do you think the world would be a better place? Continue here." Without a doubt, the world would improve. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
Post new Message to Thread |
back to top |