Join us FREE, we're FREE to use
Web's largest swingers site since 2006.
Already registered?
Login here
![]() | Back to forum list |
![]() | Back to The Lounge |
Jump to newest | ![]() |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
![]() | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Its something I'd do, I dont really see much point in my organs or even my sons organs, rotting away in a wooden box, or being chargrilled into ashes. Would rather help someone or them go to scientific research. Not everyone has the same _iew as myself, for lots of different reasons, but personally I'd be happy to donate and respect those that dont want to." the thing that id thnk id struggle with is tha altoughthey would be pronunced brain dead its actually letting go of that hope that pthey may recover x | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"My daughter has made it very clear to me that if anything happens to her, I am to donate as much from her as they'll take. Maybe talk it over with your kids (if they are old enough) and that might help strengthen your decision." yes i have done except with my 6 year old and son with spcial needs which would be in appropriate | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Its something I'd do, I dont really see much point in my organs or even my sons organs, rotting away in a wooden box, or being chargrilled into ashes. Would rather help someone or them go to scientific research. ............." It's good to tell the Anatomy people at your local University (with a School Of Medicine). They don't always have a need for or space to store cadavers and they can advise you of what might happen if that's the case. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"They can have anything apart from my eyes... they are the window to your soul.. I don't care if I am dead my eyes are staying with me.. " If that's the case, I'm keeping my arsehole as well ![]() | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"They can have anything apart from my eyes... they are the window to your soul.. I don't care if I am dead my eyes are staying with me.. " I think the exact same thing... Spooky ![]() | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"a close family member dropped dead very unexpectedly and relatively young. He was transferred to hospital and kept on a life support machine for a few days. At the time we were oblivious to the reason why and thought he may come round. However over the next few days it transpired that due to his relative youth and health alot of hospitals had requested 'various parts' should we give the 'nod'. About 3 days later at a very late point in the evening the question was put to us about 30 doctors descended onto our 'family private room' .. the reason for this is a doctor cannot request organs till hes witnessed a qualified doctor doing this a number of times .. we did give the go ahead for certain parts to be used and were then advised that we would need to wait a further 2 hours for the organ donation people to counsell us first .. 2 hours later a woman arrived from a town miles away and started to give us graphic detail of the procedure he was about to undergo and asked if one of us would volunteer to 'watch the operation'. Clearly we declined she then went on to say she would do this on our behalf. She then had hours of wait whilst each surgeon who would use the organ was flown in as he has to take it out of the body .. The whole process was a nightmare and very few people realise this is what it involves but, the trauma of it aside, a few did go onto live as a result so it was worth it in the end " That sounds horrific...but if others have lived and had a quality of life......seems they could surely make it less painful for the family... | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
" That sounds horrific...but if others have lived and had a quality of life......seems they could surely make it less painful for the family..." they cant unfortunately and we did address the organ donor lady about this trauma at the time. Her explanation for requesting a family member to witness the operation is to ensure us that it is done in a dignified and respectful manner. The surgeons stitch up the body with the same degree of respect that they would afford a living person. It is meant to give us peace of mind. Their other concern is that pressure was put onto someone in deep trauma who agrees to donation whilst not clearly thinking .. i do see their point but geez .. was it a shocker at your lowest point in your life but hey ho .. we got a very nice letter off one guy who works for F1 and Williams dedicated a race to our deceased which was very nice touch ! | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I have an advanced directive. I dont think if you have one of those you can donate anything because they cant put you on life support to take the organs." Excuse my ignorance but what does that mean? | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"My mother in laws husband died from a sudden heart attack and two people got sight because of it. They can have any part of me because my soul would have already gone. I would like to think if my children needed a body part and I could not donate mine that someone would give them the gift if life. I think its wrong to be willing to accept but not to give. My childrens father is in agreement about donating our childrens parts too if they die. Fruit x" i am in complete agreement with you .. what I dont think is correct though is that we were left under the illusion that our loved one was on a life support machine thinking he may wake up again .. he wasnt .. he was already dead .. they made us watch this and proved it to us by shooting water into his ears from a water pistol .. there was not a flicker . but for 3 days we thought this was the case .. they were keeping him alive to get all the doctors and hospitals who were going to receive his body parts .. should we give the nod .. in place. why not just tell us the truth from the start and we stil would have agreed but not kept 24 hour vigils at the bedside | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I have an advanced directive. I dont think if you have one of those you can donate anything because they cant put you on life support to take the organs. Excuse my ignorance but what does that mean?" Oh it just means a I have a "do not resuscitate order" so that if I have a cardiac arrest or need fluids etc they will withold them, Ive asked them to do that so that they dont keep me alive, I just die naturally, and am not put on a life support machine. I think you have to be saved on a machine to have your organs harvested. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"They can have anything apart from my eyes... they are the window to your soul.. I don't care if I am dead my eyes are staying with me.. " My card says everything other than my eyes too. ![]() | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
![]() | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I have an advanced directive. I dont think if you have one of those you can donate anything because they cant put you on life support to take the organs. Excuse my ignorance but what does that mean? Oh it just means a I have a "do not resuscitate order" so that if I have a cardiac arrest or need fluids etc they will withold them, Ive asked them to do that so that they dont keep me alive, I just die naturally, and am not put on a life support machine. I think you have to be saved on a machine to have your organs harvested." quite right you do .. it can take days for all the recipients to be in place and the surgeons and when your technically dead they also have to artificially raise blood sugar and other levels to represent a living person which is apparantly a task in itself so it cant be done overnight but I take my hat off to the doctors who do have the ability to do it and long may it continue ! | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"They can have anything apart from my eyes... they are the window to your soul.. I don't care if I am dead my eyes are staying with me.. My card says everything other than my eyes too. ![]() I understand that others have and people have got sight due to eye donation.. However it is my belief to want to keep my eyes as regardless if your soul has left I still believe your eyes are the window to your soul... | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"They can have anything apart from my eyes... they are the window to your soul.. I don't care if I am dead my eyes are staying with me.. " And what lovely eyes they are, does that mean you have an even more beautiful soul?xx | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I have an advanced directive. I dont think if you have one of those you can donate anything because they cant put you on life support to take the organs. Excuse my ignorance but what does that mean? Oh it just means a I have a "do not resuscitate order" so that if I have a cardiac arrest or need fluids etc they will withold them, Ive asked them to do that so that they dont keep me alive, I just die naturally, and am not put on a life support machine. I think you have to be saved on a machine to have your organs harvested. quite right you do .. it can take days for all the recipients to be in place and the surgeons and when your technically dead they also have to artificially raise blood sugar and other levels to represent a living person which is apparantly a task in itself so it cant be done overnight but I take my hat off to the doctors who do have the ability to do it and long may it continue ! " I dont disagree with organ donation. If they could do it from my dead body that would be ok. But, if I die I dont want to be brought back as a vegetable on a machine for weeks in ITU and sadly a sideline of that is that I cant donate "/. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"They can have anything apart from my eyes... they are the window to your soul.. I don't care if I am dead my eyes are staying with me.. And what lovely eyes they are, does that mean you have an even more beautiful soul?xx" I like to think I am a good person with a good soul... ![]() | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"im on the list and id like to think god forbid if anything happened to my children I would be happy for there organs to be used but in reality i dont know if I could .." I did A lot of people who know me on here will already know as will a few others as this subject has been talked about before on here so for those who do i apologise for repeating myself ![]() | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"........... I lost my son at 20 months old and i dontaed his organs, organs for children under 5 are in the highest demande for this very reason, and 90% of children under 5 on the donor list will die due to a shortage, people dont want their baby being cut up after they die, its a very hard thing to do but i have no regrets over my choice ..............." That's the essence of altruistic donation and you have my belated thanks and condolences. It's comparitively easy for old duffers like me who've lived hard enough for two lifetimes and whose earthly remains would simply be a bit of a bother for those left behind to sign up for donation or the anatomists. To donate the organs of a precious child to unknown recipients at a time of such sadness is generosity of the highest order. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"im on the list and id like to think god forbid if anything happened to my children I would be happy for there organs to be used but in reality i dont know if I could .. I did A lot of people who know me on here will already know as will a few others as this subject has been talked about before on here so for those who do i apologise for repeating myself ![]() ![]() ![]() | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"My mum benefitted from a donor kidney about 3 years ago. She asked not to be told who it was from as she said she would struggle to accept it if she knew it had come from a young person. She actually felt selfish in taking it as she thought that someone with a longer life ahead of them would benefit more. Unfortunately the matching of an organ to an individual is not that simple and if it's right for you, it's right for you." The one thing i struggeled with was people trying to make contact with me I suppose if someone gave your child a second chance of life you would want to meet them and say thank you, i know i would, but i just couldnt, not because i didnt care how the children was doing but because i was scared, because the operations have to be done very soon after the death, his death was still very raw to me and i wasnt in the best place and i had no idea how i would react if i saw a child knowing that a part of my son was in there, i was afraid i would try to take claim to that and somehow feel the child was partly mine I know that sounds stupid now but i wasnt seeing things then as i do now so i felt for my own sanity it was best to stay away | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I am not on a register, I really should. " I went on it when I got my advantage card with boots.... | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I am not on a register, I really should. I went on it when I got my advantage card with boots.... " I need to look into it tomorrow. ![]() | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I am not on a register, I really should. I went on it when I got my advantage card with boots.... " Which particular register is that ? ![]() | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I am not on a register, I really should. I went on it when I got my advantage card with boots.... " you went on what sorry ?? | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I respect those that will donate organs. But I feel that because I will have no say as to "who" will have my parts I'de opt out." Count me on that list to , its the not knowing that bothers me ...... ![]() | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I am not on a register, I really should. I went on it when I got my advantage card with boots.... Which particular register is that ? ![]() When I got my advantage card and i filled out a form there was a section where you can say you want to go on the organ donation register i ticked yes to everything apart from my eyes | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
![]() | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I respect those that will donate organs. But I feel that because I will have no say as to "who" will have my parts I'de opt out." Heaven forbid you are ever in the situation of requiring a transplant but if you where would you be too concerned over where it came from? | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I respect those that will donate organs. But I feel that because I will have no say as to "who" will have my parts I'de opt out. Heaven forbid you are ever in the situation of requiring a transplant but if you where would you be too concerned over where it came from?" No, I would be concerned if my organs were used to save the life of a d*unk driver, or some one in prison drug dealers crack addict, "get my point now". | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I respect those that will donate organs. But I feel that because I will have no say as to "who" will have my parts I'de opt out. Heaven forbid you are ever in the situation of requiring a transplant but if you where would you be too concerned over where it came from? No, I would be concerned if my organs were used to save the life of a d*unk driver, or some one in prison drug dealers crack addict, "get my point now"." How would you know who they went to? I don't carry a donor card but saying that I don't anyone would want anything of mine. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I respect those that will donate organs. But I feel that because I will have no say as to "who" will have my parts I'de opt out. Heaven forbid you are ever in the situation of requiring a transplant but if you where would you be too concerned over where it came from? No, I would be concerned if my organs were used to save the life of a d*unk driver, or some one in prison drug dealers crack addict, "get my point now". How would you know who they went to? I don't carry a donor card but saying that I don't anyone would want anything of mine." It's hard to believe the fear of the very remote possibility of an organ going to someone the donor would deem unsuitable would outweigh the value of altruistic donation. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I respect those that will donate organs. But I feel that because I will have no say as to "who" will have my parts I'de opt out. Count me on that list to , its the not knowing that bothers me ...... ![]() just out of interest what does it matter who has them? what group of people wouldnt you be willing to help? | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I respect those that will donate organs. But I feel that because I will have no say as to "who" will have my parts I'de opt out. Heaven forbid you are ever in the situation of requiring a transplant but if you where would you be too concerned over where it came from? No, I would be concerned if my organs were used to save the life of a d*unk driver, or some one in prison drug dealers crack addict, "get my point now"." could also be a 18 year old that needs a heart thro no fault of their own that you have deprived because your scared it may go to a d*unk driver | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"My mum drummed it into us since we were little her body was being donated to medical science when time came it was very hard to do it but her wishes more important. Was strange not having funeral as such but worth it. ..........." There's no excuse not to have a wake, though. Glasgow Uni Anatomy Dept organise a non-religious service (sorry about that word) of thanksgiving every few years to remember those who donated organs or cadavers to help others or advance medical education. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I respect those that will donate organs. But I feel that because I will have no say as to "who" will have my parts I'de opt out. Heaven forbid you are ever in the situation of requiring a transplant but if you where would you be too concerned over where it came from? No, I would be concerned if my organs were used to save the life of a d*unk driver, or some one in prison drug dealers crack addict, "get my point now". How would you know who they went to? I don't carry a donor card but saying that I don't anyone would want anything of mine. It's hard to believe the fear of the very remote possibility of an organ going to someone the donor would deem unsuitable would outweigh the value of altruistic donation." With respect, I have never hurt any one in my life, when my son died the hospital asked if they could keep his heart which had been operated on three times, Hospital researchers would use it to improve treatments and medication to save lives, we had an informed choice which we were glad to allow. The driver that hit him din't give him that choice which is where my fear comes from. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"............ The driver that hit him din't give him that choice which is where my fear comes from." Whilst I cannot comprehend your attitude, might it not be better to prolong the life of the driver in order that he might reflect at length on his/ her folly? | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I respect those that will donate organs. But I feel that because I will have no say as to "who" will have my parts I'de opt out. Heaven forbid you are ever in the situation of requiring a transplant but if you where would you be too concerned over where it came from? No, I would be concerned if my organs were used to save the life of a d*unk driver, or some one in prison drug dealers crack addict, "get my point now". How would you know who they went to? I don't carry a donor card but saying that I don't anyone would want anything of mine. It's hard to believe the fear of the very remote possibility of an organ going to someone the donor would deem unsuitable would outweigh the value of altruistic donation. With respect, I have never hurt any one in my life, when my son died the hospital asked if they could keep his heart which had been operated on three times, Hospital researchers would use it to improve treatments and medication to save lives, we had an informed choice which we were glad to allow. The driver that hit him din't give him that choice which is where my fear comes from." So you will punish the many worthy to spite the few non worthy? | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"sorry got to add to that again but i find the term d*unk diver very open im not by any stroke of the imagination saying i agree with drinking and driving let me make that clear but this d*unk driver could be your 20 year old daughter thats been out with her boyfriend and they have had a argument thats got a little heated so she has stupidly got in the car and gone home to get away from him, had a crash on the way and ended up in hospital, would you tell the Dr not to save her because of one stupid mistake? Lets assum noone else was killed in this crash befor anyone starts giving me the low down on drinking and driving lol the example was for the thread purpose only" Everyone has a choice....... | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
".......... The driver that hit him din't give him that choice which is where my fear comes from. So you will punish the many worthy to spite the few non worthy?" So you will punish the many worthy for the remote possibility of spiting the non worthy. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
".......... The driver that hit him din't give him that choice which is where my fear comes from. So you will punish the many worthy to spite the few non worthy? So you will punish the many worthy for the remote possibility of spiting the non worthy." WTF was that all about? LoL | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
".......... The driver that hit him din't give him that choice which is where my fear comes from. So you will punish the many worthy to spite the few non worthy? So you will punish the many worthy for the remote possibility of spiting the non worthy." to be fair, after reading the guys posts, untill you have been thro what he has you couldnt possabily know how you would feel in his situation When i donated my sons organs i didnt have this to worry about this as his organs could only go to children under 5, had he be been a adult and killed by someone would i feel the same knowing he could be saving his killer or someone on a equal status? i dont know, sitting here im thinking yes i would but if i was really given that choice to make whos to say i would still feel the same | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
".......... The driver that hit him din't give him that choice which is where my fear comes from. So you will punish the many worthy to spite the few non worthy? So you will punish the many worthy for the remote possibility of spiting the non worthy. WTF was that all about? LoL" The likelihood of a donated organ going to a serial killer, a rapist, a child molester or a d*unk driver is slim. Donated organs are in VERY short supply. Does it make sense to decline to donate JUST IN CASE it goes somewhere a donor wouldn't approve of? | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
".......... The driver that hit him din't give him that choice which is where my fear comes from. So you will punish the many worthy to spite the few non worthy? So you will punish the many worthy for the remote possibility of spiting the non worthy. WTF was that all about? LoL The likelihood of a donated organ going to a serial killer, a rapist, a child molester or a d*unk driver is slim. Donated organs are in VERY short supply. Does it make sense to decline to donate JUST IN CASE it goes somewhere a donor wouldn't approve of?" Maybe I am paranoid, It's some thing you cant judge untill it's happend to you, with your loved one laying infront of you life less and you feel your life has just been ripped out of you, it's not an easy choice when your upset and angry. In my case I was informed what his heart would be used for, that was all i needed. I believe every one should have that informed choice, which should be respected wether you agree or not. It's not punishing anyone, that implies your harming some one for some thing they have done to you. It's about dealing with your own greif. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"They can have anything apart from my eyes... they are the window to your soul.. I don't care if I am dead my eyes are staying with me.. " You do know that undertakers remove the eyes don't you? | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"They can have anything apart from my eyes... they are the window to your soul.. I don't care if I am dead my eyes are staying with me.. You do know that undertakers remove the eyes don't you?" No they dont! They place inserts on top of the eyes due to them sinking... | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"My mum drummed into us from early she was donating her body to medical science. When she died i was so close to not give the ok but did as it was her wish and really i was being selfish. I am on organ donor list and whilst each have own _iews i think folk that do not are being a tad selfish. Would the same folk turn down organ transplant in the event of themselves or family member being in need of one, somehow i doubt it. It should be case you have opt out of organ donation not opt in. What greater gift can there be than potentially saving soneone elses life after your own ends." I can empathise with your situation - really I can. That said, I feel it is taking away an element of my libery assuming that I am happy to be a donor and I would not subscribe to that system at all. I feel I should have the choice to opt in - which is very unlikely in my and my family's case. Also, I dont think you can simply label people as selfish if they choose to have a different stance. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"They can have anything apart from my eyes... they are the window to your soul.. I don't care if I am dead my eyes are staying with me.. I think the exact same thing... Spooky ![]() Me too ![]() ![]() | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
![]() | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"I'm very grateful to everyone on the list at sometime in the future I am going to need a kidney transplant So thank you everyone for making the chances of getting one a lot higher D xxx" wish you all the very best with that ![]() | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"having donated a family members organs previously " You are a very brave person. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"can you register online? Ive taken ten pints of blood from the stock so its only fare to give a little somthing back when im gone! " Yes. organdonation dot nhs dot uk | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"What would worry me with the opt out system is the short time scale in which a decision has to be made - how would medical staff be sure that they are not taking organs from somebody who has not given consent? To me the assumption I am happy to be a donor unless proven otherwise does feel like an infringement on my rights." They would just check the register the same way they check now to see if you have opted in. The big problem now is that even if you are on the register they still have to get consent from next of kin at a very sad time, | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"What would worry me with the opt out system is the short time scale in which a decision has to be made - how would medical staff be sure that they are not taking organs from somebody who has not given consent? To me the assumption I am happy to be a donor unless proven otherwise does feel like an infringement on my rights. They would just check the register the same way they check now to see if you have opted in. The big problem now is that even if you are on the register they still have to get consent from next of kin at a very sad time," So what you are saying is, they check against the register and if you have opted out then that is the end of it. If you have not really thought about it that would be taken as implied consent? | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
".............So what you are saying is, they check against the register and if you have opted out then that is the end of it. If you have not really thought about it that would be taken as implied consent? " That's how I reckon it'd work. That's why I'm not sure it's the answer. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
".............So what you are saying is, they check against the register and if you have opted out then that is the end of it. If you have not really thought about it that would be taken as implied consent? That's how I reckon it'd work. That's why I'm not sure it's the answer." Apart from my own feelings and decision on this, I am wondering about the most people, young people going about their business not even remotely considering they might suddenly die. That is what I meant with not really having reflected on soemthing that may happen without consent if that makes sense. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"What would worry me with the opt out system is the short time scale in which a decision has to be made - how would medical staff be sure that they are not taking organs from somebody who has not given consent? To me the assumption I am happy to be a donor unless proven otherwise does feel like an infringement on my rights. They would just check the register the same way they check now to see if you have opted in. The big problem now is that even if you are on the register they still have to get consent from next of kin at a very sad time, So what you are saying is, they check against the register and if you have opted out then that is the end of it. If you have not really thought about it that would be taken as implied consent? " But if it was an opt out system that was well publicised why would you not think about it? I can see that there would have to be safeguards for minors and other people that were deemed not fit to make a decision. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"What would worry me with the opt out system is the short time scale in which a decision has to be made - how would medical staff be sure that they are not taking organs from somebody who has not given consent? To me the assumption I am happy to be a donor unless proven otherwise does feel like an infringement on my rights. They would just check the register the same way they check now to see if you have opted in. The big problem now is that even if you are on the register they still have to get consent from next of kin at a very sad time, So what you are saying is, they check against the register and if you have opted out then that is the end of it. If you have not really thought about it that would be taken as implied consent? But if it was an opt out system that was well publicised why would you not think about it? I can see that there would have to be safeguards for minors and other people that were deemed not fit to make a decision." I am of course just talking about my perspective - I find it a bit unacceptable I guess that consent is assumed unless stated otherwise. It just does not sit right with me. Not just on this issue - but with any issue I think I want to be asked rather than having an assumption made about me. I think that is what bugs me really? | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"If any guy wants to give me their Organ (especially large ones) then please contact me." ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
![]() | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
| |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
" Mainly I am shocked, here in the US family is not required to watch, to me that is wrong. Beyond that, don't go to an opt out system. People should make that choice, humans do not belong to the state and should not be treated that way.. just my opinion. " Spot on - I know now why I am uncomfortable with the idea - you have just put your finger on the file. Thanks ![]() | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"im on the list and id like to think god forbid if anything happened to my children I would be happy for there organs to be used but in reality i dont know if I could .." I think that decision should be made in the cold light of day and then stuck to rather than face that decision at the time of death when emotionally you would all over the place. Dave | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"Despite being in favour of organ donation I don't think we should move to an 'opt-out' situation. I would, however, remove the next of kin's right of veto. If someone has made the generous decision to donate, that should be it." Definitely agree with this...Do think it needs to stay as opt in but don't agree that next of kin can say no to my wishes when I no longer have a say in it. I'm confident anything of mine that can be used after my death will be ok'd by my family as we are all on the list but I don't think it's fair that they have to effectively make that decision again when I'm gone x | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
"can you register online? Ive taken ten pints of blood from the stock so its only fare to give a little somthing back when im gone! Yes. organdonation dot nhs dot uk" You can also add yourself to the register via your boots advantage card believe it or not...and I think more people are likely to carry that than a donor card myself. I'm on both lists to be on the safe side, I donate blood too and through that I'm on the bone marrow donor list too...I'm a very giving person!! | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
" I am of course just talking about my perspective - I find it a bit unacceptable I guess that consent is assumed unless stated otherwise. It just does not sit right with me. Not just on this issue - but with any issue I think I want to be asked rather than having an assumption made about me. I think that is what bugs me really?" Hmm, that made me think. Maybe I am just seeing this from my perspective i.e. once I'm dead it's just a piece of meat and if someone can use a bit then happy days. Maybe opt in with no veto for the next of kin might be the way to go. That way it wouldn't have to be mentioned at the time and the team could just get on with it. | |||
Reply privately | Reply in forum | Reply +quote |
Post new Message to Thread |
back to top | ![]() |