FabSwingers.com mobile

Already registered?
Login here

Back to forum list
Back to The Lounge

PUBS LOST

Jump to newest
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago

How many pubs have we lost since Tony Blair banned smoking Hospitality/Pubs got the rough end of covid.

A community hub lost

After a 20 year battle my local pub the ploughman has lost its battle with Tesco to turn the pub into a car park x

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *onicZMan
over a year ago

Nottinghamshire

There is a website called the lost pubs project. I've contributed a fair few photos and paragraphs to their cause

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago

Along with the smoke and mirrors booze tax 10.1% another hit x

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,

Probably tens of thousands.They were closing at a rate of about 50 a week.For many communities the local closing was the end of socialising for a lot of residents.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago

[Removed by poster at 01/08/23 23:39:33]

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago

100 percent x

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *hirleyMan
over a year ago

somewhere

What a crock, I'd not go anywhere that had smoking now.

Pubs closing is a result of many things. I can tell you know nothing about how these establiments are run and the breweries fleecing people.

Venture capitalism is what killed a lot of those pubs! Check your notes on which cunting PM brought that in!!!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *penbicoupleCouple
over a year ago

Northampton

I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *penbicoupleCouple
over a year ago

Northampton


"WlVenture capitalism is what killed a lot of those pubs! Check your notes on which cunting PM brought that in!!!"

Right on all counts

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago


"WlVenture capitalism is what killed a lot of those pubs! Check your notes on which cunting PM brought that in!!!

Right on all counts "

Seriously....

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

I just think pub culture has changed, the old man's local died off because better options came alone and millennials grew up and lost that drinking culture. I remember my Mum and Dad having it as their weekly or mid week social event, it was a change from sitting in and watching corrie or eastenders. Now we have entertainment in the palm of our hands, we would rather go and drink at a bar with good food, live music, quirky drinks or atmosphere.

I am from York and it has over 365 bars and pubs. The reason is they all adapted to tourism, we have Gin bars, themed speakeasys, bars with bowling and botanical drinks.

Honestly if I want a pint I buy a pint, I've never gone, I would love a bevvy but I am sticking with water because of bloody taxes.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *aitonelMan
over a year ago

Travelling


"WlVenture capitalism is what killed a lot of those pubs! Check your notes on which cunting PM brought that in!!!

Right on all counts

Seriously...."

Excellent grade A rebuttal!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend. "

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago


"I just think pub culture has changed, the old man's local died off because better options came alone and millennials grew up and lost that drinking culture. I remember my Mum and Dad having it as their weekly or mid week social event, it was a change from sitting in and watching corrie or eastenders. Now we have entertainment in the palm of our hands, we would rather go and drink at a bar with good food, live music, quirky drinks or atmosphere.

I am from York and it has over 365 bars and pubs. The reason is they all adapted to tourism, we have Gin bars, themed speakeasys, bars with bowling and botanical drinks.

Honestly if I want a pint I buy a pint, I've never gone, I would love a bevvy but I am sticking with water because of bloody taxes. "

Great input thank you on the day they increased alcohol tax at the Great British beer fest x

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x"

I'm sure many people value their religious community more than most people value pubs.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inky_couple2020Couple
over a year ago

North West


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x"

Heavens above, not mosques! Deary me.

I've lived in various communities over the course of my life. Not once have I felt the need for a pub. We lived in our previous house for 14yrs and don't recall ever going into a pub in that area. Some of the coffee places, yes.

We've been here since Feb this year and again, a pub free existence. I'd rather have more shops that I can get into please.

And I grew up (primary school) in a community with greater focus on the mosque than the pub. Guess what? It was a normal, ordinary community.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

I'm sure many people value their religious community more than most people value pubs."

Even God enjoyed a glass of wine x a church, music, alcohol, community, pub, school, doctors, a community lost x

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)

I'm quite engaged in my community and I, too, have a pub free existence. To me community means knowing the people around you and working towards a common good.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques"

And boom goes the dynamite...

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *imi_RougeWoman
over a year ago

Portsmouth

I kind of agree with Quinn, I don't know why people are so obsessed with pubs... There are so many other options for entertainment and leisure these days.

And why alcohol is held in such high regard... Moaning about the prices going up. At least people won't be drinking themselves into an early grave

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Heavens above, not mosques! Deary me.

I've lived in various communities over the course of my life. Not once have I felt the need for a pub. We lived in our previous house for 14yrs and don't recall ever going into a pub in that area. Some of the coffee places, yes.

We've been here since Feb this year and again, a pub free existence. I'd rather have more shops that I can get into please.

And I grew up (primary school) in a community with greater focus on the mosque than the pub. Guess what? It was a normal, ordinary community. "

And that is your opinion.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inky_couple2020Couple
over a year ago

North West


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

I'm sure many people value their religious community more than most people value pubs.

Even God enjoyed a glass of wine x a church, music, alcohol, community, pub, school, doctors, a community lost x"

Where in the Bible did God go to the pub, doctors or church?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inky_couple2020Couple
over a year ago

North West


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Heavens above, not mosques! Deary me.

I've lived in various communities over the course of my life. Not once have I felt the need for a pub. We lived in our previous house for 14yrs and don't recall ever going into a pub in that area. Some of the coffee places, yes.

We've been here since Feb this year and again, a pub free existence. I'd rather have more shops that I can get into please.

And I grew up (primary school) in a community with greater focus on the mosque than the pub. Guess what? It was a normal, ordinary community.

And that is your opinion."

Actually not an opinion. The fact is neither of us set foot in a pub across 14yr and neither have we since arriving here. Mr KC did go to pubs at our address prior but that was as a student and was in a university city centre. It was certainly not the centre of a specific community.

And my childhood neighbourhood was indeed very ordinary and normal, like any other British area.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *aitonelMan
over a year ago

Travelling

Plenty of communities all over the world, all over the god damn world, that do perfectly fine without a pub.

And it's a wonderful thing to see.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

I'm sure many people value their religious community more than most people value pubs.

Even God enjoyed a glass of wine x a church, music, alcohol, community, pub, school, doctors, a community lost x"

Wine as described in the Bible was partly a way to decontaminate water

I'm afraid I value the mosque much more than the pub. Mosques bring communities together, encourage charitable work, etc.

I don't see a tangible benefit to pubs.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *imi_RougeWoman
over a year ago

Portsmouth


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x"

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago


"I'm quite engaged in my community and I, too, have a pub free existence. To me community means knowing the people around you and working towards a common good. "

I live in a village we still have the Werrington carnival, the community church where do we all gather at the pub or the tea room across the road which becomes a speak easy at night/weekends. It's all about choice x

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend. "

The smoking ban had a big effect,we lost three pubs,not because of it entirely but as a contributing factor.Some smokers stopped going out.Some non smokers stopped coming because the smokers were outside socialising,inside was dead.No new non smoking customers arrived.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub."

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *andycandy88Woman
over a year ago

Northolt

Why bash someone for their views, everyone's views comes from their own walk of life and experiences goodness gracious me.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub."

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community."

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown. "

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

WTF does a mosque have to do with it, what Red Lion pub now has a minaret? Honestly if a buildings selling point is the communal spreading or harmful carcinogenics and the ability to get rat arsed I am glad they are closing. Also taxes are used to fund schools, hospitals, roads, libraries. They aren't these demonic things, a 10% rise in alcohol tax probably funded a Hepatology unit at your local hospital to pay for the operations and medicine linked to liver disease.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker."

Staff remain a finite resource, and treatment doesn't happen without them.

We should all exercise personal responsibility and be more like the people in the mosque

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference."

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker."

You know a chest xray costs a GP or NHS unit £80, the most simple blood test costs £25. You know how many people have them everyday? A Phlebotomist takes 100-150 blood samples each day, most units have 3-6 Phlebotomists, all taking bloods. A radiographer takes around 80 chest xrays a day. And when are you ever given a bill? Never. Because taxes pay for them. The more people drinking and smoking equals more patients which equals more blood tests which equal more taxes.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago


"WTF does a mosque have to do with it, what Red Lion pub now has a minaret? Honestly if a buildings selling point is the communal spreading or harmful carcinogenics and the ability to get rat arsed I am glad they are closing. Also taxes are used to fund schools, hospitals, roads, libraries. They aren't these demonic things, a 10% rise in alcohol tax probably funded a Hepatology unit at your local hospital to pay for the operations and medicine linked to liver disease."

You may question the chemists that have brought the GPs and turned them in to drug pushers and told us alcohol was bad x

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house."

Why is a pub necessary for talking or getting out of the house? There are countless other ways to do that.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

Staff remain a finite resource, and treatment doesn't happen without them.

We should all exercise personal responsibility and be more like the people in the mosque "

If you want to preach mosqueology start a thread on the subject,this is about pubs closing and the effect on the community

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

You know a chest xray costs a GP or NHS unit £80, the most simple blood test costs £25. You know how many people have them everyday? A Phlebotomist takes 100-150 blood samples each day, most units have 3-6 Phlebotomists, all taking bloods. A radiographer takes around 80 chest xrays a day. And when are you ever given a bill? Never. Because taxes pay for them. The more people drinking and smoking equals more patients which equals more blood tests which equal more taxes.

"

Taxes also pay to stitch up the idiots who fight outside pubs late at night

Signed, I overlook a pub when I'm trying to sleep

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *aitonelMan
over a year ago

Travelling

All I see about the smoking ban is smokers being whiney and choosing to not support pubs regardless. They essentially picked their own habit over supporting a "community pub", simply screams to me they didn't really care much for the pub and it's business in the first place.

So smokers themselves are the issue, not the ban.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inky_couple2020Couple
over a year ago

North West


"WTF does a mosque have to do with it, what Red Lion pub now has a minaret? Honestly if a buildings selling point is the communal spreading or harmful carcinogenics and the ability to get rat arsed I am glad they are closing. Also taxes are used to fund schools, hospitals, roads, libraries. They aren't these demonic things, a 10% rise in alcohol tax probably funded a Hepatology unit at your local hospital to pay for the operations and medicine linked to liver disease.

You may question the chemists that have brought the GPs and turned them in to drug pushers and told us alcohol was bad x"

Alcohol definitely isn't healthy. Like many noxious substances, it can be tolerated at low doses. But in the quantities many people consume it, it's definitely unhealthy. That's well accepted.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Work for the NHS and you realise free healthcare costs a shit ton and it has to come from somewhere. It costs £184m to fund the NHS each day. On everage each person costs the NHS £4000 a year.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house.

Why is a pub necessary for talking or getting out of the house? There are countless other ways to do that."

Obviously you don't live in a small community which funnily enough doesn't have the same socialising options as a town or city because it's errr.....small.Get out of your bubble into the wider world a bit more.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

Staff remain a finite resource, and treatment doesn't happen without them.

We should all exercise personal responsibility and be more like the people in the mosque

If you want to preach mosqueology start a thread on the subject,this is about pubs closing and the effect on the community"

The OP bemoans loss of community and specifically mentioned mosques replacing breweries.

She should turn that smile upside down. Mosques are excellent at building community for people of all ages, and do excellent work outside their attendees as well

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house.

Why is a pub necessary for talking or getting out of the house? There are countless other ways to do that.

Obviously you don't live in a small community which funnily enough doesn't have the same socialising options as a town or city because it's errr.....small.Get out of your bubble into the wider world a bit more."

A community so small you can't go out walking? Do you live in Antarctica?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

You know a chest xray costs a GP or NHS unit £80, the most simple blood test costs £25. You know how many people have them everyday? A Phlebotomist takes 100-150 blood samples each day, most units have 3-6 Phlebotomists, all taking bloods. A radiographer takes around 80 chest xrays a day. And when are you ever given a bill? Never. Because taxes pay for them. The more people drinking and smoking equals more patients which equals more blood tests which equal more taxes.

Taxes also pay to stitch up the idiots who fight outside pubs late at night

Signed, I overlook a pub when I'm trying to sleep "

So you are anti pub because one disturbs you.Truth revealed.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,

[Removed by poster at 02/08/23 00:31:52]

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *929Man
over a year ago

newcastle

Bedlington was great at one joint packed Friday and Saturday night even Thursday was busy now there is maybe less than a third of the pubs still open and only ever gets busy if there is some sort of event on it’s sad was great in it’s day

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

Staff remain a finite resource, and treatment doesn't happen without them.

We should all exercise personal responsibility and be more like the people in the mosque

If you want to preach mosqueology start a thread on the subject,this is about pubs closing and the effect on the community"

FYI mosqueology isn't a word. Islamology is the study of how people relate to Islam. Perhaps if Buxton had more mosques and less pubs you would know that..

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house.

Why is a pub necessary for talking or getting out of the house? There are countless other ways to do that.

Obviously you don't live in a small community which funnily enough doesn't have the same socialising options as a town or city because it's errr.....small.Get out of your bubble into the wider world a bit more.

A community so small you can't go out walking? Do you live in Antarctica?"

Who goes walking in the pissing rain or bad weather to socialise?

Do you expect elderly people to go walking just to socialise?You really need to get out of your city bubble.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

You know a chest xray costs a GP or NHS unit £80, the most simple blood test costs £25. You know how many people have them everyday? A Phlebotomist takes 100-150 blood samples each day, most units have 3-6 Phlebotomists, all taking bloods. A radiographer takes around 80 chest xrays a day. And when are you ever given a bill? Never. Because taxes pay for them. The more people drinking and smoking equals more patients which equals more blood tests which equal more taxes.

Taxes also pay to stitch up the idiots who fight outside pubs late at night

Signed, I overlook a pub when I'm trying to sleep

So you are anti pub because one disturbs you.Truth revealed."

No. I just think that relying on a business to provide community is destined to fail. That over consumption of alcohol is dangerous. That smoking indoors in public is anti social.

I prefer mosques.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

Staff remain a finite resource, and treatment doesn't happen without them.

We should all exercise personal responsibility and be more like the people in the mosque

If you want to preach mosqueology start a thread on the subject,this is about pubs closing and the effect on the community

FYI mosqueology isn't a word. Islamology is the study of how people relate to Islam. Perhaps if Buxton had more mosques and less pubs you would know that.."

I do know that mosqueology isn't a word thank you,seems you don't know what sarcasm is,and it's fewer pubs not less.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,

[Removed by poster at 02/08/23 00:38:37]

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago


"Work for the NHS and you realise free healthcare costs a shit ton and it has to come from somewhere. It costs £184m to fund the NHS each day. On everage each person costs the NHS £4000 a year. "

My friends dog 11 years old who has cancer. For a simple scan £4000, for an operation it £10000. How is that fair x

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house.

Why is a pub necessary for talking or getting out of the house? There are countless other ways to do that.

Obviously you don't live in a small community which funnily enough doesn't have the same socialising options as a town or city because it's errr.....small.Get out of your bubble into the wider world a bit more.

A community so small you can't go out walking? Do you live in Antarctica?

Who goes walking in the pissing rain or bad weather to socialise?

Do you expect elderly people to go walking just to socialise?You really need to get out of your city bubble."

People do do that, yes.

In my city bubble we have organisations who facilitate elderly people socialising in places like church halls. Which provide safeguarding and transport and don't do it for a profit motive. It'd be more challenging in less densely populated areas, but certainly not impossible.

In my city bubble we don't need pubs to have community spirit. Maybe ask the mosque how it's done

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

Staff remain a finite resource, and treatment doesn't happen without them.

We should all exercise personal responsibility and be more like the people in the mosque

If you want to preach mosqueology start a thread on the subject,this is about pubs closing and the effect on the community

The OP bemoans loss of community and specifically mentioned mosques replacing breweries.

She should turn that smile upside down. Mosques are excellent at building community for people of all ages, and do excellent work outside their attendees as well "

A contributing factor x

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

You know a chest xray costs a GP or NHS unit £80, the most simple blood test costs £25. You know how many people have them everyday? A Phlebotomist takes 100-150 blood samples each day, most units have 3-6 Phlebotomists, all taking bloods. A radiographer takes around 80 chest xrays a day. And when are you ever given a bill? Never. Because taxes pay for them. The more people drinking and smoking equals more patients which equals more blood tests which equal more taxes.

Taxes also pay to stitch up the idiots who fight outside pubs late at night

Signed, I overlook a pub when I'm trying to sleep

So you are anti pub because one disturbs you.Truth revealed.

No. I just think that relying on a business to provide community is destined to fail. That over consumption of alcohol is dangerous. That smoking indoors in public is anti social.

I prefer mosques."

Pubs have provided community for centuries and continue to do so in many places.Hardly failure.I think most adults know over consumption is dangerous.we don't need patronising lectures on the subject.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

Staff remain a finite resource, and treatment doesn't happen without them.

We should all exercise personal responsibility and be more like the people in the mosque

If you want to preach mosqueology start a thread on the subject,this is about pubs closing and the effect on the community

FYI mosqueology isn't a word. Islamology is the study of how people relate to Islam. Perhaps if Buxton had more mosques and less pubs you would know that..

I do know that mosqueology isn't a word thank you,seems you don't know what sarcasm is,and it's fewer pubs not less."

I often go to the 10 Items or less, counter rather than the 10 items or fewer counter. I understand that fewer is a numerical drop, however less is also acceptable as the rule has changed as language has developed

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

Staff remain a finite resource, and treatment doesn't happen without them.

We should all exercise personal responsibility and be more like the people in the mosque

If you want to preach mosqueology start a thread on the subject,this is about pubs closing and the effect on the community

The OP bemoans loss of community and specifically mentioned mosques replacing breweries.

She should turn that smile upside down. Mosques are excellent at building community for people of all ages, and do excellent work outside their attendees as well

A contributing factor x"

But mosques do the work needed to bring community together! They go out of their way to do so.

Why is charitable work and outreach, plus a free gathering place once a week, not a benefit to the community? That's community in action

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *isterPepperMan
over a year ago

Central Swindon

I value pubs. Unfortunately society no longer does the way that it once did. Therefore they close. This is because they are not as important as they once were. If you believe in capitalism then you believe in the closure of loss-making, unviable businesses.

This has little to do with smoking. Most pubs have long, long, long since learnt ways to accommodate smokers comfortably on or adjacent to the premises. You may know of some people who no longer visit the pub because they want to smoke but refuse to do so outside, but that is anecdotal and, to be blunt, negligible.

Some of the reasons pubs are suffering are political, others are just part of social change.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inky_couple2020Couple
over a year ago

North West


"Work for the NHS and you realise free healthcare costs a shit ton and it has to come from somewhere. It costs £184m to fund the NHS each day. On everage each person costs the NHS £4000 a year.

My friends dog 11 years old who has cancer. For a simple scan £4000, for an operation it £10000. How is that fair x"

That's what private healthcare would cost. My future hysterectomy will cost me nothing on the day but if I went private, I could expect to pay £7000-8000. I might ask a vet to do it actually, it'd be much cheaper.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

You know a chest xray costs a GP or NHS unit £80, the most simple blood test costs £25. You know how many people have them everyday? A Phlebotomist takes 100-150 blood samples each day, most units have 3-6 Phlebotomists, all taking bloods. A radiographer takes around 80 chest xrays a day. And when are you ever given a bill? Never. Because taxes pay for them. The more people drinking and smoking equals more patients which equals more blood tests which equal more taxes.

Taxes also pay to stitch up the idiots who fight outside pubs late at night

Signed, I overlook a pub when I'm trying to sleep

So you are anti pub because one disturbs you.Truth revealed.

No. I just think that relying on a business to provide community is destined to fail. That over consumption of alcohol is dangerous. That smoking indoors in public is anti social.

I prefer mosques.

Pubs have provided community for centuries and continue to do so in many places.Hardly failure.I think most adults know over consumption is dangerous.we don't need patronising lectures on the subject."

I apologise if you think I was lecturing you on the topic. I was not.

I just see pubs as another institution that has had its time and is not to be mourned.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

You know a chest xray costs a GP or NHS unit £80, the most simple blood test costs £25. You know how many people have them everyday? A Phlebotomist takes 100-150 blood samples each day, most units have 3-6 Phlebotomists, all taking bloods. A radiographer takes around 80 chest xrays a day. And when are you ever given a bill? Never. Because taxes pay for them. The more people drinking and smoking equals more patients which equals more blood tests which equal more taxes.

Taxes also pay to stitch up the idiots who fight outside pubs late at night

Signed, I overlook a pub when I'm trying to sleep

So you are anti pub because one disturbs you.Truth revealed.

No. I just think that relying on a business to provide community is destined to fail. That over consumption of alcohol is dangerous. That smoking indoors in public is anti social.

I prefer mosques.

Pubs have provided community for centuries and continue to do so in many places.Hardly failure.I think most adults know over consumption is dangerous.we don't need patronising lectures on the subject."

The response was to the 'How is it a burden on the NHS' comment. You suggested £1 in tax would be suitable for £2 treatment. I was simply advising that £1 in tax is like throwing a sausage down an alleyway.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house.

Why is a pub necessary for talking or getting out of the house? There are countless other ways to do that.

Obviously you don't live in a small community which funnily enough doesn't have the same socialising options as a town or city because it's errr.....small.Get out of your bubble into the wider world a bit more.

A community so small you can't go out walking? Do you live in Antarctica?

Who goes walking in the pissing rain or bad weather to socialise?

Do you expect elderly people to go walking just to socialise?You really need to get out of your city bubble.

People do do that, yes.

In my city bubble we have organisations who facilitate elderly people socialising in places like church halls. Which provide safeguarding and transport and don't do it for a profit motive. It'd be more challenging in less densely populated areas, but certainly not impossible.

In my city bubble we don't need pubs to have community spirit. Maybe ask the mosque how it's done "

Once again you fail to understand that not everywhere has churches open or community transport.Get out of your bubble you might realise that.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *moochyvibesMan
over a year ago

Nearby

Just watched GB news not long ago they were mentioning so many closed in the last 6 months and property developers changing then to apartments...

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house.

Why is a pub necessary for talking or getting out of the house? There are countless other ways to do that.

Obviously you don't live in a small community which funnily enough doesn't have the same socialising options as a town or city because it's errr.....small.Get out of your bubble into the wider world a bit more.

A community so small you can't go out walking? Do you live in Antarctica?

Who goes walking in the pissing rain or bad weather to socialise?

Do you expect elderly people to go walking just to socialise?You really need to get out of your city bubble.

People do do that, yes.

In my city bubble we have organisations who facilitate elderly people socialising in places like church halls. Which provide safeguarding and transport and don't do it for a profit motive. It'd be more challenging in less densely populated areas, but certainly not impossible.

In my city bubble we don't need pubs to have community spirit. Maybe ask the mosque how it's done

Once again you fail to understand that not everywhere has churches open or community transport.Get out of your bubble you might realise that."

So you see, the way that it happened in my community was people. Community minded people. Getting together and making it happen. With the spaces they do have and the cars that people already own. I thought people owned more cars outside of cities?

I'm sorry if you don't have any community minded people where you are though. That must be difficult. I'm not sure how a pub would help

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *isterPepperMan
over a year ago

Central Swindon

And whatever the problem is, let me tell you, it ain’t mosques for goodness sake

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house.

Why is a pub necessary for talking or getting out of the house? There are countless other ways to do that.

Obviously you don't live in a small community which funnily enough doesn't have the same socialising options as a town or city because it's errr.....small.Get out of your bubble into the wider world a bit more.

A community so small you can't go out walking? Do you live in Antarctica?

Who goes walking in the pissing rain or bad weather to socialise?

Do you expect elderly people to go walking just to socialise?You really need to get out of your city bubble.

People do do that, yes.

In my city bubble we have organisations who facilitate elderly people socialising in places like church halls. Which provide safeguarding and transport and don't do it for a profit motive. It'd be more challenging in less densely populated areas, but certainly not impossible.

In my city bubble we don't need pubs to have community spirit. Maybe ask the mosque how it's done

Once again you fail to understand that not everywhere has churches open or community transport.Get out of your bubble you might realise that."

Not everywhere has pubs now either lol

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inky_couple2020Couple
over a year ago

North West


"Just watched GB news not long ago they were mentioning so many closed in the last 6 months and property developers changing then to apartments... "

We do need more housing and better to convert existing buildings rather than build on the green belt. Unfortunately not enough of the development will be affordable.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

You know a chest xray costs a GP or NHS unit £80, the most simple blood test costs £25. You know how many people have them everyday? A Phlebotomist takes 100-150 blood samples each day, most units have 3-6 Phlebotomists, all taking bloods. A radiographer takes around 80 chest xrays a day. And when are you ever given a bill? Never. Because taxes pay for them. The more people drinking and smoking equals more patients which equals more blood tests which equal more taxes.

Taxes also pay to stitch up the idiots who fight outside pubs late at night

Signed, I overlook a pub when I'm trying to sleep

So you are anti pub because one disturbs you.Truth revealed.

No. I just think that relying on a business to provide community is destined to fail. That over consumption of alcohol is dangerous. That smoking indoors in public is anti social.

I prefer mosques.

Pubs have provided community for centuries and continue to do so in many places.Hardly failure.I think most adults know over consumption is dangerous.we don't need patronising lectures on the subject.

The response was to the 'How is it a burden on the NHS' comment. You suggested £1 in tax would be suitable for £2 treatment. I was simply advising that £1 in tax is like throwing a sausage down an alleyway. "

I said £1 of treatment,the smoker paid £3 in tax.If that money isn't making it to the frontline that's the fault of the Treasury.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

Staff remain a finite resource, and treatment doesn't happen without them.

We should all exercise personal responsibility and be more like the people in the mosque

If you want to preach mosqueology start a thread on the subject,this is about pubs closing and the effect on the community

The OP bemoans loss of community and specifically mentioned mosques replacing breweries.

She should turn that smile upside down. Mosques are excellent at building community for people of all ages, and do excellent work outside their attendees as well

A contributing factor x

But mosques do the work needed to bring community together! They go out of their way to do so.

Why is charitable work and outreach, plus a free gathering place once a week, not a benefit to the community? That's community in action "

I dare you to look a non for profit organisations and who are the top earners in fact I double dare you x

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

Staff remain a finite resource, and treatment doesn't happen without them.

We should all exercise personal responsibility and be more like the people in the mosque

If you want to preach mosqueology start a thread on the subject,this is about pubs closing and the effect on the community

The OP bemoans loss of community and specifically mentioned mosques replacing breweries.

She should turn that smile upside down. Mosques are excellent at building community for people of all ages, and do excellent work outside their attendees as well

A contributing factor x

But mosques do the work needed to bring community together! They go out of their way to do so.

Why is charitable work and outreach, plus a free gathering place once a week, not a benefit to the community? That's community in action

I dare you to look a non for profit organisations and who are the top earners in fact I double dare you x"

What does that have to do with the price of tea in China?

During lockdown the local mosque looked out for the health of the local community by sending vitamins to the charity I volunteer with. They got nothing from it other than thanks.

That's community mindedness. My local mosque does it all the time in all sorts of ways.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

Staff remain a finite resource, and treatment doesn't happen without them.

We should all exercise personal responsibility and be more like the people in the mosque

If you want to preach mosqueology start a thread on the subject,this is about pubs closing and the effect on the community

The OP bemoans loss of community and specifically mentioned mosques replacing breweries.

She should turn that smile upside down. Mosques are excellent at building community for people of all ages, and do excellent work outside their attendees as well

A contributing factor x

But mosques do the work needed to bring community together! They go out of their way to do so.

Why is charitable work and outreach, plus a free gathering place once a week, not a benefit to the community? That's community in action

I dare you to look a non for profit organisations and who are the top earners in fact I double dare you x"

SAVE THE CHILDREN INTERNATIONAL £988,001,224

THE ARTS COUNCIL OF ENGLAND £941,845,043

THE BRITISH COUNCIL £896,655,974

CANCER RESEARCH UK £668,369,451

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house.

Why is a pub necessary for talking or getting out of the house? There are countless other ways to do that.

Obviously you don't live in a small community which funnily enough doesn't have the same socialising options as a town or city because it's errr.....small.Get out of your bubble into the wider world a bit more.

A community so small you can't go out walking? Do you live in Antarctica?

Who goes walking in the pissing rain or bad weather to socialise?

Do you expect elderly people to go walking just to socialise?You really need to get out of your city bubble.

People do do that, yes.

In my city bubble we have organisations who facilitate elderly people socialising in places like church halls. Which provide safeguarding and transport and don't do it for a profit motive. It'd be more challenging in less densely populated areas, but certainly not impossible.

In my city bubble we don't need pubs to have community spirit. Maybe ask the mosque how it's done

Once again you fail to understand that not everywhere has churches open or community transport.Get out of your bubble you might realise that.

So you see, the way that it happened in my community was people. Community minded people. Getting together and making it happen. With the spaces they do have and the cars that people already own. I thought people owned more cars outside of cities?

I'm sorry if you don't have any community minded people where you are though. That must be difficult. I'm not sure how a pub would help "

Because you have no idea of what a pub can provide for a small community It's not about getting pissed.Some pubs took in the Post Office to save it from closure,others incorporated a village shop,some open as a cafe/tearoom,others have an alternative to a conventional library.For those struggling with heating bills for example,sitting in a pub for the afternoon or evening is a big financial help,not to mention the benefit of social interaction.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"And whatever the problem is, let me tell you, it ain’t mosques for goodness sake"

It's an incredibly odd thing to pick on. Mosques do a hell of a lot of community work.

Pubs are just a venue. There's *work* to do to support people in community.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

Staff remain a finite resource, and treatment doesn't happen without them.

We should all exercise personal responsibility and be more like the people in the mosque

If you want to preach mosqueology start a thread on the subject,this is about pubs closing and the effect on the community

The OP bemoans loss of community and specifically mentioned mosques replacing breweries.

She should turn that smile upside down. Mosques are excellent at building community for people of all ages, and do excellent work outside their attendees as well

A contributing factor x

But mosques do the work needed to bring community together! They go out of their way to do so.

Why is charitable work and outreach, plus a free gathering place once a week, not a benefit to the community? That's community in action

I dare you to look a non for profit organisations and who are the top earners in fact I double dare you x

SAVE THE CHILDREN INTERNATIONAL £988,001,224

THE ARTS COUNCIL OF ENGLAND £941,845,043

THE BRITISH COUNCIL £896,655,974

CANCER RESEARCH UK £668,369,451"

THANK YOU x

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house.

Why is a pub necessary for talking or getting out of the house? There are countless other ways to do that.

Obviously you don't live in a small community which funnily enough doesn't have the same socialising options as a town or city because it's errr.....small.Get out of your bubble into the wider world a bit more.

A community so small you can't go out walking? Do you live in Antarctica?

Who goes walking in the pissing rain or bad weather to socialise?

Do you expect elderly people to go walking just to socialise?You really need to get out of your city bubble.

People do do that, yes.

In my city bubble we have organisations who facilitate elderly people socialising in places like church halls. Which provide safeguarding and transport and don't do it for a profit motive. It'd be more challenging in less densely populated areas, but certainly not impossible.

In my city bubble we don't need pubs to have community spirit. Maybe ask the mosque how it's done

Once again you fail to understand that not everywhere has churches open or community transport.Get out of your bubble you might realise that.

So you see, the way that it happened in my community was people. Community minded people. Getting together and making it happen. With the spaces they do have and the cars that people already own. I thought people owned more cars outside of cities?

I'm sorry if you don't have any community minded people where you are though. That must be difficult. I'm not sure how a pub would help

Because you have no idea of what a pub can provide for a small community It's not about getting pissed.Some pubs took in the Post Office to save it from closure,others incorporated a village shop,some open as a cafe/tearoom,others have an alternative to a conventional library.For those struggling with heating bills for example,sitting in a pub for the afternoon or evening is a big financial help,not to mention the benefit of social interaction."

Ok. You're basically describing a charity near me.

I see no reason why "pub" is essential to this. Just community minded businesses or people.

If there aren't any community minded people, a million pubs won't help.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inky_couple2020Couple
over a year ago

North West

The British Council is not a non-profit organisation. It has charitable status but is it public body, an offshoot of the FCDO.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Hell yes.

Smoking and drinking - burden on the NHS.

Mosques often do so much good locally. One near me organised vitamin D for elderly people during lockdown.

How are smoking and drinking a burden on the NHS? Tax on tobacco tax on alcohol.for every £1 it costs the NHS to treat a smoker,that smoker has paid £3 in tax,and before the usual suspects make 2+2 into 9 I am not a smoker.

Staff remain a finite resource, and treatment doesn't happen without them.

We should all exercise personal responsibility and be more like the people in the mosque

If you want to preach mosqueology start a thread on the subject,this is about pubs closing and the effect on the community

The OP bemoans loss of community and specifically mentioned mosques replacing breweries.

She should turn that smile upside down. Mosques are excellent at building community for people of all ages, and do excellent work outside their attendees as well

A contributing factor x

But mosques do the work needed to bring community together! They go out of their way to do so.

Why is charitable work and outreach, plus a free gathering place once a week, not a benefit to the community? That's community in action

I dare you to look a non for profit organisations and who are the top earners in fact I double dare you x

SAVE THE CHILDREN INTERNATIONAL £988,001,224

THE ARTS COUNCIL OF ENGLAND £941,845,043

THE BRITISH COUNCIL £896,655,974

CANCER RESEARCH UK £668,369,451

THANK YOU x"

What in sweet baby Jesus all caps name does that have to do with MY LOCAL MOSQUE?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *aitonelMan
over a year ago

Travelling

I'm so god damn confused right now!

I'm off to the pub... Oh wait...

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"The British Council is not a non-profit organisation. It has charitable status but is it public body, an offshoot of the FCDO. "

I just used the .gov website. I only did it because I was double dared! Lol

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inky_couple2020Couple
over a year ago

North West


"I'm so god damn confused right now!

I'm off to the pub... Oh wait... "

There might be a mosque nearby where you can get a nice cup of tea.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house.

Why is a pub necessary for talking or getting out of the house? There are countless other ways to do that.

Obviously you don't live in a small community which funnily enough doesn't have the same socialising options as a town or city because it's errr.....small.Get out of your bubble into the wider world a bit more.

A community so small you can't go out walking? Do you live in Antarctica?

Who goes walking in the pissing rain or bad weather to socialise?

Do you expect elderly people to go walking just to socialise?You really need to get out of your city bubble.

People do do that, yes.

In my city bubble we have organisations who facilitate elderly people socialising in places like church halls. Which provide safeguarding and transport and don't do it for a profit motive. It'd be more challenging in less densely populated areas, but certainly not impossible.

In my city bubble we don't need pubs to have community spirit. Maybe ask the mosque how it's done

Once again you fail to understand that not everywhere has churches open or community transport.Get out of your bubble you might realise that.

So you see, the way that it happened in my community was people. Community minded people. Getting together and making it happen. With the spaces they do have and the cars that people already own. I thought people owned more cars outside of cities?

I'm sorry if you don't have any community minded people where you are though. That must be difficult. I'm not sure how a pub would help

Because you have no idea of what a pub can provide for a small community It's not about getting pissed.Some pubs took in the Post Office to save it from closure,others incorporated a village shop,some open as a cafe/tearoom,others have an alternative to a conventional library.For those struggling with heating bills for example,sitting in a pub for the afternoon or evening is a big financial help,not to mention the benefit of social interaction.

Ok. You're basically describing a charity near me.

I see no reason why "pub" is essential to this. Just community minded businesses or people.

If there aren't any community minded people, a million pubs won't help."

In some small communities the pub is the only ******* building left that is suitable,you'd know that if you got out of your concrete jungle for a day and stopped judging and imagining the rest of the world was the same as your microcosm.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I'm so god damn confused right now!

I'm off to the pub... Oh wait...

There might be a mosque nearby where you can get a nice cup of tea. "

The one near me will give it to you for free. Community minded and all of that.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

Just to add- 27500 pubs in the UK and less than 1500 mosques. Non of them are converted pubs.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago


"I'm so god damn confused right now!

I'm off to the pub... Oh wait... "

Me too what did I start. Off for a cheeky smoke and bed x

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"I'm so god damn confused right now!

I'm off to the pub... Oh wait...

Me too what did I start. Off for a cheeky smoke and bed x"

Don't blame you.FFS.sweet dreams.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inky_couple2020Couple
over a year ago

North West


"Just to add- 27500 pubs in the UK and less than 1500 mosques. Non of them are converted pubs. "

Actually, there are some mosques in former pubs

https://www.thetelegraphandargus.co.uk/news/20584103.plan-turn-pub-community-centre-mosque-approved/

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house.

Why is a pub necessary for talking or getting out of the house? There are countless other ways to do that.

Obviously you don't live in a small community which funnily enough doesn't have the same socialising options as a town or city because it's errr.....small.Get out of your bubble into the wider world a bit more.

A community so small you can't go out walking? Do you live in Antarctica?

Who goes walking in the pissing rain or bad weather to socialise?

Do you expect elderly people to go walking just to socialise?You really need to get out of your city bubble.

People do do that, yes.

In my city bubble we have organisations who facilitate elderly people socialising in places like church halls. Which provide safeguarding and transport and don't do it for a profit motive. It'd be more challenging in less densely populated areas, but certainly not impossible.

In my city bubble we don't need pubs to have community spirit. Maybe ask the mosque how it's done

Once again you fail to understand that not everywhere has churches open or community transport.Get out of your bubble you might realise that.

So you see, the way that it happened in my community was people. Community minded people. Getting together and making it happen. With the spaces they do have and the cars that people already own. I thought people owned more cars outside of cities?

I'm sorry if you don't have any community minded people where you are though. That must be difficult. I'm not sure how a pub would help

Because you have no idea of what a pub can provide for a small community It's not about getting pissed.Some pubs took in the Post Office to save it from closure,others incorporated a village shop,some open as a cafe/tearoom,others have an alternative to a conventional library.For those struggling with heating bills for example,sitting in a pub for the afternoon or evening is a big financial help,not to mention the benefit of social interaction.

Ok. You're basically describing a charity near me.

I see no reason why "pub" is essential to this. Just community minded businesses or people.

If there aren't any community minded people, a million pubs won't help.

In some small communities the pub is the only ******* building left that is suitable,you'd know that if you got out of your concrete jungle for a day and stopped judging and imagining the rest of the world was the same as your microcosm."

Ok. If your argument is that you need a building with appropriate space, ok, I'll agree.

If you say it has to be a pub and (going back to your earlier complaint) smoking should be allowed inside, that's fucking ridiculous.

(Although to facilitate community gathering, in cities many people use these things called cars? Might that help communities pool resources and do community things without relying on the profit motives of a struggling business model?)

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house.

Why is a pub necessary for talking or getting out of the house? There are countless other ways to do that.

Obviously you don't live in a small community which funnily enough doesn't have the same socialising options as a town or city because it's errr.....small.Get out of your bubble into the wider world a bit more.

A community so small you can't go out walking? Do you live in Antarctica?

Who goes walking in the pissing rain or bad weather to socialise?

Do you expect elderly people to go walking just to socialise?You really need to get out of your city bubble.

People do do that, yes.

In my city bubble we have organisations who facilitate elderly people socialising in places like church halls. Which provide safeguarding and transport and don't do it for a profit motive. It'd be more challenging in less densely populated areas, but certainly not impossible.

In my city bubble we don't need pubs to have community spirit. Maybe ask the mosque how it's done

Once again you fail to understand that not everywhere has churches open or community transport.Get out of your bubble you might realise that.

So you see, the way that it happened in my community was people. Community minded people. Getting together and making it happen. With the spaces they do have and the cars that people already own. I thought people owned more cars outside of cities?

I'm sorry if you don't have any community minded people where you are though. That must be difficult. I'm not sure how a pub would help

Because you have no idea of what a pub can provide for a small community It's not about getting pissed.Some pubs took in the Post Office to save it from closure,others incorporated a village shop,some open as a cafe/tearoom,others have an alternative to a conventional library.For those struggling with heating bills for example,sitting in a pub for the afternoon or evening is a big financial help,not to mention the benefit of social interaction.

Ok. You're basically describing a charity near me.

I see no reason why "pub" is essential to this. Just community minded businesses or people.

If there aren't any community minded people, a million pubs won't help.

In some small communities the pub is the only ******* building left that is suitable,you'd know that if you got out of your concrete jungle for a day and stopped judging and imagining the rest of the world was the same as your microcosm.

Ok. If your argument is that you need a building with appropriate space, ok, I'll agree.

If you say it has to be a pub and (going back to your earlier complaint) smoking should be allowed inside, that's fucking ridiculous.

(Although to facilitate community gathering, in cities many people use these things called cars? Might that help communities pool resources and do community things without relying on the profit motives of a struggling business model?)"

I never said smoking should be allowed indoors,I never complained about the smoking ban.I know for a fact it had an effect,from talking to the non smokers and smokers at the local.Again you are talking as if everywhere is a city or the same as a city.What use is a car if there is nowhere to go to? Not everyone has a car or can drive,especially the elderly.Where you are there are probably buses every 5 minutes,some places don't see a bus for 5 hours.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"Just to add- 27500 pubs in the UK and less than 1500 mosques. Non of them are converted pubs.

Actually, there are some mosques in former pubs

https://www.thetelegraphandargus.co.uk/news/20584103.plan-turn-pub-community-centre-mosque-approved/"

Iqra Centre! Looks nice too.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house.

Why is a pub necessary for talking or getting out of the house? There are countless other ways to do that.

Obviously you don't live in a small community which funnily enough doesn't have the same socialising options as a town or city because it's errr.....small.Get out of your bubble into the wider world a bit more.

A community so small you can't go out walking? Do you live in Antarctica?

Who goes walking in the pissing rain or bad weather to socialise?

Do you expect elderly people to go walking just to socialise?You really need to get out of your city bubble.

People do do that, yes.

In my city bubble we have organisations who facilitate elderly people socialising in places like church halls. Which provide safeguarding and transport and don't do it for a profit motive. It'd be more challenging in less densely populated areas, but certainly not impossible.

In my city bubble we don't need pubs to have community spirit. Maybe ask the mosque how it's done

Once again you fail to understand that not everywhere has churches open or community transport.Get out of your bubble you might realise that.

So you see, the way that it happened in my community was people. Community minded people. Getting together and making it happen. With the spaces they do have and the cars that people already own. I thought people owned more cars outside of cities?

I'm sorry if you don't have any community minded people where you are though. That must be difficult. I'm not sure how a pub would help

Because you have no idea of what a pub can provide for a small community It's not about getting pissed.Some pubs took in the Post Office to save it from closure,others incorporated a village shop,some open as a cafe/tearoom,others have an alternative to a conventional library.For those struggling with heating bills for example,sitting in a pub for the afternoon or evening is a big financial help,not to mention the benefit of social interaction.

Ok. You're basically describing a charity near me.

I see no reason why "pub" is essential to this. Just community minded businesses or people.

If there aren't any community minded people, a million pubs won't help.

In some small communities the pub is the only ******* building left that is suitable,you'd know that if you got out of your concrete jungle for a day and stopped judging and imagining the rest of the world was the same as your microcosm.

Ok. If your argument is that you need a building with appropriate space, ok, I'll agree.

If you say it has to be a pub and (going back to your earlier complaint) smoking should be allowed inside, that's fucking ridiculous.

(Although to facilitate community gathering, in cities many people use these things called cars? Might that help communities pool resources and do community things without relying on the profit motives of a struggling business model?)

I never said smoking should be allowed indoors,I never complained about the smoking ban.I know for a fact it had an effect,from talking to the non smokers and smokers at the local.Again you are talking as if everywhere is a city or the same as a city.What use is a car if there is nowhere to go to? Not everyone has a car or can drive,especially the elderly.Where you are there are probably buses every 5 minutes,some places don't see a bus for 5 hours."

The charity I'm a part of has people who *pick up* the elderly and take them to the centre. I appreciate that it might be further away in a small community, communities could even join forces. But my charity doesn't put anyone on the bus (that's not safe), we chauffer them. With... Volunteers.

And hang on. If the elderly rely on the pub in a small community and they don't drive... I hope they live in walking distance? You know walking distance is much less once you reach a certain age, right? Maybe someone should help them. (and if they do, that's community... Pub not required)

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house.

Why is a pub necessary for talking or getting out of the house? There are countless other ways to do that.

Obviously you don't live in a small community which funnily enough doesn't have the same socialising options as a town or city because it's errr.....small.Get out of your bubble into the wider world a bit more.

A community so small you can't go out walking? Do you live in Antarctica?

Who goes walking in the pissing rain or bad weather to socialise?

Do you expect elderly people to go walking just to socialise?You really need to get out of your city bubble.

People do do that, yes.

In my city bubble we have organisations who facilitate elderly people socialising in places like church halls. Which provide safeguarding and transport and don't do it for a profit motive. It'd be more challenging in less densely populated areas, but certainly not impossible.

In my city bubble we don't need pubs to have community spirit. Maybe ask the mosque how it's done

Once again you fail to understand that not everywhere has churches open or community transport.Get out of your bubble you might realise that.

So you see, the way that it happened in my community was people. Community minded people. Getting together and making it happen. With the spaces they do have and the cars that people already own. I thought people owned more cars outside of cities?

I'm sorry if you don't have any community minded people where you are though. That must be difficult. I'm not sure how a pub would help

Because you have no idea of what a pub can provide for a small community It's not about getting pissed.Some pubs took in the Post Office to save it from closure,others incorporated a village shop,some open as a cafe/tearoom,others have an alternative to a conventional library.For those struggling with heating bills for example,sitting in a pub for the afternoon or evening is a big financial help,not to mention the benefit of social interaction.

Ok. You're basically describing a charity near me.

I see no reason why "pub" is essential to this. Just community minded businesses or people.

If there aren't any community minded people, a million pubs won't help.

In some small communities the pub is the only ******* building left that is suitable,you'd know that if you got out of your concrete jungle for a day and stopped judging and imagining the rest of the world was the same as your microcosm.

Ok. If your argument is that you need a building with appropriate space, ok, I'll agree.

If you say it has to be a pub and (going back to your earlier complaint) smoking should be allowed inside, that's fucking ridiculous.

(Although to facilitate community gathering, in cities many people use these things called cars? Might that help communities pool resources and do community things without relying on the profit motives of a struggling business model?)

I never said smoking should be allowed indoors,I never complained about the smoking ban.I know for a fact it had an effect,from talking to the non smokers and smokers at the local.Again you are talking as if everywhere is a city or the same as a city.What use is a car if there is nowhere to go to? Not everyone has a car or can drive,especially the elderly.Where you are there are probably buses every 5 minutes,some places don't see a bus for 5 hours.

The charity I'm a part of has people who *pick up* the elderly and take them to the centre. I appreciate that it might be further away in a small community, communities could even join forces. But my charity doesn't put anyone on the bus (that's not safe), we chauffer them. With... Volunteers.

And hang on. If the elderly rely on the pub in a small community and they don't drive... I hope they live in walking distance? You know walking distance is much less once you reach a certain age, right? Maybe someone should help them. (and if they do, that's community... Pub not required)"

Things tend to be in walking distance in a small community,the clue is in the word "small".Not everywhere has all the volunteers and chauffeurs you have.To say a pub is not required,a resource or a valuable part of a small community is absolute pig ignorance.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house.

Why is a pub necessary for talking or getting out of the house? There are countless other ways to do that.

Obviously you don't live in a small community which funnily enough doesn't have the same socialising options as a town or city because it's errr.....small.Get out of your bubble into the wider world a bit more.

A community so small you can't go out walking? Do you live in Antarctica?

Who goes walking in the pissing rain or bad weather to socialise?

Do you expect elderly people to go walking just to socialise?You really need to get out of your city bubble.

People do do that, yes.

In my city bubble we have organisations who facilitate elderly people socialising in places like church halls. Which provide safeguarding and transport and don't do it for a profit motive. It'd be more challenging in less densely populated areas, but certainly not impossible.

In my city bubble we don't need pubs to have community spirit. Maybe ask the mosque how it's done

Once again you fail to understand that not everywhere has churches open or community transport.Get out of your bubble you might realise that.

So you see, the way that it happened in my community was people. Community minded people. Getting together and making it happen. With the spaces they do have and the cars that people already own. I thought people owned more cars outside of cities?

I'm sorry if you don't have any community minded people where you are though. That must be difficult. I'm not sure how a pub would help

Because you have no idea of what a pub can provide for a small community It's not about getting pissed.Some pubs took in the Post Office to save it from closure,others incorporated a village shop,some open as a cafe/tearoom,others have an alternative to a conventional library.For those struggling with heating bills for example,sitting in a pub for the afternoon or evening is a big financial help,not to mention the benefit of social interaction.

Ok. You're basically describing a charity near me.

I see no reason why "pub" is essential to this. Just community minded businesses or people.

If there aren't any community minded people, a million pubs won't help.

In some small communities the pub is the only ******* building left that is suitable,you'd know that if you got out of your concrete jungle for a day and stopped judging and imagining the rest of the world was the same as your microcosm.

Ok. If your argument is that you need a building with appropriate space, ok, I'll agree.

If you say it has to be a pub and (going back to your earlier complaint) smoking should be allowed inside, that's fucking ridiculous.

(Although to facilitate community gathering, in cities many people use these things called cars? Might that help communities pool resources and do community things without relying on the profit motives of a struggling business model?)

I never said smoking should be allowed indoors,I never complained about the smoking ban.I know for a fact it had an effect,from talking to the non smokers and smokers at the local.Again you are talking as if everywhere is a city or the same as a city.What use is a car if there is nowhere to go to? Not everyone has a car or can drive,especially the elderly.Where you are there are probably buses every 5 minutes,some places don't see a bus for 5 hours.

The charity I'm a part of has people who *pick up* the elderly and take them to the centre. I appreciate that it might be further away in a small community, communities could even join forces. But my charity doesn't put anyone on the bus (that's not safe), we chauffer them. With... Volunteers.

And hang on. If the elderly rely on the pub in a small community and they don't drive... I hope they live in walking distance? You know walking distance is much less once you reach a certain age, right? Maybe someone should help them. (and if they do, that's community... Pub not required)

Things tend to be in walking distance in a small community,the clue is in the word "small".Not everywhere has all the volunteers and chauffeurs you have.To say a pub is not required,a resource or a valuable part of a small community is absolute pig ignorance."

Some of the people I've served have been unable to walk to their front gate without assistance. No pub would be within walking distance for them.

I'm sorry if your area doesn't have people who have stepped up to help others. That's unfortunate. Maybe you can be the change your area needs? Your closest mosque might provide you with ideas on how to do so.

The idea that a pub is necessary in any size community is a complete failure of imagination. The fact that it's come to it is also a failure of government and other institutions, and I hope your situation improves.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *lynJMan
over a year ago

Morden


"... At least people won't be drinking themselves into an early grave "

They can/will do it at home instead with all the cheap alcohol from the supermarkets.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house.

Why is a pub necessary for talking or getting out of the house? There are countless other ways to do that.

Obviously you don't live in a small community which funnily enough doesn't have the same socialising options as a town or city because it's errr.....small.Get out of your bubble into the wider world a bit more.

A community so small you can't go out walking? Do you live in Antarctica?

Who goes walking in the pissing rain or bad weather to socialise?

Do you expect elderly people to go walking just to socialise?You really need to get out of your city bubble.

People do do that, yes.

In my city bubble we have organisations who facilitate elderly people socialising in places like church halls. Which provide safeguarding and transport and don't do it for a profit motive. It'd be more challenging in less densely populated areas, but certainly not impossible.

In my city bubble we don't need pubs to have community spirit. Maybe ask the mosque how it's done

Once again you fail to understand that not everywhere has churches open or community transport.Get out of your bubble you might realise that.

So you see, the way that it happened in my community was people. Community minded people. Getting together and making it happen. With the spaces they do have and the cars that people already own. I thought people owned more cars outside of cities?

I'm sorry if you don't have any community minded people where you are though. That must be difficult. I'm not sure how a pub would help

Because you have no idea of what a pub can provide for a small community It's not about getting pissed.Some pubs took in the Post Office to save it from closure,others incorporated a village shop,some open as a cafe/tearoom,others have an alternative to a conventional library.For those struggling with heating bills for example,sitting in a pub for the afternoon or evening is a big financial help,not to mention the benefit of social interaction.

Ok. You're basically describing a charity near me.

I see no reason why "pub" is essential to this. Just community minded businesses or people.

If there aren't any community minded people, a million pubs won't help.

In some small communities the pub is the only ******* building left that is suitable,you'd know that if you got out of your concrete jungle for a day and stopped judging and imagining the rest of the world was the same as your microcosm.

Ok. If your argument is that you need a building with appropriate space, ok, I'll agree.

If you say it has to be a pub and (going back to your earlier complaint) smoking should be allowed inside, that's fucking ridiculous.

(Although to facilitate community gathering, in cities many people use these things called cars? Might that help communities pool resources and do community things without relying on the profit motives of a struggling business model?)

I never said smoking should be allowed indoors,I never complained about the smoking ban.I know for a fact it had an effect,from talking to the non smokers and smokers at the local.Again you are talking as if everywhere is a city or the same as a city.What use is a car if there is nowhere to go to? Not everyone has a car or can drive,especially the elderly.Where you are there are probably buses every 5 minutes,some places don't see a bus for 5 hours.

The charity I'm a part of has people who *pick up* the elderly and take them to the centre. I appreciate that it might be further away in a small community, communities could even join forces. But my charity doesn't put anyone on the bus (that's not safe), we chauffer them. With... Volunteers.

And hang on. If the elderly rely on the pub in a small community and they don't drive... I hope they live in walking distance? You know walking distance is much less once you reach a certain age, right? Maybe someone should help them. (and if they do, that's community... Pub not required)

Things tend to be in walking distance in a small community,the clue is in the word "small".Not everywhere has all the volunteers and chauffeurs you have.To say a pub is not required,a resource or a valuable part of a small community is absolute pig ignorance.

Some of the people I've served have been unable to walk to their front gate without assistance. No pub would be within walking distance for them.

I'm sorry if your area doesn't have people who have stepped up to help others. That's unfortunate. Maybe you can be the change your area needs? Your closest mosque might provide you with ideas on how to do so.

The idea that a pub is necessary in any size community is a complete failure of imagination. The fact that it's come to it is also a failure of government and other institutions, and I hope your situation improves."

Your fanaticism has totally blinded you to reality.Completely dismissing a valuable resource (pub) is a failure of you're imagination.Its clear you are in an entrenched anti pub mindset,unwilling and unable to see or accept what they provide for small communities.You concentrate on your little microcosm,you clearly can't see beyond it.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"... At least people won't be drinking themselves into an early grave

They can/will do it at home instead with all the cheap alcohol from the supermarkets."

Another pub killer.£1 a pint from Morrisons.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"

Your fanaticism has totally blinded you to reality.Completely dismissing a valuable resource (pub) is a failure of you're imagination.Its clear you are in an entrenched anti pub mindset,unwilling and unable to see or accept what they provide for small communities.You concentrate on your little microcosm,you clearly can't see beyond it."

Ok. You have a nice night now. I'll keep focussing on building community with action and spirit, not a business model

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *penbicoupleCouple
over a year ago

Northampton


"Wine as described in the Bible was partly a way to decontaminate water"

Wine is not once described in the Bible as a way to decontaminate water. Get merry? Sure! Decontaminate water? Not even once.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago


"

Your fanaticism has totally blinded you to reality.Completely dismissing a valuable resource (pub) is a failure of you're imagination.Its clear you are in an entrenched anti pub mindset,unwilling and unable to see or accept what they provide for small communities.You concentrate on your little microcosm,you clearly can't see beyond it.

Ok. You have a nice night now. I'll keep focussing on building community with action and spirit, not a business model "

Are you a bot x

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"

Your fanaticism has totally blinded you to reality.Completely dismissing a valuable resource (pub) is a failure of you're imagination.Its clear you are in an entrenched anti pub mindset,unwilling and unable to see or accept what they provide for small communities.You concentrate on your little microcosm,you clearly can't see beyond it.

Ok. You have a nice night now. I'll keep focussing on building community with action and spirit, not a business model "

You just won't accept it that a local is not all about a business model.Never mind,you play with the mosque.At least you will be out of our way.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"Wine as described in the Bible was partly a way to decontaminate water

Wine is not once described in the Bible as a way to decontaminate water. Get merry? Sure! Decontaminate water? Not even once."

Wine "as described". Not "is described"

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"

Your fanaticism has totally blinded you to reality.Completely dismissing a valuable resource (pub) is a failure of you're imagination.Its clear you are in an entrenched anti pub mindset,unwilling and unable to see or accept what they provide for small communities.You concentrate on your little microcosm,you clearly can't see beyond it.

Ok. You have a nice night now. I'll keep focussing on building community with action and spirit, not a business model

Are you a bot x"

I can think of something else

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"

Your fanaticism has totally blinded you to reality.Completely dismissing a valuable resource (pub) is a failure of you're imagination.Its clear you are in an entrenched anti pub mindset,unwilling and unable to see or accept what they provide for small communities.You concentrate on your little microcosm,you clearly can't see beyond it.

Ok. You have a nice night now. I'll keep focussing on building community with action and spirit, not a business model

Are you a bot x"

Are you accusing me of being fake because I disagree with you?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *penbicoupleCouple
over a year ago

Northampton


"Wine as described in the Bible was partly a way to decontaminate water

Wine is not once described in the Bible as a way to decontaminate water. Get merry? Sure! Decontaminate water? Not even once.

Wine "as described". Not "is described""

That's a completely irrelevant response. Feel free to provide one text if I am wrong.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,

Don't rise to it Shazza,it's taken a little longer that I thought to reach the accusation stage,but it was coming.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *lynJMan
over a year ago

Morden


"Wine as described in the Bible was partly a way to decontaminate water

Wine is not once described in the Bible as a way to decontaminate water. Get merry? Sure! Decontaminate water? Not even once.

Wine "as described". Not "is described"

That's a completely irrelevant response. Feel free to provide one text if I am wrong. "

Beer was originally brewed because the water was not clean enough.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago


"Wine as described in the Bible was partly a way to decontaminate water

Wine is not once described in the Bible as a way to decontaminate water. Get merry? Sure! Decontaminate water? Not even once.

Wine "as described". Not "is described"

That's a completely irrelevant response. Feel free to provide one text if I am wrong.

Beer was originally brewed because the water was not clean enough."

Same as our waterways a sewerage and drains x

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"Wine as described in the Bible was partly a way to decontaminate water

Wine is not once described in the Bible as a way to decontaminate water. Get merry? Sure! Decontaminate water? Not even once.

Wine "as described". Not "is described"

That's a completely irrelevant response. Feel free to provide one text if I am wrong.

Beer was originally brewed because the water was not clean enough."

Correct.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"Wine as described in the Bible was partly a way to decontaminate water

Wine is not once described in the Bible as a way to decontaminate water. Get merry? Sure! Decontaminate water? Not even once.

Wine "as described". Not "is described"

That's a completely irrelevant response. Feel free to provide one text if I am wrong. "

Is it irrelevant? I'm pointing out the historical use of alcohol, which is different to our own. Try "The Conflicted History of Alcohol in Western Civilization" on the site Scientific American from 2015.

You say "wine is not described as" as though you were refuting my statement. I didn't say it was. I doubt the writers had any need to clarify their ordinary practices when trying to describe the history of the divine.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *lynJMan
over a year ago

Morden


"Plenty of communities all over the world, all over the god damn world, that do perfectly fine without a pub.

And it's a wonderful thing to see. "

And that's fine, but it's not our culture.

Pubs, especially in small towns and villages are assets for the community.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *penbicoupleCouple
over a year ago

Northampton


"Beer was originally brewed because the water was not clean enough."

But that's not the 'biblical' reason. (Also, the statement was about wine.)

I suspext that the reason for beer and wine was related to intoxication - which is the biblical reason - but it's possible that the reap reason back then was what you assert.

But that's not what the Bible says.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *penbicoupleCouple
over a year ago

Northampton


"Wine as described in the Bible was partly a way to decontaminate water

Wine is not once described in the Bible as a way to decontaminate water. Get merry? Sure! Decontaminate water? Not even once.

Wine "as described". Not "is described"

That's a completely irrelevant response. Feel free to provide one text if I am wrong.

Is it irrelevant?"

Yes, because I was referring to the Biblical reference.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ndycoinsMan
over a year ago

Whaley Bridge,Nr Buxton,


"Plenty of communities all over the world, all over the god damn world, that do perfectly fine without a pub.

And it's a wonderful thing to see.

And that's fine, but it's not our culture.

Pubs, especially in small towns and villages are assets for the community. "

Spot on.When you live in such places you know.When you don't....

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"Beer was originally brewed because the water was not clean enough.

But that's not the 'biblical' reason. (Also, the statement was about wine.)

I suspext that the reason for beer and wine was related to intoxication - which is the biblical reason - but it's possible that the reap reason back then was what you assert.

But that's not what the Bible says."

I never said the Bible *said* that. I was making an historical statement. That wine - along with other alcohol - helped with impure water.

Hence why the difference between me saying "as" and you saying "is" was important.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *penbicoupleCouple
over a year ago

Northampton


"Hence why the difference between me saying "as" and you saying "is" was important."

Thanks for your replies. I think I am closer to understanding what you are saying.

I think I was side-tracked by your use of the phrase, 'as used in the Bible.' Because that is not at all how alcohol is described in the Bible.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *penbicoupleCouple
over a year ago

Northampton


"I was making an historical statement. That wine - along with other alcohol - helped with impure water.

Hence why the difference between me saying "as" and you saying "is" was important."

I think you're right.

God, that hurts to admit!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"Hence why the difference between me saying "as" and you saying "is" was important.

Thanks for your replies. I think I am closer to understanding what you are saying.

I think I was side-tracked by your use of the phrase, 'as used in the Bible.' Because that is not at all how alcohol is described in the Bible. "

The historical use of alcohol involved making water safer to drink. That's all I was getting at

(I'm not an expert on this specific culture, but in other cultures in a similar time period, wine was watered down as a rule)

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"I was making an historical statement. That wine - along with other alcohol - helped with impure water.

Hence why the difference between me saying "as" and you saying "is" was important.

I think you're right.

God, that hurts to admit! "

Lol, no worries

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *penbicoupleCouple
over a year ago

Northampton


"(I'm not an expert on this specific culture, but in other cultures in a similar time period, wine was watered down as a rule)"

The same is true in biblical times. That's why people who get overexcited by e.g. 7-day weddings might be misguided.

Either way, I don't like being wrong and have thus not enjoyed this interaction.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *atnip make me purrWoman
over a year ago

Reading


"And whatever the problem is, let me tell you, it ain’t mosques for goodness sake

It's an incredibly odd thing to pick on. Mosques do a hell of a lot of community work.

Pubs are just a venue. There's *work* to do to support people in community."

It was just a sneaky bit of islamaphobia.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *lay 4 your plessureMan
over a year ago

Wigan

Surely the simple truth is, pubs close because of 1 of 2 things, the people running them aren't good enough business people to make them profitable or the people who did use those pubs didn't spend enough to keep them going. There's no other excuses or people to blame. Either you have someone in charge with good enough ideas to bring more money in or those using them spend more to keep it at least at break even, if you don't have either of those 2 things happening then you just have to accept the consequences and blame. Many trades and traditions have died over the centuries because they failed to adapt to change.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *cotty_01ukMan
over a year ago

birmingham

It's just all gone commercialised

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago


"It's just all gone commercialised "

Over 150 weatherspoons are due to close just been announced x

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *orthernJayMan
over a year ago

LHR

Now the debate is back to pub closures and not places of worship…..

The boss of Spoons has narrated the choice of punters to stay at home and drink cheaper supermarket supplied beer as the main reason for closures!

It’s exactly this! The breweries, who owned most of the pubs back in their halcyon days, sold their souls to the devil when they started supplying Tesco et al. with floor standing pallets (TRDU’s in the trade) for shoppers to fill their trolleys with!

Once the supermarkets started selling booze as a loss leader, which a lot of them still do, and on promotions “two for £20” etc then pubs were doomed!

It’s naff all to do with smoking or landlords not able to run boozers effectively!

Supermarkets gave drinkers a cheaper choice and they’ve voted with their feet; straight up and down commercial decision by consumers!

Pubs as a concept are dead men walking unless they offer something different to justify the cost difference to customers!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago


"Now the debate is back to pub closures and not places of worship…..

The boss of Spoons has narrated the choice of punters to stay at home and drink cheaper supermarket supplied beer as the main reason for closures!

It’s exactly this! The breweries, who owned most of the pubs back in their halcyon days, sold their souls to the devil when they started supplying Tesco et al. with floor standing pallets (TRDU’s in the trade) for shoppers to fill their trolleys with!

Once the supermarkets started selling booze as a loss leader, which a lot of them still do, and on promotions “two for £20” etc then pubs were doomed!

It’s naff all to do with smoking or landlords not able to run boozers effectively!

Supermarkets gave drinkers a cheaper choice and they’ve voted with their feet; straight up and down commercial decision by consumers!

Pubs as a concept are dead men walking unless they offer something different to justify the cost difference to customers!"

Back to my original statement after a 20 year battle my local the ploughman has lost its battle with tesco it will be turned into a car park.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago


"Now the debate is back to pub closures and not places of worship…..

The boss of Spoons has narrated the choice of punters to stay at home and drink cheaper supermarket supplied beer as the main reason for closures!

It’s exactly this! The breweries, who owned most of the pubs back in their halcyon days, sold their souls to the devil when they started supplying Tesco et al. with floor standing pallets (TRDU’s in the trade) for shoppers to fill their trolleys with!

Once the supermarkets started selling booze as a loss leader, which a lot of them still do, and on promotions “two for £20” etc then pubs were doomed!

It’s naff all to do with smoking or landlords not able to run boozers effectively!

Supermarkets gave drinkers a cheaper choice and they’ve voted with their feet; straight up and down commercial decision by consumers!

Pubs as a concept are dead men walking unless they offer something different to justify the cost difference to customers!

Back to my original statement after a 20 year battle my local the ploughman has lost its battle with tesco it will be turned into a car park."

And who owns tesco and who owns asda x

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ilverjagMan
over a year ago

swansea

Well this thread has been more entertaining during an insomnic moment than watching The House of Commons on good day.

Now having put a smile on the faces of a ladies whose partners joined alcohols anonymous, became familiar with their group motto.

GOD grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference. If you ever go into someones house and see that on a plaque, the chances are at least one or other is a fully fledged, 24 carat piss tank.

Having bought, and subsequently dispossessed of two closed pubs, demolished one to put a supermarket on the site, and converted the other into two flats and a tea room on the ground floor because, I accepted the things that I couldn't change, and realised it was a waste of time time and money reopening them as pubs, changed the things I could, and got the planning consents for alternative projects, and had the wisdom to know it was a smart move.

What emerged out of these projects was that all pubs have what is known as A3 Planning consent, which basically means that you can retail virtually anything within the boundary of the existing building without obtaining change of use for planning.

As the man pointed out, people voted with their feet and bought their booze at Tesco and Asda at knock down prices. My pub licences also allowed me to sell alcohol for consumption off the premises. This being the case, it somewhat surprises me that brewery chains, supermarket chains and enterprising landlords have not sought to find alternative, profitable use for the floor space if there is insufficient footfall to support the pub on wet sales alone, whilst retaining enough space for bar and entertainment area for those who wanted it, effectively a mini market that's doubles up as a social hub.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site) OP   
over a year ago


"Well this thread has been more entertaining during an insomnic moment than watching The House of Commons on good day.

Now having put a smile on the faces of a ladies whose partners joined alcohols anonymous, became familiar with their group motto.

GOD grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference. If you ever go into someones house and see that on a plaque, the chances are at least one or other is a fully fledged, 24 carat piss tank.

Having bought, and subsequently dispossessed of two closed pubs, demolished one to put a supermarket on the site, and converted the other into two flats and a tea room on the ground floor because, I accepted the things that I couldn't change, and realised it was a waste of time time and money reopening them as pubs, changed the things I could, and got the planning consents for alternative projects, and had the wisdom to know it was a smart move.

What emerged out of these projects was that all pubs have what is known as A3 Planning consent, which basically means that you can retail virtually anything within the boundary of the existing building without obtaining change of use for planning.

As the man pointed out, people voted with their feet and bought their booze at Tesco and Asda at knock down prices. My pub licences also allowed me to sell alcohol for consumption off the premises. This being the case, it somewhat surprises me that brewery chains, supermarket chains and enterprising landlords have not sought to find alternative, profitable use for the floor space if there is insufficient footfall to support the pub on wet sales alone, whilst retaining enough space for bar and entertainment area for those who wanted it, effectively a mini market that's doubles up as a social hub.

"

I love this x

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ertcamembertMan
over a year ago

Reading area


"Now the debate is back to pub closures and not places of worship…..

The boss of Spoons has narrated the choice of punters to stay at home and drink cheaper supermarket supplied beer as the main reason for closures!

It’s exactly this! The breweries, who owned most of the pubs back in their halcyon days, sold their souls to the devil when they started supplying Tesco et al. with floor standing pallets (TRDU’s in the trade) for shoppers to fill their trolleys with!

Once the supermarkets started selling booze as a loss leader, which a lot of them still do, and on promotions “two for £20” etc then pubs were doomed!

It’s naff all to do with smoking or landlords not able to run boozers effectively!

Supermarkets gave drinkers a cheaper choice and they’ve voted with their feet; straight up and down commercial decision by consumers!

Pubs as a concept are dead men walking unless they offer something different to justify the cost difference to customers!"

50 years ago buying a pint in a pub was cheap in relation to the cost of living back then and there was no option to buy a pint of supermarket beer for approximately a quarter to one third of the price of the pub pint. Then along came the "Beer Orders" act of Parliament in 1989 which dealt a severe blow to the number of pubs able to operate cheaply as part of a brewery tied estate and later on the smoking ban saw more pubs struggling. Maybe government needs to trial reducing duty on pub beer and increasing it for supermarket beer to narrow the cost difference between both?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *orthernJayMan
over a year ago

LHR

Booze has always been a cash cow for governments, whatever their political persuasion, they don’t care as long as their percentage is flowing regardless of where the drink is sold; retailer or pub!

Think on this, if everyone in the UK abandoned drinking alcohol, UK government would be absolutely fucked; they probably start taxing raindrops

As a random aside, I live in Malaysia most of the year, booze is available here but it’s typically sold at circa four times the price of equivalent in UK retail and it’s only allowed to be sold within a glass cube inside the main supermarkets!

Us expats still queue up most nights and for certain on Friday/Saturday to pay over the odds for a decent bottle of wine or four pack of Tiger beer that’s brewed down the road!

Go figure

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ealitybitesMan
over a year ago

Belfast


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend. "

I managed a company for 22 years that supplied the licensed trade. Within a year of the smoking ban being introduced our turnover was down 70 percent and we went from having 10 employees to only 2.

We had to close in 2013 as a direct result. By that time 20 percent of our customers had also closed.

I can confirm though that a large percentage of pubs have had to close due to poor management and greedy publicans with a short term get rich quick attitude.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *alandNitaCouple
over a year ago

Scunthorpe


"How many pubs have we lost since Tony Blair banned smoking Hospitality/Pubs got the rough end of covid.

A community hub lost

After a 20 year battle my local pub the ploughman has lost its battle with Tesco to turn the pub into a car park x"

It's not the smoking ban that is killing pubs, it is cheap supermarket drinks pricing.

Cal

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *arkus1812Man
over a year ago

Lifes departure lounge NN9 Northamptonshire East not West MidlandsMidlands

Now we know what a hijacked post looks like.

Back on topic the demise of pubs, mainly rural but some in town pubs as well can be traced back to 1968 with the introduction of the breathalyser by the then Labour government.

At that time I and many of my friends would visit pubs two or three time a week and enjoy the traditional pub games.

Sadly the breathalyser brought that to an abrupt end.

The smoking ban did not help, neither did the selling off batches of pubs by the big brewers to the so called Pub Co,s who immediately increased rents and demanded all beer and spirits be obtained from them only at inflated prices.

Fortunately the Free House Pubs survived and in a lot of cases prospered.

In the time I have lived in my village I have seen three out of the original four pubs have closed, I still use the one survivor and will continue to do so.

Wild horses would not drag me into a Mosque.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *inky_couple2020Couple
over a year ago

North West


"Now the debate is back to pub closures and not places of worship…..

The boss of Spoons has narrated the choice of punters to stay at home and drink cheaper supermarket supplied beer as the main reason for closures!

It’s exactly this! The breweries, who owned most of the pubs back in their halcyon days, sold their souls to the devil when they started supplying Tesco et al. with floor standing pallets (TRDU’s in the trade) for shoppers to fill their trolleys with!

Once the supermarkets started selling booze as a loss leader, which a lot of them still do, and on promotions “two for £20” etc then pubs were doomed!

It’s naff all to do with smoking or landlords not able to run boozers effectively!

Supermarkets gave drinkers a cheaper choice and they’ve voted with their feet; straight up and down commercial decision by consumers!

Pubs as a concept are dead men walking unless they offer something different to justify the cost difference to customers!

Back to my original statement after a 20 year battle my local the ploughman has lost its battle with tesco it will be turned into a car park.

And who owns tesco and who owns asda x"

Tesco is owned by Tesco PLC. ASDA is owned by the Issa brothers.

Are you alluding to the fact Tesco was originally founded by a Jewish man and Tesco is owned by Muslim brothers?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *otbeefandonionsCouple
over a year ago

Bathgate

I started going to the pub more when the smoking ban came in. Smoking kept me away from pubs.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *orthernJayMan
over a year ago

LHR


"Now the debate is back to pub closures and not places of worship…..

The boss of Spoons has narrated the choice of punters to stay at home and drink cheaper supermarket supplied beer as the main reason for closures!

It’s exactly this! The breweries, who owned most of the pubs back in their halcyon days, sold their souls to the devil when they started supplying Tesco et al. with floor standing pallets (TRDU’s in the trade) for shoppers to fill their trolleys with!

Once the supermarkets started selling booze as a loss leader, which a lot of them still do, and on promotions “two for £20” etc then pubs were doomed!

It’s naff all to do with smoking or landlords not able to run boozers effectively!

Supermarkets gave drinkers a cheaper choice and they’ve voted with their feet; straight up and down commercial decision by consumers!

Pubs as a concept are dead men walking unless they offer something different to justify the cost difference to customers!

Back to my original statement after a 20 year battle my local the ploughman has lost its battle with tesco it will be turned into a car park.

And who owns tesco and who owns asda x

Tesco is owned by Tesco PLC. ASDA is owned by the Issa brothers.

Are you alluding to the fact Tesco was originally founded by a Jewish man and Tesco is owned by Muslim brothers? "

Tesco isn’t owned by anybody, it’s “owned” by shareholders, including Mike Ashley and the least said about him the better!

How do you know the brothers who own Asda are Muslim and who said anything about Jews?

Let’s not re-hijack what is actually a great subject to debate, it’s naff all to do with culture nor religion!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"And whatever the problem is, let me tell you, it ain’t mosques for goodness sake

It's an incredibly odd thing to pick on. Mosques do a hell of a lot of community work.

Pubs are just a venue. There's *work* to do to support people in community.

It was just a sneaky bit of islamaphobia."

Shame that in this instance that my experience of Muslims is that they're incredibly community spirited.

You want a community? Find the community minded. They'll help.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *rumpyMcFuckNuggetMan
over a year ago

Den of Iniquity

Fuck me this debate is more Toxic than Brexit

You can have Pubs AND other community places and a thriving community..

Sorry for the common sense

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ranny-CrumpetWoman
over a year ago

The Town by The Cross


"What a crock, I'd not go anywhere that had smoking now.

Pubs closing is a result of many things. I can tell you know nothing about how these establiments are run and the breweries fleecing people.

Venture capitalism is what killed a lot of those pubs! Check your notes on which cunting PM brought that in!!!"

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"Fuck me this debate is more Toxic than Brexit

You can have Pubs AND other community places and a thriving community..

Sorry for the common sense "

I don't think anyone said otherwise?

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

I’d imagine Muslims are reading this like 50 Cent in that video.

“What he say fuck me for?”

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago

The writing on the wall for pubs started as early as the 70s with conglomerates like Grand Met buying anything that moved and rent gouging to get rid of tenants. Enterprise Inns own about 5000 pubs, they never give struggling pubs a chance because they're primarily property companies. Any company who owns 5000 pubs doesn't give a fuck about actual pubs.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ranny-CrumpetWoman
over a year ago

The Town by The Cross


"I’d imagine Muslims are reading this like 50 Cent in that video.

“What he say fuck me for?”"

I didn't know what that was ... so I looked.. now that's funny

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"I’d imagine Muslims are reading this like 50 Cent in that video.

“What he say fuck me for?”

I didn't know what that was ... so I looked.. now that's funny"

It’s about 10 years old and still makes me laugh when I see it

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ig1gaz1Man
over a year ago

bradford

the main killer for pubs has been cheap booze cans and bottles bought at the supermarket.

but other factors have also contributed to there demise as well.

drink driving

smoking ban

government tax on booze

covid

power bills

The first main one was man of the house taking all of the money to spend it all on booze in the pub.

hence the reason why the ladies gained child benefit.

as goes for pubs turned into mosques it does happen but alot of issues starts back at who owns the pub.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ertcamembertMan
over a year ago

Reading area


"The writing on the wall for pubs started as early as the 70s with conglomerates like Grand Met buying anything that moved and rent gouging to get rid of tenants. Enterprise Inns own about 5000 pubs, they never give struggling pubs a chance because they're primarily property companies. Any company who owns 5000 pubs doesn't give a fuck about actual pubs."
Yes pubco's that are really property companies have been responsible for deliberately closing and demolishing many pubs purely for the land value. Most of the pubs lost had been established for over a hundred years

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *hromosexualsCouple
over a year ago

Near Abercynon

There's a lot on this thread about how much drinkers cost the NHS... that might be a fair point, but I wonder if the maths stacks up.

I like a good pub, but I suppose I could die early because of it.

Is it better for me as a higher rate tax payer with 100% national insurance contributions to die around retirement age, or to retire in my mid 60's and live for another 40 years?

It's one for "more or less" on Radio 4.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ent in BlackMan
over a year ago

Silsden

My nearest city is Bradford. It used to have a fantastic night life in the 90’s. Most of the best pubs have gone now.

The town where I live has 4 pubs that are very busy, but the prices are now quite high so they can make profit.

Pubs are slowly dying out. Personally I blame the fact that I can go and buy 24 cans of strong lager for about £18.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *heelerMan
over a year ago

Northants


"How many pubs have we lost since Tony Blair banned smoking Hospitality/Pubs got the rough end of covid.

A community hub lost

After a 20 year battle my local pub the ploughman has lost its battle with Tesco to turn the pub into a car park x"

I think the price of drinks nowadays people go weatherspoons who wants to pay around a fiver a drink.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *addad99Man
over a year ago

Rotherham /newquay


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend. "
I think it depends where you are from here local mining villages the smoking ban hit them hard other had a less effect on them the breweries and capital investment aren't helping true freehouses are better connected but also a lot of the younger generation don't really drink my son's never go out to a pub.also some breweries are bully's to other owned pub's

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ig1gaz1Man
over a year ago

bradford


"My nearest city is Bradford. It used to have a fantastic night life in the 90’s. Most of the best pubs have gone now. "

That it did you could have a sever pub crawl from each of the pubs and clubs and finaly hiting the takeaways before taxi home.

but also got ruined as the police wouldnt do anything with the yobs in the cars.

and constant harrasement of pub goers

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *addad99Man
over a year ago

Rotherham /newquay


"I don't think the smoking ban has *anything* to do with it. If anything, it probably allowed more non-smokers to attend.

Not just smokers, lock down and covid along with business rates. The hospitality industry is on its knees.

What about independent breweries or pubs being replaced by mosques

Along with schools and doctors a community needs a pub and a post office and community values. A pub is at the heart of a community x

Post offices and pubs are not the heart of a community. We don't all live in a little village where there's no other options. I'm in no way religious, but the churches are open to everyone these days, for more than just saying a prayer, one of ours hosts the community larder, a coffee shop, charity shop and soft play centre, and the community centres are more of a valuable asset than any pub.

Well lucky for you that you live in a community with other options to socialise,and has a church,never mind one that is open.A lot of of communities aren't so fortunate.For such communities pubs and post offices are the heart of the community.

My local community is thriving. Because people in my community make it so. In ways that don't need to involve alcohol and are inclusive.

If a community depends on being able to afford overpriced drinks and that's the only civic centre, then I feel bad for its residents. Someone ought to step up and make a difference.

Not everyone who goes to a small community pub goes there to get pissed.Pubs do serve other drinks,stuff called Tea and Coffee.Its not about being able to afford "overpriced" drinks (ever heard of overheads?) It's about residents being able to meet up and have a chat,get out of the house.

Why is a pub necessary for talking or getting out of the house? There are countless other ways to do that.

Obviously you don't live in a small community which funnily enough doesn't have the same socialising options as a town or city because it's errr.....small.Get out of your bubble into the wider world a bit more.

A community so small you can't go out walking? Do you live in Antarctica?

Who goes walking in the pissing rain or bad weather to socialise?

Do you expect elderly people to go walking just to socialise?You really need to get out of your city bubble.

People do do that, yes.

In my city bubble we have organisations who facilitate elderly people socialising in places like church halls. Which provide safeguarding and transport and don't do it for a profit motive. It'd be more challenging in less densely populated areas, but certainly not impossible.

In my city bubble we don't need pubs to have community spirit. Maybe ask the mosque how it's done "

I've just built my own bar smoke drink chat as much as you want brilliant 2pound a pint

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *alandNitaCouple
over a year ago

Scunthorpe


"There's a lot on this thread about how much drinkers cost the NHS... that might be a fair point, but I wonder if the maths stacks up.

I like a good pub, but I suppose I could die early because of it.

"

Realistically, there's very few alcoholics in pubs. You need would to be a millionaire to fuel an addiction in a pub.

I would personally like to see a return to pubs, restaurants and "off licenses" being the only places you can buy alcohol. Off licenses should also have limited opening hours and restricted "pack sizes"... no "crates of beer".

I'd also make tobacco products only available through a dedicated tobacconist! But that's a different subject all together (obviously )

Cal

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *tylebender03Man
over a year ago

Manchester

so many its unbelievable, its been damaging to communities

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ove2pleaseseukMan
over a year ago

Hastings


"How many pubs have we lost since Tony Blair banned smoking Hospitality/Pubs got the rough end of covid.

A community hub lost

After a 20 year battle my local pub the ploughman has lost its battle with Tesco to turn the pub into a car park x"

Drink driving was the start of the decline of the pub when working generally men would have a pint on the way home. Then supermarkets selling cheaper drink. Killing the off licence side of the pub smoking ban was just another nail in the coffin.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ove2pleaseseukMan
over a year ago

Hastings


"There's a lot on this thread about how much drinkers cost the NHS... that might be a fair point, but I wonder if the maths stacks up.

I like a good pub, but I suppose I could die early because of it.

Realistically, there's very few alcoholics in pubs. You need would to be a millionaire to fuel an addiction in a pub.

I would personally like to see a return to pubs, restaurants and "off licenses" being the only places you can buy alcohol. Off licenses should also have limited opening hours and restricted "pack sizes"... no "crates of beer".

I'd also make tobacco products only available through a dedicated tobacconist! But that's a different subject all together (obviously )

Cal"

Do you mean off license from a pub like it use to be or off licence like threshers a wine store.

To me an " off licence " is the part of the pub you got you beer from to drink off the licenced premises. As in off licence!

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *an de LyonMan
over a year ago

welling


"How many pubs have we lost since Tony Blair banned smoking Hospitality/Pubs got the rough end of covid.

A community hub lost

After a 20 year battle my local pub the ploughman has lost its battle with Tesco to turn the pub into a car park x

Drink driving was the start of the decline of the pub when working generally men would have a pint on the way home. Then supermarkets selling cheaper drink. Killing the off licence side of the pub smoking ban was just another nail in the coffin. "

Think it’s a combination of things, smoking ban was one factor but it’s easy to forget that pubs used to serve their local community when a big chunk of people worked within 5 miles of their home. Then think about the changes in demographics (a lot of pubs where situated in the midst of white working class communities that might have been replaced by cultures who don’t drink as much/at all/in different scenarios), supermarkets charging less, more money for and availability of alternative forms of entertainment, more awareness of the detrimental health effects…

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *avexxMan
over a year ago

cheshire

its such a shame art of chatting to each other face to face pubs will be missed badly

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ove2pleaseseukMan
over a year ago

Hastings


"its such a shame art of chatting to each other face to face pubs will be missed badly"

So how often do you go to a pub use it or lose it.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *alandNitaCouple
over a year ago

Scunthorpe


"There's a lot on this thread about how much drinkers cost the NHS... that might be a fair point, but I wonder if the maths stacks up.

I like a good pub, but I suppose I could die early because of it.

Realistically, there's very few alcoholics in pubs. You need would to be a millionaire to fuel an addiction in a pub.

I would personally like to see a return to pubs, restaurants and "off licenses" being the only places you can buy alcohol. Off licenses should also have limited opening hours and restricted "pack sizes"... no "crates of beer".

I'd also make tobacco products only available through a dedicated tobacconist! But that's a different subject all together (obviously )

Cal

Do you mean off license from a pub like it use to be or off licence like threshers a wine store.

To me an " off licence " is the part of the pub you got you beer from to drink off the licenced premises. As in off licence!"

From the Pub would be best, but actual Off License shops were a reasonable compromise.

Cal

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *octor ProdMan
over a year ago

working Overseas

Pubs died not because of the smoking ban (secondary smoke is a killer and the ban was needed), but because of a culture change; pubs core clientle stopped going to the pub every night

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"How many pubs have we lost since Tony Blair banned smoking Hospitality/Pubs got the rough end of covid.

A community hub lost

After a 20 year battle my local pub the ploughman has lost its battle with Tesco to turn the pub into a car park x"

Little to do with smoking, more to do with people's free choice to use supermarket and abide by drink driving laws.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *ove2pleaseseukMan
over a year ago

Hastings


"How many pubs have we lost since Tony Blair banned smoking Hospitality/Pubs got the rough end of covid.

A community hub lost

After a 20 year battle my local pub the ploughman has lost its battle with Tesco to turn the pub into a car park x

Little to do with smoking, more to do with people's free choice to use supermarket and abide by drink driving laws. "

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *obilebottomMan
over a year ago

All over

I will be sad to see them and other traditiomal stuff go. Some people call it change and progress. Personally I rather havr the mor traditional pubs that the souless, loud and full of d*unks bars sprouting up everywhere. There are very few places left to go like people used, meet friends or family for a nice quite drink or just to walk down to for a little drink begore walking back home.

Ps. Sad to see some of the antagonistic posts yet again. That sort of ping pong match seems to becoming a habit with some but each to their own. Perhaps they just like to have the last word, who knows.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"How many pubs have we lost since Tony Blair banned smoking Hospitality/Pubs got the rough end of covid.

A community hub lost

After a 20 year battle my local pub the ploughman has lost its battle with Tesco to turn the pub into a car park x"

As a non-smoker I’d rather have healthy lungs, clean smelling clothes, than be subjected to constant cigarette smoke indoors. I also don’t think the reason pubs are closing is because people can’t smoke indoors.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago


"Pubs died not because of the smoking ban (secondary smoke is a killer and the ban was needed), but because of a culture change; pubs core clientle stopped going to the pub every night"

Good, I don't want cancer because of someone's poor life choices

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"Pubs died not because of the smoking ban (secondary smoke is a killer and the ban was needed), but because of a culture change; pubs core clientle stopped going to the pub every night

Good, I don't want cancer because of someone's poor life choices"

I don't want pub staff to have to subject themselves to a higher risk of cancer either.

Drink driving - I'm sure it's saved lots of lives and prevented a whole bunch of harm. I can't be arsed looking up the statistics.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *atnip make me purrWoman
over a year ago

Reading

People voted with their feet. You can't force people to go to pubs. It's the same as a lot of high street shops. I am not sure that a place selling alcohol is the best focus of the community. Maybe we will become more of a cafe culture. I don't see this as a bad thing tbh.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *rHotNottsMan
over a year ago

Dubai & Nottingham

How many posts on Facebook and here every day basically saying ‘everything was better in the past , bring me my lard and coal’

Those places were evil full of dodgy geezerrs selling knock off meat and duty fee fags . The beer was flat and tasted of piss. The landlord was a fruit machine addicted alcoholic. A little nasty Scottish man was always ready to knife someone. Yeah the good old days

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"People voted with their feet. You can't force people to go to pubs. It's the same as a lot of high street shops. I am not sure that a place selling alcohol is the best focus of the community. Maybe we will become more of a cafe culture. I don't see this as a bad thing tbh."

I sympathise with small places needing a place to go - when I was in the northern islands of Scotland recently I noticed that a lot of the towns had community halls separate from pubs. I don't know who let those things lapse in other places, but they probably need to be brought back - a way to have a community space that isn't alcohol focused.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *achel SmythTV/TS
over a year ago

Farnborough

I am an ‘ex-smoker’, my last cigarette was on the 16th December 2006, ahead of the smoking ban coming in, in England in 2007. I had visited Scotland where the ban was already in place … and decided, I didn’t want to be one of those who had to go and stand outside to light up! … my father was also close to death, caused by smoking induced lung cancer - 2 fantastic incentives! … never touched one since, and now hate it!

I used to live in a village where there were 7 pubs … but now there is one! Habits have changed, but don’t think it is smoking related.

I went into my local a while ago, and noticed that they had stopped selling my favourite lager on draft, but were instead stocking bottles -they tried to tell me it was better value for money!!! I can buy said lager in the same bottle for £2 in the supermarket … that they were charging me £4.50 for … I do expect, and don’t mind a pub premium….. but that is taking the piss … before I go to the loo!!

R xx

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *obilebottomMan
over a year ago

All over


"How many posts on Facebook and here every day basically saying ‘everything was better in the past , bring me my lard and coal’

Those places were evil full of dodgy geezerrs selling knock off meat and duty fee fags . The beer was flat and tasted of piss. The landlord was a fruit machine addicted alcoholic. A little nasty Scottish man was always ready to knife someone. Yeah the good old days"

Wow! That's certainly not the places I would class a tradditional and quintessentially british pubs. The latter I would prefer them to stay as wpild like the nice independent little coffee bars and tea rooms to do so too. I certainly prefer to the new style loud bars and cafes. I don't understand why people focused on things like smoking and such like as most people would not want that anyway but they would want a local place to meet with neighbours and friends for a drink ( my parents went frequently, neither drank alcohol) or even a sing along and a little knees up.Nothing wrong with that in my opinion.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 

By *naswingdressWoman
over a year ago

Manchester (she/her)


"How many posts on Facebook and here every day basically saying ‘everything was better in the past , bring me my lard and coal’

Those places were evil full of dodgy geezerrs selling knock off meat and duty fee fags . The beer was flat and tasted of piss. The landlord was a fruit machine addicted alcoholic. A little nasty Scottish man was always ready to knife someone. Yeah the good old days

Wow! That's certainly not the places I would class a tradditional and quintessentially british pubs. The latter I would prefer them to stay as wpild like the nice independent little coffee bars and tea rooms to do so too. I certainly prefer to the new style loud bars and cafes. I don't understand why people focused on things like smoking and such like as most people would not want that anyway but they would want a local place to meet with neighbours and friends for a drink ( my parents went frequently, neither drank alcohol) or even a sing along and a little knees up.Nothing wrong with that in my opinion. "

I think the focus on alcohol is unhealthy, given all we know it can do.

Local place to meet, fine. Why does it have to be a pub, a place that is difficult to disentangle from alcohol? I don't like being around intoxicated people, some of them then drive anyway, etc.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
 
 

By *dy-ukTV/TS
over a year ago

Alcester

I think weatherspoons pushed for the smoking ban, and were the first to ban smoking in their pubs, before it became law.

Don't think I've ever seen a quiet weatherspoons either. Guess they're doing something right.

If pubs have to close, maybe look at the manager.

How the pub is run, the food menu, quality and prices of food, (people will pay higher money for top notch food, but many try to charge a premium for sub-standard food, customers only get burnt once!) entertainment nights, the range of drinks on offer and the prices. I've seen a few pubs change manager and go from 'deserted' to thriving family pub. I've sadly seen the opposite more often.

The smoking ban definitely is not too blame.

 (closed, thread got too big)

Reply privately
back to top